×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

HP 50g

HP 50g

(OP)
Does anyone use the new HP 50g calculator?  I am thinking about buying one, to replace my HP 33s with defective keys.  Specifically, do the keys get "jiggly" after one year of use, like on the HP 33s?

DaveAtkins

RE: HP 50g

I did have problems with keys in the early
designs where they used bubble membrane
technology to act as springs or contact
points.  My 11c has been going for 15 years
or more.

RE: HP 50g

DaveAtkins,

I am glad to here that I'm not the only one dealing with jiggly keys on the HP33s.  I attempted to dismantle and investigate the problem, but was unable to pull the face off.  I have determined that the keys are linked together in a grid with plastic ties between each key.  I guess my keystroke style has broken a few links, mainly the enter and number 1 key.

Have you mentioned this to HP yet?  I have been contemplating talking to them.  I rather like the calculator over my HP48GX just for its size.  I have had the HP48GX for over 10 years without problem.  The HP33s is new so hopefully they can modify the design to fix this problem.

RE: HP 50g

(OP)
I sent HP an e-mail about a year ago (I think), and they never responded.  Great customer service, no?  If it weren't for the fact that they are the only company that makes RPN calculators...

DaveAtkins

RE: HP 50g

dimjim - 11c's were one of the greatest calculators ever made in my opinion.  Wish they still made them.

RE: HP 50g

Maybe you should try a TI?  I mean; TI [ENTER] try a [ENTER] maybe you should [ENTER]

Just kidding!  I love the old HP vs TI argument. :) I say whatever works best for you is the best calculator.

Anyway, my boss had his old HP repaired.  I think he found a company on www.hpmuseum.org/repair.htm

RE: HP 50g

I am on my third HP 33s in two years.  First two had the same problem.  Broken (jiggly) decimal or enter key.  I am also looking at the 50 and was wondering the same thing about the keys.  I happen to really like the 33s, but I am getting tired of getting a new one every year because the buttons break.

RE: HP 50g

Before you buy, check out the price at the commercial link listed on www.hpcalc.org.  They give discounts.

As for key problems, it is the reason I've stayed with my old 48GX.  The 49G and 49G+ just didn't cut it and they are now collecting dust in my drawer.  Can anyone compare the keys on the 49G, 49G+, 33S and 50G?  Have they improved appreciably?  

I just can't believe that they went away from the fantastic keys they had on the 11C, 41CV, and 48 series.  You've already heard from the 11C guys - my 48GX was purchased in 1993 and looks terrible considering how many times it's been dropped and banged up.  It has never let me down and the keys feel just as tight as the brand new 48G backup machine I bought off of Ebay a couple of years back.



If you "heard" it on the internet, it's guilty until proven innocent. - DCS

RE: HP 50g

Have an HP15c thats still my everday calculator after 24 years.

They don't make them like that anymore!

RE: HP 50g

I've read great reviews about the 50's keyboard feel.

On a side issue, I bought a 33 to go along with my 48G and am extremely disappointed in it.  The keys are too hard and that 4 register stack is retarded.  I'm used to punching equations from left to right, regardless of size and this is simply not possible with 4 registers.

I'm planning to buy a 50 when I can come up with an adequate excuse.

RE: HP 50g

271828 -

Some excuses for you:

1.  The HP50g better matches the color of my eyes (my pupils actually).
2.  I can use RPN, Textbook, or Agebraic entry depending on whether I'm a) calculating by myself, b) showing off to my kids, or c) explaining something to an Architect.
3.  The dog ate my 33.
4.  I can write the expense of the 50g off....I think.
5.  Oops...I accidentally dropped my 33 out the window on the freeway.
6.  I'm getting cross-eyed using the 33 with its "V" shaped key layout.  Can't loose my eyesight now can I.
7.  It's rumoured that the latest building codes do not accept use of the 33 in design calculations.
8.  The 33 doesn't do 3D and everyone in the country knows that BIM and 3D are coming.


RE: HP 50g

LOL. I like 7 and the last part of 2 the best!

RE: HP 50g

Apparantly the 50G is what the 49G should have been. The keys are supposedly much better. I have yet to hear of anyone who didnt hate the 49G keys.

RE: HP 50g

apparently i'm still the only engineer in the world who uses a TI.

well, geez...now i feel inferior.

LOL



RE: HP 50g

swivel63 - you're the greatest.






(just trying to help)thumbsup2

RE: HP 50g

LOLOL, i just gave you a gold star for that "valuable post"



RE: HP 50g

swivel, don't feel bad.  I taught a design class last semester with 37 students and NOT ONE student had anything other than a TI.

I made fun of their calculator skills because I gave them a fairly long equation on an exam and about 5 of them made it from one end to the other without catastrophe!

RE: HP 50g

I currently use a TI-89. Having the 30 previous entries is very useful. The screen has a nice resolution too.

I am thinking about getting an HP 50G because I lost my old HP 48.

RE: HP 50g

for the PE exam in october i had to get used to the TI30.  i could have basically used my cell phone for that exam, lol.

RE: HP 50g

My son had an older HP and spilled coffee on it.  Since what he had was discontinued he decided to buy the latest and greatest (I forget the model numbers) but hated the newer model.  He ended up going on ebay to buy a used calculator like the original one he had.  He likes this calculator so much he is actually thinking about buying another one on ebay so he has a backup.

I think HP went through quality problems back during the Carly F. era.

-Mike

RE: HP 50g

DaveAtkins,
I spoke with HP customer service yesterday, and they said issues with jiggly keys has never been reported.  So I guess they didn't get or trashed your email.  I'm back using my trusty HP48GX for now.  I looked on ebay for the 32sII.  I like the traditional look better, so I might buy one.  

hpmuseam.com has a link to a repair shop, but I believe a new 33s would be cheaper than repairing the one you have.

RE: HP 50g

I have worn out about four 32SII.  Last time I purchased one I bought three of them.  I am on my second one and still have one spare.  

What I don't understand is why HP reduced the quality.  I've used both TI's and HP's and believe for engineering work there is nothing better than RPN.  I am sure there are lots of engineers like myself who would still pay $300 to $400 for a quality calculator.  

RE: HP 50g

No cell phones in the exam room swivel63 :)

I use a TI as well...

RE: HP 50g


HAVE MY 41CV THAT I BOUGHT BACK IN 1982 OR 1983 AND IT IS STILL CHUGGING ALONG FINE.  HAVE THE STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS MODULE AND THE CARD READER ATTACHMENT - THE CARD READER ATTACHMENT HAS LONG SINCE BIT THE BULLET BUT I STILL USE THE ANALYSIS MODULE ON A REGULAR BASIS. HAD SEVERAL KEYS GO OUT ABOUT 7 OR 8 YEARS AGO, SENT IT BACK TO HP AND THEY FIXED IT LIKE NEW.  SPILLED A COKE ON THE KEY BOARD ABOUT A YEAR AGO - CLEANED EVERYTHING WITH RUBBING ALCOHOL A COUPLE OF TIMES AND HAVE HAD NO PROBLEMS AT ALL WITH IT. IT APPEARS THAT THESE WERE BUILT TO LAST.

RE: HP 50g

LOL, so i guess i would have been SOL, then

RE: HP 50g

I also still use an HP 41CV with the Structural Module. Are there any new HP's, maybe the HP 50, for which preprogrammed structural modules or cards are available? I would think that after 25 years something newer and better would be available.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources