×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Condensing exhaust in engine

Condensing exhaust in engine

Condensing exhaust in engine

(OP)
We have a device that needs to water emitted in an exhaust stream of a diesel engine. that is about all I can say about it.

So I am basically looking to route the exhaust through a condenser, collect the water and let the remaining exhaust pass through.

There are some issues with this. First if I do it early enough in the pipe (i.e. before any catalytic converters or anything) the water will be quite acidic.

Second, I want to limit the number of components required to do this. So I am thinking of using the condensed water as the media to remove heat also. Basically, collect water in the bottom of something that would look like a sink trap (but not full, otherwise I add significant pressure drop to the exhaust stream), pump that water at say 10 psi through a radiator, and into a spray nozzle that throws the cooled water into the exhaust stream to collect even more water.  The pressure supplied by this pump would supply the water to other areas of the device also.

What do you think of this design? Is there something obivously better? Is it a dumb idea?

so my final questions are: how do I size the radiator and where to I get one? how do I size the flow rate for the cold water spray? I realize its about how much heat I want to remove in order to get the water to condense. but I am unsure of how to get at that.

Im a mechanical engineer who hates engines and thermo. mechatronics is my area. :)

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

Please re-write your first sentence.  I don't understand what you are trying to do to the exhaust gas.



Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

Is this a one-of? or a production requirement?

What kind of precision/accuracy are you trying to measure at?  How long do you have to collect the water?

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies


RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

(OP)
Mike,

sorry I left out a word and the sentence IS confusing.

We have a device that needs to use the water that comes out of the exhaust of a diesel engine. Basically I need to take the exhaust from the engine and condense it because I need that water. I will collect the water and let the gases pass through.

The two designs I can think of are to have a coil inside the exhaust stream, which I will run cold water through (it will be pumped through another radiator on the outside to cool down the water inside that loop. then I would collect the water from the exhaust that drips off the coils.

The other design I can think of is to spray cold water into the exhaust stream. This should pull some water out of the exhaust stream. Then I would collect the water I sprayed + what condensed, run that through a radiator and spray it again. This way I would accumulate water for the device.

I need to collect about 20 ml of water/minute.

So I dont know how big the radiator must be, I dont know how fast I need to pump water (either for spray or cooling coil).


I hope this was more clear.

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

(OP)
IR stuff,

for now I need to make 2 of these devices. Ultimately that device would be mass produced.

I need to condense 20ml/min or so (on the whole diesel makes about as much water as fuel it burns, so a kilogram of fuel makes about a kilogram of water). at 20 mpg, each mile should make about 160g (or ml) of water. Its ok to condense more than this rate, its not ok to condense less.

I hope this is clearer.

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

On a boat, it's common to inject water into to the exhaust, to cool the gas enough so that fiberglass mufflers won't melt.  I wouldn't add water to the gas stream on a road vehicle.

Cooling the exhaust gas to any extent will mess up the operation of any catalytic converters downstream, so your condenser should go after the cat.

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

(OP)
OK lets say I do that (condense water after the catalytic converter).

What do you think is a better design? spraying water into the exhaust stream, or running the exhaust by a cooling coil?

more importantly, how do I size these components? I dont know how to calculate the correct flow rate (for the spray or the cooling coil). I also dont know how to size the radiator that will be needed to cool the water before it enters the exhaust stream. Any ideas on how I go about this?

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

Yeah, about that; condensing and collecting water, then pumping and cooling it and injecting it to condense and collect more, in a sort of tail recursion.  Worrying about it has clouded your thinking.  Simplify your problem.


Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

There was a packaged unit call a REN Rainmaker made by Davco Ren.  Ren also made automatic oil level controllers for industrial engines.  It wouls use the air frfom the radiator to condense water.  We then would pump the water into the radiator in remote loactios (desert).

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

Spraying water into the gas stream, in an effort to condense more water from the stream, seems fruitless; you are just re-saturating the gas stream.  Condense the water on coils and collect the drops.

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

I think it would look great. Coonect a sink trap to the muffler, then attach  the trap to the radiator and spray a garden hose over it. Call over the neighbor and ask him what he thinks of it. Tell him you read about it in popular mechanics.

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

Sounds sort of like gas sample coolers.  A small can with a cooling coil in it.
Even if you do this after the cats, which you must, you will still need to use high alloy materials.

What is the relative humidity of exhaust gas?  How cold will your coils need to be in order to get condensation?
I would expect that a small 12V inline pump and a radiator about the size of a small car's with a single fan on it should cool you loop enough.

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Rust never sleeps
Neither should your protection
http://www.trent-tube.com/contact/Tech_Assist.cfm

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

Have you considered the volume that this would take?  I'm thinking that a couple of cubic feet are required for the exchanger with the exhaust and something comparable to an air conditioning compressor.

Seems somewhat Rube Goldberg-ish to collect barely 2.5 gallons of water per 8 hours of operation.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies


RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

(OP)
Thanks all.

To most of those comments. I'm not married to the water spray idea, it just removes one pump form the entire system. I dont understand why spraying COLD water into the exhaust stream would not condense out more water. but if it is coils, then coils it is.

IRstuff,
The reason I started posting here was to get some help on those exact issues. The water gets consumed as it is made, and if there is too much condensed I can reject it. But there must be a way to know how to size the condenser and the radiator, knowing the exhaust flow rate, and how much water I want to get out of the stream (21 ml/min).

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

I'm just saying that you're going to be carrying a lot more water to do the cooling than what you're asking for as a product.

And the water you do collect will be quite dirty, containing particulates as well as various acids.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies


RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

(OP)
no problem with the dirty water. Im not sure why I would be carrying so much extra water? Either by spray or by cooling loop, the only important water is that which goes through the loop. why would I need to carry extra (besides from dealing with expansion and leakage). Why would the volume of water other than what is in the radiator matter?

Are you saying the radiator would be so huge that I would be carrying a lot of water?

That is exactly the information I am looking for, how to size that radiator. I need to take 700 deg C vapor down to under 100C. how do I size the radiator and cooling loop?

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

Its a prepetual motion machine.  Spray in water to have it absorb 1000 btu/lb of heat plus oh 70 f to 1070 F of sensible heat of 500 BTU/lb all to cool some water and condense  total amount of energy is 1400 BTU/lb becasue you don't nee the water back at 70 F.  

OOP's what about all that CO2 and N2, rats there goes that cycle.....

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

(OP)
It cant be a perpetual motion machine. Are all these people promoting a perpetual motion machine?

http://www.iit.edu/~ipro304es02/Condenser1.html
http://www.valv.com/literature/documents/tbs-brochure.pdf
http://www.specialized-mechanical.com/products/bh_feedwater.html

Actually that IIT one is virtually identical to what I am proposing.

Here they run the process through pipes and spray water on the pipes
http://www.sandia.gov/energy-water/EastPresentations/WaterConserv.pdf

In terms of heat transfer, what is the difference if the exhaust is running in pipes or not? and as I said, I dont care about the dissolved CO2 and N2 and other crap in the water. So it doesnt look like I'm asking for the impossible.

regardless of spray method (which probably needs a very high flow rate) or running it through a coil, I still am asking forSo, I dont think it is perpetual motion. Particularly because work is being done collecting the condensate and pumping it through the radiator to cool it down. someone to help me understand how I size the coils and radiator.

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

You write out the heat balance and follow the enthaphies, including the energy it takes to vaporize the subcooled water that will condense and then that energy will be transfered to the water in the exhaust to condense it.  You can make the energy balance by putting enough energy into the pumps and fans to make it work, so you will trade off energy levels in favor of making water.

The rainmaker uses the hot air from the radiator fan, no extra energy added to the system and free water.

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

If you're going to spray water on the exhaust stream to collect water, how will you separate the collected water from the cooling water?

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies


RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

(OP)
I dont need to separate them per se. The spray water and the condensed water will end up in the same reservoir. This reservior will be hot water. I will pump out of that reservior to supply water through a radiator to the sprayer. The extra water will be used for what I need and if there is too much it will be dumped.

After a lot of poking around I found out that this method of condensing water is called a "direct contact condenser" and is one of the most efficient methods of condensing water out of a vapor stream. Most applications dont have the cooling fluid being the same as the condensing fluid so this method would be inappropriate. but for my case it will be very effective.

now if someone could help me figure out how big the radiator needs to be, and what the pump rate should be, that would be great.

Or forgetting that method, and lets just say i have a heat pipe with a heat sink on the inside of the vapor stream and a heatsink outside. How big do they have to be?

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

With a 1000 HP engine burning pure methane, you could circulate 300 gallons/minute of 80F water with a 7.5HP pump (up 50 feet) and recover a net 1 gpm of water.  The exhaust and water would be at 96 F, so you would need a huge tank or someway to cool the 96F water to 80 F to start the process over.  Now what?

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

Install an air conditioner compressor on the engine.  Locate the evaporator coil to a wide spot in the exhaust line. Collect drips to a P-trap branch off of the exhaust pipe.  This will recover some of the water.  

Will also require frequent cleaning and replacing of the coil.

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

(OP)
rzrbk,


yes  that is something like what I was thinking (for a non-direct contact version), but I am asking about sizing that sort of a system. how much surface area would I need. how big does the AC radiator need to be?

dcasto,

how did you come up with those numbers? I guess I am trying to understand the set of equations that get you there. Obviously if I need 300 gallons to do this, that wont work for me. But I dont need to extract ALL the water, just about 25ml/min (you are saying that all that will only extract 1ml/min, this can not be right, I've seen that rate come out the tailpipe of my car without any heat exchange).

The exhaust stream is about 11% by mole of H2O, it is also between 250 and 700 deg C. I do not know if this exhaust stream is saturated with water as I can not find a calculator or pyschrometric chart that goes that high in temp. It seems that getting the water down to 96F will take out most of the the water out of the stream (I think maximum water content of a 100 degree vapor stream is about 4 or 5% by mole). the water content of the stream is approximately 160 ml/minute (at cruising speed), I dont need that much.

I may be barking up the wrong tree, but it seems this has been done before, I just dont know how.
http://www.popsci.com/popsci/technology/generaltechnology/e05a7178706d8010vgnvcm1000004eecbccdrcrd.html
http://edition.cnn.com/2003/TECH/10/01/wow.tech.exhaust.water/index.html

Yes they talk about a refrigerated 'blanket' around the tail pipe, but how big is the refrigeration unit?

They also talk about a shell and tube design. This leads me to beleive that this can be done pretty compactly with the spray method which is more efficient.

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

Why not just make up a drained jacketed pipe of arbitrary dimensions (e.g. whatever will fit), cool it with _something_, e.g. engine coolant, and measure what comes out of the drain?  Most any marine exhaust manufacturer can make you a nice one out of 316L pretty quick.



Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

(OP)
I may end up doing that. I was just hoping to calculate _something_ to get within range of the right amount of water extraction (if I get out 5ml/min or 50 i would be happy). I really dislike going into a design arbitrarily, I find it wastes a lot of time.

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

I can give you one rough data point:

A DDC 16V4000 (~3650BHP, 48l, 2 turbos) typically uses a wye exhaust collector/riser.  The branches are 12" diameter, one elbow and 1.5 ft of tube, and the run is 18" diameter about 2 feet long.  The total length of interest would be about 4 feet.  

When such a riser is jacketed, and the jacket is cooled with winter North Sea water that has gone through the engine's heat exchanger once (maybe 40F at most), I have one report of condensate flow of 5gpm, I'm guessing with the engine running at ~1000HP or so on just one turbo.  I estimate that engine's riser had a surface area of 18 square feet condensing at the time.

The gas flow will not cause condensed water to flow uphill away from the engine, so jacketed risers require full time drains at the turbo flanges.  You will of course want to slope your pipe so the water runs away from the turbo and cat.  

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Condensing exhaust in engine

(OP)
Thanks. I'll start with some scale of that!

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources