×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?
2

Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

(OP)

I am a mechanical engineer at a large petrocehemical complex in Turkey. We are located on the seaside and we have decided to feed our fire water pipeline with sea water during an emergency such as lack of fresh water or very low fresh water pressure. In the project the suction line from sea to the main collector (serving three centrifugal pumps) is about 50m long. What kind of material is appropriate for the suction line? It will be full of sea water at all times. Is 316L OK? We do not want to have corrosion problem in the near future.

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

What about cement lined CS pipe?  We used that for our SW firewater systems on offshore platforms for the larger piping.  For the smaller piping, we used some much more exotic alloy, a monel alloy if I remember correctly but that was 10+ years ago.

With 316L, my first question would be wrt stress corrosion cracking due to the chlorides in sea water.

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

In case metal pipe system required, 316L is NOT suitable specially in case of emergency operated system. Metals such as 254 SMO or 904L should be used.

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

Suggest you use ABS as there are many locations in Australia & SE Asia where this material is used. Checkout www.eurapipe.com.au. The company is owned by Tyco and is represented throughout the world. Pipe is avaliable up to 1000mm diameter.

I have installed many systems for use on sea water, sewage sludge, potable water etc.

No fear of stress corrosion cracking

Standards are available from www.standards.com.au. Look for AS 3518 & AS 3690. Check out the drafts as AS 3518 is under revision and you may be able to download for free.

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

for above ground application.
CS pipe EFW cement lined, coated and wrapped to awwa spec. downside is the maintenance. if the mortar lining comes loose then you will start seing and repairing leaks. at the valve-to-pipe joint, you will also expreince some flaking of the mortar lining requiring another repair/replacement. note that once you losse the cement lining its an uphill battle to just keep on monitoring the line and fixing it. OK in your case since lenght is only 50 m.

between 4-36 NPS we have started using CS pipe lined with fiberglass (glass flake such as those made by Jotun) reinforced vinyl ester resin. for the small branch connection, we have selected B43 brass annealed (too small to lined properly). so far the result is better thatn the cement lined cs pipe.

fiberglass. we have consider it (lcc is really very attractive) but decided againts it. reason - if it breaks, reparing the line is a struggle especially in a very tight area (ive been into one inside the valve pit wiht sea water ozzing out like a fountain).

ss pipe. some says that scc is a concern. well for scc to occur three things must be present - residual stress, excessive amount of chloride (well for seawater of course it must be excessive)and temperature (most of the documented failure related to scc has these properties). mode of failure is leak. there is no weld repair. either you shutdwon the system to repalce your spool or you install a clamp and assess the risk. beside its costly.

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

Stainless steel is not recommend for Seawater.You can use Fiberglass Reinforced Pies(GRP or RTRP).As an inert material ,fibergalss composite pipes have excellent anticorrosive properties.Seawater, chemicals, soil and atmospheric environments typical in severe corrosion within a short period of time.I've been good experience with GRP lines for seawater service in South Pars Gas Field (Iran)

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

As the above engineer say,316 is not suitable for chlorides sea water,it will made your pipe stress corrosion cracking. In our company we customerly use 402 or 921. 902 is also ok,and the price is lower than the others.

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

In the North Sea offshore industry it is quite common to use 6MO stainless steels for Seawater service (wet firewater systems and water injection). Sometimes also titanium is used.

Some (10 or more) years ago Cunifer piping (=Cupro-Nickel) was the standard material for seawater, but nobody uses this anymore due to fabrication, installation and mechanical strength problems I think.

GRP is also used for seawater but normally only for "non-critical" systems, i.e. systems that is not required to work in case of emergency.

Maybe though for a large diameter onshore header it it is acceptable, and cheaper to use one of the other suggestions above.

Try the site www.steel.sandvik.com/
or www.avestasheffield.com/steel_grades.asp
They have specs for SMO254


regards
Mogens

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

(OP)
This will be 24" in diameter. Have you experienced  'Ductile Iron with coating'? Would that be acceptable for this service? What kind of coating is appropriate?

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?


 most common for seawater are ,,,FRP'S or C.S.cement lined

 FRP'S potential problems are breakage...

 cement lined c.s problems are when lining is gone...

 a decision i beleive should be based on how good u will design and engineer any of the two options...

 316 L ( known limit for the clorides part is 50 ppm )  ? seawater (thousands of chlorides ) ppms ?! no way !

 cheers

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

(OP)

For more responses to the same question, please see the following forum.

Materials Engineers Area - Corrosion engineering Forum

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

I recommend GRP only for non-critical low risk installations. It easily breaks and is costly to repair. If you have a budget (or a long term installation) go for SS or epoxy coated ductile iron.

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

What are the methods availabe for cleaning the sea water intake pipe to get rid of any settlements clogging up the pipe or any living organisms that might gone into the pipe by chance?

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

Try Zeron 100 Super Duplex Stainless steel. This should be suitable for your application. Available from Weir Materials.

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

For your valves, go to www.pureflex.com Series 800, composite butterfly valve.

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

(OP)
George,
That is really an important issue if you are taking the water directly from the sea, lake etc. It is apparent that there will be clams and other settlements at the pipe intake. We think about using a self cleaning filter at the pipe intake. Lakos has such a filter up to 460m3/h for sea, lake and spring suctions. One idea was to keep the pipe out of the water at idle times with some kind of lever system which may not sound very practical..At the moment we do not have a clear solution. I will appreciate any idea on this matter..

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

In the North Sea, Shell still use CuNi for Seawater systems. Another alternative is to use GRP

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

Dear Mufasa,

Just for your reference, In our power plant practise, we use GRP pipe for seawater intake DN2500 (undersea & underground). For aboveground, we use A53-B with rubberlinned. Rubber linning is an good option for seawater.  


Regards
Kent

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

In one of the ammenity centre pipe 316L is leaking which is given for firefighting purpose.Can somebody suggest some material or other way like filling that portion with fresh water. Underground pipe is of GRP.Firewater pump discharge is of Duplex Stainless steel
Thanks
SA

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

steel pipe cement mortar lined is suitable ,internationally accepted ,used and approved .....rgds TC

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

Mufasa:
Consider polypropalene. Sea life does not grow on poly. This would solve the clam problem. Also it high density poly is strong and would not be easily damaged.

Cement pipe using type V cement is very good for sea water but it is good at growing sea life such as clams, etc. If this is use it could be treated with chlorine. A chlorine solution can be derived from sea water with electrolysis. After about 8 hours it reverts back to sea water with no long term effects. Injection of this chlorine solution in the intake would keep sea life out.

Hope some of these suggestions help!

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

DLANDISSR,  I think you mean "polypropylene" pipe.  

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

AT OUR FACILITY IN THE COAST OF CHILE, WE USE SEA WATER FOR THE FIRE AND COOLING SYTEM, FOR THAT PURPOSE WE USE A 16" DIAMETER FRP PIPE, WITH A LENGTH OF 3.5 KMS AND A SURGE SUPRESSER TANK AT BOTH ENDS, THIS IS TO PREVENT A SHOCK WAVE THAT CAN DESTROY THE FRP PIPE.

RE: Sea Water Service Pipeline, 316L?

Interesting. The replies of the experts indicate that for sea water carbon steel or lined carbon steel, stainless steel, FRP, PP, superaustenitic stainless steels, cupronickels  etc are all used at one or the other place. Who says that SS 316 or 316L is not used in sea water service. All RO Plants will give the testimony of such commercial usage. Problems may come if the water is hot , temp more than 60-70 deg C, then SCC , cracking, heavy pittins start.
I have a write up which i preapared for a seawater using chemical manufacturing company indicating the host of materials suitable for the service ant their priorities in selection due to varied reasons. i may share it if one wishes. No hold from my side. This can be emailed as MS Word doc file.

Narendra K. Roy
Gramya Research Analysis Institute,
PO box 4016, Vadodara 390015, India
Website: www.gramya.com ; www.charismaglobal.com

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources