×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Just grumbling...

Just grumbling...

Just grumbling...

(OP)
Getting ready to remodel major portions of the significant other's house, which means messing around in the breaker box.  As an electrical engineer I'm fully aware of electrical safety practices, but that also means I'm very nervous about approaching the box because I know what can go wrong (been shocked too many times building high-voltage circuits as a young'un, but they were obviously low current).  The house was built the early 70's, and everything looks copper (thankfully).  There doesn't appear to be a main breaker in the box, so I'm hoping there's a cut-off on the meter (I'd feel much safer doing that anyway).  I'll be doing a lot of work on and off, so I don't want to call the power company each time to shut it all down.

The first change is to move the water heater downstairs, but I'll also be debugging a nagging problem... the power to the bathroom goes out about once a month.  With no warning, the lights fail to come on and the outlet attached to the same box supplies no power, and power is restored in the same manner by next morning.  It happened two nights ago and the meter shows no power being supplied to the switch, so I'm thinking it's in the breaker box (loose terminal screw?).  I don't smell/see any arcing or burning in the switch/outlet box.  I love the puzzle, but hate that it's on a high-voltage/current circuit :(

Just wanted to grumble about having to do it, maybe get a few "I was once nervous, too" stories added in.  Now that I think about it, some self-learned safety tips would be good to add here, too (maybe easy ways to block off live bus bars while working in the breaker box, etc.).

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Just grumbling...

Turn on everything in the bathroom.

Point an infrared thermometer at the breaker terminals, and look for a hot one.

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Just grumbling...

Look for a GFI on the same circuit (we have one in the garage that is inexplicably connected to the laundry room outlets as well).

RE: Just grumbling...

(OP)
btrue, There are zero GFCI circuits (or breakers) in the house, something I will be slowly remedying as I redo each portion.  The kitchen comes first, the bathroom will be the third (second being putting in another bathroom in the basement).




Mike, If I can find an IR thermometer here at work I'll try it, but I did not feel any hot breakers when it happened a few nights ago.  Shall I assume a hot breaker designates one that needs to be replaced?  I know the circuit can get hot if there is arcing.  I can run a 1900W hairdryer on high for 10 minutes with the lights on (fluorescents) and see no issue... two days later, flick the light switch in the middle of the day and nothing.

Now, an interesting tidbit of info which I just remembered... my SO says she replaced the four incandescent bulbs in the light fixture with two fluorescent months back and that seemed to mitigate the problem.  How true that is I do not know (it happens so infrequently, it's difficult to tell if anything has an effect), but I will quiz her on it some more this evening.

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Just grumbling...

Just take your VOM meter and measure @ the breaker when problem is occurring.  If 120ac is present then check @ the switch.  Could be bad or dirty switch.

RE: Just grumbling...

I'd be less concerned about a warm breaker than a warm terminal.

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Just grumbling...

(OP)
jde, That brings me back to my original grumbling point, and that's taking the cover off of the breaker box.  It may seem silly to people who do it all of the time, but after popping myself several times in years past with workbench projects, moving to high-powered stuff gives me the willies... but I'll be biting the bullet soon and doing it.

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Just grumbling...

Check it at the switch if you do not want to remove the cover of breaker box. Just be careful when pulling it out.

RE: Just grumbling...

Since for your bathroom problem you have both an outlet box and a light, I would check the wiring at these points. Inexpensive outlets and switches may have push-in wire-captures and not screw terminals. Power is daisy-chained from one outlet to the next. These can be intermittent killing everything downstream. Also check the outlet for an incompletely stripped wire where the insulation is under the screw head - also a possible intermittent.

Circuit breakers do go bad with age, and I've had to replace some in houses I've owned. The usual symptom is tripping, or lights that flicker - both indicate the breaker is heating from internal resistance. If your bathroom has a ceiling heater on the same circuit, this can pull enough current to weaken the breaker over time.

RE: Just grumbling...

I'm with Comcokid..

 The daisy chaining between outlets/fixtures is a really common place for this nonsense to happen. I'd say 90% of the time this is The Problem.  It can be very serious too!  As it means an undesired resistance in a place that shouldn't have multihundred degree temperature rises.  I've had four cases in this house over 35 years.  Half of them blinkers and half of them smells.  In one case a metal switch cover turned out to be too hot to touch!  I'm glad that it wasn't a plastic cover as it wouldn't have been dumping a 100W of heat out of the problem area.  That was discovered as a "what's that smell?!?!?" as we walked in from a family outing.


Quit sweating the breaker box stuff!  It's easy. If you understand everything, as I'm sure you do.  The key is you turn the breaker of interest OFF and then just unplug it.  Do all the work you need to, replacing it etc.  Make sure it's OFF plug it back in.  Then turn it on.  You aren't working on anything live.  How is this different from unplugging a lamp to repair?!  It isn't.

  The largest problem is if you bring wires into the box.  You must be careful to not let them wander about as they can hit the buses or the other breaker screws etc.  Try to always run new wire from say, a roll on the ground up to the breaker box, thru the conduit or knockout to the point of use.  That way only fully insulated wire is running thru the breaker box and you're never shoving wires into the box from somewhere.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Just grumbling...

I would start with checking the splices in the boxes and looking to see if they did daisy chain thru the receptacles.

While 99% of all house power electrical contractors love do daisy chain thru devices cause it cheap easy and fast, pay close attention to the neutral!! That is where the problem usually hides in a bad or loose connection / splice, ene under wires nuts being loose and wires not tightly twisted together.

If the house was built in the 70's it was before the code required the use of GFI in bathroom and kitchen and the problem could even be outside the bathroom area. Would recommend that you turn the breaker off for the bathroom and check to see what else goes off with it.


Hope it helps you some,

Roger
Master Electrician

RE: Just grumbling...

Yep,
I agree with smoked and comcokid.
I had a problem at my friends farm in the attic like smoked said. Garbage wiring. Had a hot switch problem in my own house.

If you contact your electrical company and tell them what you want to do, they may let you pull the main meter outside. This WILL shut your box down. However, the meter box usually has a one use only tag thru the locking lever. If you remove this w/o contacting your service provider, they may decide to investigate you. Oh, FYI, do not put the kwh meter back in upside down or it will run backwards! This will GREATLY increase the chance that your local provider may wish to speak to you. :)
If you go insde the meter box, BE CAREFUL, this has the capability of big current! I believe they fuse the local transformers, I dont know. But by the time that blows, a person would just be a puff of smoke and a memory. Please be careful.

Oh, be safe, still check your box with a meter!

Have fun,
Scott

In a hundred years, it isn't going to matter anyway.

RE: Just grumbling...

An unintentionally disconnected neutral can cause a meter to read zero (H-N) even when it's all hot. Keep your wits about you.

Once upon a time I had a reason to make sure that the large allen keys that clamp the 200A wires into the panel were tight (confirm they're tight while live). I used an insulated surface to stand on, clean rubber boots, rubber electrician gloves, tool with an insulated handle, and some quick touches just to make sure. It apparently worked out okay...

RE: Just grumbling...

Tsk tsk tsk... not supposed to post residential Qs here, but you get a pass for being a regular I suppose.

My house (cir. 1971) has no main CB in the load center either, it's outside below the meter socket. No problem with that as long as you know where to go find it in an emergency. It was an "experiment" in the 70s based on the idea that the Fire Dept. could shut down power to your house before entering. Turned out not to matter that much one way or the other; if it was an electrical fire and the fire dept. was already there, the fire must have already started anyway!  

Tip;
While it is still working OK, find out which breaker it is by plugging a radio into the circuit and playing it real loud while flipping breakers until the radio goes off. NOTE: may cause you to need to reset your TV station choices and clocks everywhere! Once the circuit is identified, try to also identify all other sockets and light circuits tied to it by plugging in the radio with only that circuit breaker off. No radio = common circuit. To test light sockets, turn every light on in the house before flipping that breaker off, no light = common circuit. Make yourself a map.

Then next time it fails, start at the breaker with a meter to see if you have voltage there. If you do, there is a loose connection downstream from there somewhere. Starting at the closest identified outlet of light switch / fixture, keep testing to see if one of the hot wires is still hot. Work your way towards the farthest identified fixture, thinking like you were the guy having to pull that wire, i.e. the shortest route possible if the walls were still open. IMPORTANT: test by going Hot to Ground, not hot to neutral (explained later). If you have plastic boxes and/or no ground wires (although you should have had a ground wire in the 70s), then get a long length of wire connected at one end to a water pipe. If you get to a box and the hot is dead, the loose connection may be there or in the previous box.

If you get to the end and they all are hot, then you have a lose neutral somewhere. This is actually very common for your symptom by the way, because if it were a loose hot wire you would likely hear sparking sounds or smell smoke. Start the process over but go Hot to neutral until you find a dead circuit. make sure you don't touch the ground and neutral together when doing this check or you may get a false positive.

If any of that makes you uncomfortable or if that doesn't find it, call an electrician. He will have tools to do this faster, but those tools are typically too expensive for occasional use. Don't leave it be, this is potentially life threatening!

RE: Just grumbling...

Do you have a recessed lighting in the bathroom? They collect moisture from the shower and don't dry out. Since they are not in direct contact to the moisture the problems are delayed and so are the fantem self fixes. Bathroom recessed fixtures have a seal which degrades. When the seal leaks, well we all know what steam can do to connections. especially wire nuts. Good luck.

RE: Just grumbling...

(OP)
poo, no recessed lighting.


j, Thanks for the tips.  I started the post more as a place to simply grumble about having to go into the box, maybe read a few first-timer stories and safety tips, but as the posts went on it turned into more of a troubleshooting session for one problem I ran into.




The power was lost again last night, but I had already taken my meter home, so I couldn't check anything.  I also learned the switch is a three-way with the mating switch hiding behind the bathroom door (gotta love those 70's architects!).  I plan on checking this one, too, the next time it happens.  We're taking a trip to Home Depot tonight, so I'll pick up some new switches and a GFCI socket... it certainly can't hurt to replace them, and she definitely needs a GFCI socket in there.

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Just grumbling...

Check the 3-way behind the door.  If it is slightly out of position it will create an open.  If it is open, you get what you have described.  Flip that unused switch back and forth several times to clean the contacts.  See if that doesn't clear things up.

RE: Just grumbling...

Another option is to hire an electrician and let him grumble about it while you sit in front of your PC with a beer.  He will also have to take any blame should something go wrong with other wiring in your significant other's house.

RE: Just grumbling...

(OP)
I've already started on the plumbing, going to rough it all in before I cut into the existing pipes.  I'll do the same for the electrical, get it all ready with the wire leading up to the breaker box... that way the box is only open for an hour or so and everything is good to go.

I'm surprised no one had any horror stories to share...

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Just grumbling...

You want horror stories I got one.
My buddy's house is 13 years old, 2600sqft, two story.

He requested that the plumber use heavy wall copper pipe. (M?) (L?)(I forget).   Anyway nine years after the build the valve for an upstairs toilet starts leaking.. Bad enough that it drops the garage ceiling.  Calls the contractor and asks where's that plumber?!?!?  "He left the state a few years ago."(brother-in-law) I'll come fix it. He does.

10 years, one month later the hot exit pipe from the water heater starts leaking. He calls the contractor again.  Guy comes out and cuts out two sheet rock panels behind and above the water heater, fixes the leak.

A month later another fitting lets go flooding the dining room.  Calls the contractor. "10 year statute of limitations is over, sorry don't bother calling me anymore."    This requires wall repair and a plush carpet replacement.

Next his wife mentions that the hardwood kitchen floor seems oddly warm.  He's busy, doesn't check it out.  $400 water bill and $400 dollar gas bill arrive simultaneously.  Time to check things. A copper fitting in the hot water circuit with reduction and (4),(four),(IV), outlets has corroded thru and has almost a 1/4" hole in it directing the hot water at the kitchen floor.  HE must lay in a warm mud bog under the middle of his house and remove 8 inch insulation before locating and fixing that obtuse fitting and engineer a way to replace it in the center of the four lines coming from four directions.

Since this failure he has 11 more similar ones.

The plumbing contractor(dufus) failed to clean any of the flux off the lines so they are all corroding thru one at a time starting with the hot lines as the reaction rates are higher.

So, if you are using copper clean your flux off and flush your lines properly!!

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Just grumbling...

mac,

not a horror story, but it caught me by surprise: a 3-phase lighting system wired with standard (1 phase only, I thought) Romex wire (the kind with two solid, insulated wires and a third bare "ground" wire running in a rectangular jacket).  Third leg was on the bare wire.  Our "facilities" engineer in the plant told me that it was "to code".

RE: Just grumbling...

(OP)
I don't know 3-phase and even I know that can't be to code! winky smile



Keith, I'm using water-soluble flux, so after a few days/weeks worth of showers I imagine it should all be gone.

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Just grumbling...

I was adding a circuit to a fuse box after purchasing the house.  Removed the cover and found all the later upgraded wiring with grounds had all the grounds twisted together.  Not connected to ground, just twisted together!  In the basement there was a one foot section of pipe hanging in the air by just a wire and a ground clamp.  Clamp had a tag on it that said do not remove without calling telephone company.  Well, it wasn't removed when they cut the pipe out!

Another 1910 era house I bought had its  original fuse box with wire and tube wiring.  This had the returning neutral fused on each branch.   

RE: Just grumbling...

Hows this?  I was called to my brothers house after his TV,Stero,answering machine and computers power supplys smoked. When the microwave or the fridge or freezer turned on, half the lights in the house would go dim and the other half would go bright. When I put my meter acrossed both legs of the breaker box, I measured a consistant 220V no mater what. When I referenced neutral which was straped to ground I would get 110v with no load but when a high draw like the furnas blower turned on, one leg would go to 60v and the other leg would go to 160v. The neutral wire coming from the pole had broke stopping the transformer from balancing the load. I scratched my head for two hours. After the Detroit Edision told me I was full of crap they fixed it the next day.

RE: Just grumbling...

(OP)
Opera, While prepping for all of this I noticed a copper pipe that came from upstairs near the water heater and ended in the main drain in the basement.  For no particular reason I tried to shake it, and much to my surprise it actually moved... a LOT!  After a few more minutes of crawling around I realized what had happened.  They replaced the heater a few years back but didn't reconnect the overpressure drain line (it was M-rated pipe).  Since the heater had been moved from its original location, the pipe didn't immediately strike me as belonging to it.  It had a couple of convoluted bends and other pipes were trapping it, but after a few twists of the cutter I was able to recover about 16' of pipe and connectors.  At least I'll be patching the floor in there.

Scares me to think what I'll find when I finally open the breaker box!

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Just grumbling...

All the above. Pulling the meter is the "Best Practice". If you must work live and a short circuit occurs you may not get zapped but sparks fly so protect your eyes! Always wear safety glasses!

RE: Just grumbling...

Dan water soluble is good.... but if you aren't wiping if off the outside of the fittings that just means atmospheric moisture will keep it "cleaning"... until, well, you get the point.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Just grumbling...

Well if plumbing horror stories are acceptable, I could go on for days. Condensed version of my biggest was that I bought a house in Seattle built in 1910, originally without indoor plumbing. Plumbing was added in the '20s by the original Rube Goldberg I think. Bizarre angles and combinations of fittings that made me assume they had to use whatever they could find at the store that day. All of it galvanized. When I bought the house, they had painted everything ion the basement white.

<<Note to self: never again ASS-U-Me that someone who paints everything in an area that didn't need painting was just a neat freak>>

Several years later, I noticed rust on the concrete floor of the basement, looked up and saw a drip mark coming from the (white) pipe. Long story short, all of the pipes were rusting through. Sent the wife and kids off on vacation for a week, ran new copper pipe everywhere. Being concerned for my young kids, I chose lead-free solder (before it was required). Ran the pipe, soldered all the joints, leaned back to admire my handiwork and flipped the lever on my globe valve (I spared no expense). Leaked like a fire sprinkler system! I hadn't had a shower in 4 days at that point, but that was not how I wanted to take one! Shut off the water, drained the pipes and started re-soldering the joints, ALL OF THEM! Turned the water back on, same thing, except worse now, plus the family was returning in 2 days. Went to the hardware store to get a recommendation for a plumber and to bitch about their silver solder. Picked up the container and saw, right on front in bold letters; "MUST USE SILVER SOLDER FLUX ONLY; DO NOT USE STANDARD FLUX". After some appropriate swearing and auto-glutial-podiatric punishment, I disassembled the entire system, melted and wire-brushed off the old solder on every joint, applied the proper flux, reassembled and re-soldered the whole house plumbing in 20 hours non-stop. Took a nice long shower and slept for about 12 more hours until the family returned.

RE: Just grumbling...

I feel for you jraef. haha..
But only so much, because I had to lay in the dirt under my house to redo all mine.

Why would you leave Seattle to move to CA??  Or don't you like big lahars?

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Just grumbling...

I've still got lead plumbing in bits of my house... gives the water that sweet taste. clown

RE: Just grumbling...

Keith,
I was born in CA, right in Bezerkely, so I was coming home. I liked it in Seattle, but my wife didn't. She was born in Minneapolis and worked hard to escape the snow by coming to CA on her own at age 18. 5 years after marrying me I moved her to Seattle and the first time it snowed, she made me promise to take her back to California. Took me 12 years to do it.

Ironically, the house I ended up buying here in CA has... you guessed it... GALVANIZED PIPE! I added on to the house after buying it and hired a plumber this time, he told me nobody used galvanized pipe in CA in 1971 when this house was built. Apparently I found the exception. Next year I'm having it redone by an outfit called Re-Pipe that specializes in doing the entire house in 2 days max., without opening up the walls. They quoted me $2400 for the whole shebang, money well worth it IMHO.

RE: Just grumbling...

I see - makes sense.

Last time I visited Seattle my young son decided to hit our host's son in the head with a hammer. (Experimentally)(once).. Luckily it was a small hammer.  I have rarely been more mortified. (Barely knew the people.)  They lived directly across the street from the water.  The next morning 2 ferries collided in front of their house.

Interesting place..

Thanks for the info.
I will forthwith relate that company to my buddy.  Maybe they will replace all his sieving for something reasonable.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources