×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Second engineering degree?

Second engineering degree?

Second engineering degree?

(OP)
Hello all.

I'm about to pick up a bachelor's degree in Nuclear Engineering.  I field that I am very interested in and would most probably enjoy working in.

The choice had always been between nuclear and electrical, and I had choosen nuclear because I thought it would make me stand out.

However I was forced to take an electrical course during my time here (just so I know the basics) and I loved it.  I went on to take the follow up of that course and another EE course (both of which were not required).

Now I really love EE.  The classes that I have taken I have really enjoyed.

I have a few questions to the engineers who would know:

- How would I benifit with a Nuclear engineering degree and an Electrical engineering degree?

- Would just any job say it would be okay to work and go to school.  Or go to work, take time off school, and then go to work? (For a degree that probably has nothing to do with them)

- Would it be easier and more benificial to get a masters in nuclear engineering while working?  (Many have suggested this)

- How are most companies about continuing your education?

I'm definetly willing (and used to) putting in the extra hours and effort to pull this off.

I'm thinking hard about this and would like any and all suggestions.

I will get this degree, sooner or later, so not doing it is not an option for me.

Thank you!

RE: Second engineering degree?

I'm not sure if you would benifit with a Nuclear engineering degree unless you had your PE.
But, I have very little experience in the nuclear field.

Chris
SolidWorks 07 2.2/PDMWorks 07
AutoCAD 06
ctopher's home (updated 03-13-07)

RE: Second engineering degree?

(OP)
From what people tell me, a nuclear engineering degree is good to have.

But I'm curious about having both.

RE: Second engineering degree?

I think any and all education is good to have.  I think most people will agree that they dabble in many different fields of engineering in their jobs.

If I could, I would definitely get an electrical engineering degree.  

RE: Second engineering degree?

(OP)
If you did though, how would it help you.

It may be true that you dabble with this and that but if something seriously needs to be done, they have electrical engineers for that.

How would it help me in: salary, job placement, advancement, things like this.

Would a job be readily okay, and willing to work with me, when I claim to want a EE, or would they say get lost.  I'm curious if anyone out there knows answers to these concerns.

RE: Second engineering degree?

Just get a graduate degree in EE.

RE: Second engineering degree?

Your questions depend on the job and the employer.  You would be suprised how many employers don't have qualified engineers in positions.

For example, I get a call from a the utilities engineer (mechanical) retired and rather than replace him, they moved an electrical engineer into his place.  He knows nothing about mechanical engineering but he is in charge of sizing cooling towers, HVAC systems, chillers, compressed air systems, boiler operation, etc.  If someone had been available who was an EE and ME, he would have likely gotten the promotion. Things like this happen all over.

I agree with COEngineer. Get a graduate degree in EE.  There is a demand out there for people with multiple degrees, that means better chance for higher salary, advancement, etc.

RE: Second engineering degree?

I would go straight through school and double major, I would not try to work full time and take night classes.  Once I had 2 degrees I would work 3-4 years in each field after researching what seemed to be jobs in demand AND ones that I would want to do.  It will be painful to start over again in the second field (financially).  However, you will now be skilled in two different fields and have greater opportunities.  I earned my bachelors in 1994 and spent 3-5 years doing 3 different types of jobs within my discipline.  To an extent I am a jack of all trades (and it has hurt financially to do this) but have a lot of flexibility in the job market.  If the economy makes a turn for the worse in one sector, I have 3X the number of jobs available compared to someone in my field who has done the same thing for 10+ years.

RE: Second engineering degree?

I think getting two BS degrees is a poor investment. Mostly your degree is teaching you how to learn - you shouldn't need to be taught that twice.

Cheers

Greg Locock

Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.

RE: Second engineering degree?

(OP)
GregLocock:

I can understand this and have been told this before.  Would you agree with the statement that getting a MS in electrical engineering would be a good investment?  Or is any education that deviates from my main one (nuclear) a poor investment?

Newfella:

Now that you have flexibility after all this time, I'm thinking to myself, to do this there must be opportunity costs.  If you had to do it all over again, would you do it the same way?

RE: Second engineering degree?

Go after a masters in E.E.  Of course, you'll have to choose a specific EE area.  I imagine some kind controls type EE master's would go well with a nuclear B.S.  And there's probably a market for it.

I think having more than one B.S. in Engineering is simply a waste of time/money.  

In a perfect world, I think the engineering world would be better served if Engineering diciplines were only choosen at a graduate level.  Opps, I'm getting off the OP subject. Sorry.





RE: Second engineering degree?

I'd have said a Masters in electrical engineering makes more sense than another Batchelors, yes.

Cheers

Greg Locock

Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.

RE: Second engineering degree?

I would echo that two bachelor's degrees will not be as beneficial to you in most jobs.  The flexibility that you get from NE and EE could be an asset, though.  Since you are getting a nuclear engineering degree, I'm going to assume that you want to work in the nuclear industry (power plant) or possibly for a national lab.  There is great need at nuclear power plants for engineers who are multi-talented, especially as we face a lot of retirements in the next 5-10 years.  However, you will not get much credit (salary and promotion-wise) for a second BS vs. a master's degree.  Most companies I have seen will give you 2 years of credit for a MS towards advancement where you get nothing for having a second BS.  Also, many companies will pay for all or part of a master's degree.  Add a PE license to that and you are in the drivers-seat for your career.  It is very hard to work full time and get a master's degree part time but that is the best way to do it, in my opinion, if you do not plan on going for the PhD.  Good luck and you made an excellent decision on the nuclear degree!  Hang on a few years and it will really pay off.
Jason

RE: Second engineering degree?

(OP)
Alright, this is what many had told me at the university but it's great to hear it from engineers on the field.

Only a few questions I had thought of are:

How exactly would I be able to jump from a BS in nuclear to a MS in electrical.  I don't expect anyone to know this but, I'm thinking out loud.

One thing that depresses me is that I'll miss all the fun 200-400 level classes in electrical.  I really do enjoy this stuff.

I guess years down the road, some get their corvettes, I'll just get my EE.

RE: Second engineering degree?

Well, you are not really going to miss out on all of those 200-400 level classes.  To go from a BS in Nuclear to a MS in Electrical, you will have to take several of the prerequisite classes required by the MS program.  If you can identify a master's program now and figure out what the prerequisites are, you can get those taken while you are still doing your undergrad work.  Depending on the field you want to go into, the prerequisites may be many or few.  Power, for example, would not take as many prerequisites as Instrumentation (how many and what will depend on your background now and the specific college).  

Also, if you play this right, you won't have to give up on your corvette to get your MSEE.  Just go to work for a company that will pay for it.  Good luck.
Jason

RE: Second engineering degree?

My favorite boss was a combined ME/EE. He could handle most challenges with confidence. He had bachelor degrees in both. The ME/EE combination is very complementary in that they address each others weaknesses.

To earn a BSEE would be straightforward; you already have a number of credits that would apply directly to the EE. If you insist on having a masters, get it in business or other related field.

RE: Second engineering degree?

You would never benefit from the second degree.

The cost of education and the loss of the 3 or 4 years salary would far outweigh any benefits.

If you are only part way through your course then you may be able to transfer over to electrical. I would advise this rather than 2 separate degrees.

RE: Second engineering degree?

If you were nearer the begining of your course I's ask why not just study electromechanical or mechatronics?  May be a bit late for you now.

RE: Second engineering degree?

The other option is to graduate as nuclear and try to get work more towards the electrical type. You may find that you can end up working as an electrical engineer with a nuclear engineering degree.

If this works out you may be able to do your masters in electrical after some years of experience. Talk to a university advisor about this.

RE: Second engineering degree?

(OP)
jpankask:  This sounds logical.  I must probably would go into power.  I want to go into power with my NE.  Now, I don't know the numbers for prereq into power but I do know that it'll take me 42 credit hours to complete a EE.  That makes 21 for two or 15-18 for three.  If the prereqs take maybe one or even two semesters to finish, I might as well go for it all, I guess.  But I don't know the hours for prereq into power.  Until I find out, this is cheep talk (type) from me.

csd72:  It would only take 1.5 years to finish.  However this in itself is a big opportunity cost. I want to work in the nuclear industry but I also love this electrical stuff.  Somehow someway I want to do both, at the same time.  Most probably impossible.  If anyone knows anything about this, please let me know.

KENAT:  Yeah, it's a little late, :)  I have all the credits I need to leave, but I'm here doing some elctrical classes.

RE: Second engineering degree?

MrNE,

I have a degree in nuclear engineering.  I don't know how yours was based but it required me to take senior level courses in power and instrumentation although my base discipline was mechanical.

Now I work as a design engineer for a utility.  I am responsible for process/instrumentation design.  I leave the power concepts to another for resource-sake.  I would say get your MScEE if you want to get into that work.  The pure nuclear engineers I work with stay in the reactor safety, fuel physics.....if you want to design the nuts and bolts you need a specialty to get the chance.

Good luck.

Frank "Grimey" Grimes
Rule 25. of Swanson's "Unwritten Rules of Management"
Have fun at what you do. It will reflect in your work. No one likes a grump except another grump.

RE: Second engineering degree?

MrNE, If you have all the credit you need to leave, I would start looking at nuclear power plants for an engineering position.  My BS was in Nuclear Engineering.  I took a job out of college with a manufacturing plant where I gained some electrical knowledge and then I got a job at a nuke plant in Electrical Systems.  You probably have all the electrical knowledge you need to get into an electrical systems job somewhere.  I loved working in electrical systems because you don't really need to know all the electrical theory you get from an EE degree to do well.  I think I said somewhere above, a lot of "electrical" components are really mechanical systems that do electrical jobs.  A generator is a huge mechanical system to generate an electric current.  Circuit breakers are very intricate mechanical devices to permit/stop the flow current, etc.  You may have to look to find a hiring electrical supervisor who can have some vision for the special knowledge you can bring to an electrical position, without a BSEE, but they are out there.  A second option would be take whatever position you can get (licensing or reactor engineering) with a company that pays tuition and start on your MSEE.  Then transfer to an electrical position when it comes up.

Also, 42 hours to complete a BSEE...do some online looking and find some MSEE programs.  They should have listed the types of prerequisites they require and if they don't call.  There is probably only 8-12 hours of classes you HAVE to have to start on the MSEE.  In the time it would take you to finish your BSEE, you could have the prerequisites and a MSEE, which will be much more worth your time than a second BS.  

Good luck.

RE: Second engineering degree?

There are earning's curves for all levels of education and time.  Earning increases are for higher levels of education not garnering multiple degrees at the same level.  Experience will increase your earnings to a point.  The old addage about 20 years of experience vs. one year repeated 20 times is very true.

I'd recommend what many others have, get your MSEE.  That will benefit you more immediately and in the long run.

I will also vote for obtaining the PE but for nuclear and EE.  A PE will open doors for you that otherwise will be shut.

I would also vote for going straight through school for the master's.  That is the voice of experience.  You'll gain a higher starting salary with your MSEE.

I do instrumentation and controls and love it.  It is a fascinating and ever changing field.  However, if you have your eyes on management, even project management, many companies will look over you in favor of a mechanical or civil engineer.  If you desire management eventually, I would suggest taking some business courses at some point and ensuring you gain experience in other areas of your company.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources