×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Asking how something can be improved...

Asking how something can be improved...

Asking how something can be improved...

(OP)
The quick question I have is, "How do you respond to the question HOW CAN THIS BE IMPROVED? if you were the one asking it initially and it is just fired back at you?"

Take care & have fun!

Kevin
"Hell, there are no rules here -- we're trying to accomplish something." - Thomas A. Edison

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

Everyone should be open to criticism.  In the engineering realm however, criticism should come with suggestions for an alternate solution.  Refrain from criticizing unless you have an alternative bouncing around in your head.

I would reply that I don't have the right answer now, but I'm sure if we find time to brainstorm some ideas offline, we'll find a solution as a group.

"Art without engineering is dreaming; Engineering without art is calculating."

Have you read FAQ731-376 to make the best use of Eng-Tips Forums?

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

We could improve it by making it better.

Charlie
www.facsco.com

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

"By "improve" do you mean make it better or make it cheaper?"

Regards,

Mike

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

Making it cheaper is improving it if the quality or performance is not adversely effected.

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

rcooper, true, I just meant we need to define the problem, as in everything else we do.

Regards,

Mike

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

Something they taught my kids in law school:

"Never ask a question to which you do not know the answer."


Seems appropriate here.


Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

Mike Halloran says, "Never ask a question to which you do not know the answer."

If that is the case I waste a hell of a lot of money employing accountants, solicitors and the like.

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

As with anything, you improve something with a systematic process.  And that starts with the question you asked  - how can it be improved.  

It depends on what the prodcut or process is.  Continuous improvement forces you to always be looking for ways to improve effeciency, lower costs, improve performance, etc.

The worst statement you can make is - "that's the way we've always done it".  There is not too much that can't be improved upon, you need experienced people to be involved and ask questions.

Greg Lamberson
Consultant - Upstream Energy
Website: www.oil-gas-consulting.com

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

"How do you respond to the question HOW CAN THIS BE IMPROVED? if you were the one asking it initially and it is just fired back at you?"

Good question KBeitel!!!!

You have split the question into two parts....

1. Personally, if you are working as an engineer (especially true for design engineers, slight bias here) then you should ask this question of every project/design/drawing in which you are involved. It is the basis of design. In design terms, there are many different aspects that you look at. Reduce part count, reduce cost, increase functionality, incorpoate new technology etc. All these are the foundations for 'HOW CAN THIS BE IMPROVED?'

2. If you are asked this question then as a design engineer, I would hope my response would be...'I have been looking at this problem and have come up with some proposals'. This is the ideal scenario, but a good fall back position is 'This looks similar to XXX that we looked at before, maybe we can adapt XXX for this situation.

Kevin Hammond

Mechanical Design Engineer
Derbyshire, UK
 

RE: Asking how something can be improved...


Mike Halloran says, "Never ask a question to which you do not know the answer."

Probably good for lawyers at the bar but no one else.

Not to pick on you Mr halloran, but my teacher used to say: "there are no stupid questions, there are only stupid people".

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

For figuring out how to improve something, look at how it can (or does) fail.  Not only from an engineering perspective, but from a user/sales/economics perspective.  A flawless product without a market is still a failure.

Praise be to the person who suffers through coming up with new designs and then puts them up for others (like me) to rip into them.  It is not an easy thing to do.  It is much easier to criticize than it is to create.

Regards,

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

Sorry, Atlas, you have to take a number to pick on me.  Your number is 92.  I am now serving number 4, but perhaps this will keep your mind occupied while you wait:

What do you suppose your teacher meant by that strange aphorism?  

1. That any person who would ask a question, was by dint therof, stupid?  And the corollary; that any person who suppressed a question, was therefore smart?

2. That all people are stupid?

3. That the particular respondent, e.g. me, was stupid?

..1.. is contrary to my experience.
..2.. may be true some of the time, but not all of the time.
..3.. see 2

To me, the aphorism suggests that the teacher used it as a way to keep the class quiet and shut down their creative development so they would listen complacently to yet more pseudobabble.  

Which I find disappointing, coming from someone whose job is nominally to reduce ignorance.

;--- back on point,

The Original Post, as posed, suggests that the protagonist engineer speaks first, asking a question, perhaps to no one, more likely to someone farther up the chain of command.

If you ask questions aloud of yourself, you may become a subject of discussion.  If you answer yourself, maybe you will merely be perceived as the weird engineer who thinks out loud.

If you ask the posted question of a peer, the response will probably be an answer, or a shrug.

If you ask the posted question of a person of superior rank, you have to understand that that person is probably not equipped to answer a technical question, is not willing to go out on a limb over a style question, is likely to interpret any open ended question as a polite way of leading up to a suggestion, and may have been specifically trained to deflect any question with a mirror response to gain time to think of an answer and consider its political consequences.

I.e., if you ask a question of anyone but a peer, and don't have a putative answer of your own ready, you will be perceived as ... well, being strange, or not being the sharpest knife in the drawer.  Since engineers are paid to be sharp, it could even be a career decision.

That's why I think the lawyers' aphorism is appropriate for engineers, too; certainly in the stated scenario.



Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

Thats easy...

Response is " I asked the question first you tell me HOW CAN THIS BE IMPROVED"

when its your turn the response is "Great answer"!

If you are forced to go first, your answer is "I don't know."

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

If I remember correctly, the socratic method of teaching involves reflecting your question back and making you rephrase it and narrow it down until you end up answering the question yourself. If you asked the question of a mentor or someone with more experience, they were probably trying to get you thinking about it for yourself instead of spoon-feeding the information.

What was the context of the question anyway? That would make it easier for us to give you a suitable answer...

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

Being in engineering, your answer should never be "I don't know."  It can be, "I don't know, but I'll find out." or  "I don't have enough data to give you an answer now."  We are supposed to know, or at least have the capability to find out.  If we didn’t have to know the answers or know where to find them, we'd all be meteorologists (the only job I know where you can be wrong more than right and still be employed). dazed

Usually when people ask "how" they are genuinely looking for a solution, since they don't have one.  In some instances it may be asked as a leading question for training/educational purposes.

As to the "there are no stupid questions, there are only stupid people" comment, I think that might be misquoted.  But the idea trying to be conveyed is that asking questions is the path to knowledge.  If you never ask questions, you will remain ignorant.

"Art without engineering is dreaming; Engineering without art is calculating."

Have you read FAQ731-376 to make the best use of Eng-Tips Forums?

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

atlas06
I agree with you that sounds like a lawyer saying but I remember the quote as "there are no stupid questions only stupid people who never ask a question".

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

To answer this question you need to take off your engineers hat and look at it like your the client. Does it meet all of the clients expectations, are there any ways that you can give added value with little or no added cost, think about how it will be used/built/manufactured and if there is anything that can be done to make these easier.

It can be the most technically advanced design that you have ever made, but it is a failure if it doesnt meet the project requirements.

Hope this helps.

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

Quote:

Sorry, Atlas, you have to take a number to pick on me.  Your number is 92.  I am now serving number 4, but perhaps this will keep your mind occupied while you wait:

What do you suppose your teacher meant by that strange aphorism?  

1. That any person who would ask a question, was by dint therof, stupid?  And the corollary; that any person who suppressed a question, was therefore smart?

2. That all people are stupid?

3. That the particular respondent, e.g. me, was stupid?

..1.. is contrary to my experience.
..2.. may be true some of the time, but not all of the time.
..3.. see 2

I'm cutting in line.

Mike, you've got it backwards.  The meaning: people who don't ask questions remain stupid.  

-b

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

I'd answer with, "We've been reviewing that same question.  It is about time we start answering that one and here is how we plan to improve IT.  We are going to go into the Quality improvement model based on Statistical Process Control (SPC).  This process will take several months to get started and really start showing reults within a year.  We will need better measurement tools and some people trained in the process.  Are you ready to join us on this process?"

Its the ending with a question that will get them just like they got you.

Have fun

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

People who don't ask questions remain ignorant.

Stupid is forever.

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

[quote]People who don't ask questions remain ignorant.

Stupid is forever.{/quote]

Perhaps, but that's what was meant.  No wonder your kids are lawyers.

-b

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

People who don't know, are trained to ask a question to deflect another and protect thier ignorance.  SEE ALSO:  "HOLLYWOOD STAR TALKING POLITICS"

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

pauljohn
The way i heard that was "the only stupid question is the one you don't ask."

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

So you are saying that /any/ question, automatically, is worth asking, to /any/ audience?

I remember an apocryphal story.  When one of Albert Einstein's colleagues asked the eminent physicist for his telephone number one day, he reached for a telephone directory and looked it up. "You don't remember your own number?" the man asked, understandably startled. "No," Einstein replied with a shrug. "Why should I memorize something I can so easily get from a book?"

Asking a question requires zero effort. Why should anyone aks a question that they can just as easily answer themselves, or at least find out what they need to know?

Cheers

Greg Locock

Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

Greg,

Nobody said that.  Just like your not saying that we don't have to know our own phone numbers.

-b

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

This is a little bit off-track, isn't it?
Now we are discussing semantics. Is stupid=ignorant if not asking a question=stupid...

I believe the purpose of the OP was :"What do you do when a question backfires at you?"

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

Ooops, I may have started this "stupid thing".
Holly cow Mike, I did not mean to get you going there man, I was just throwing my childhood remembrances at you.




RE: Asking how something can be improved...

Thanks.  I've calmed down now.

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Asking how something can be improved...

One answer to the OPs question is that you use a 5 whys technique

"I want to get rid of that sharp edge"

"why is the edge sharp?"

"Because the paint is sharp"

"why is the paint sharp?"

"because the elctrostatic field when we spray causes more powder to accumulate on the corner of the moulding"

I didn't say you'd always be able to answer them immediately!

which then raises about ten different questions....

Cheers

Greg Locock

Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources