×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter
5

V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

(OP)
I received a 250 HP motor with some "noise" problem. On examination, I found that the noise was coming from the 8 groove, V belt pulley of the motor.

The motor shaft dia is 109.92 mm and the pulley bore is 110.20 mm i.e. 0.28 mm loose fit. The key was also loose both in the shaft and the pulley.

The motor runs smoothly without the coupling.

I would appreciate if any one can point out the kind of fit of V belt pulleys (loose fit, mallet fit or interference fit) require.

Any pointers to web references would be nice.

(I did google v belt pulleys but got 43,800 hits and the few sites I saw did not have this fit information).

Thanks

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

For this large a shaft and such a high horsepower, this should be an interference fit.  For ease of assembly, this is usually accomplished with a tapered bushing.  We commonly use QD bushings or Taperlock (spelling?) bushings.  In both cases, the bushing is split and sized to slip over the shaft.  When the bushing is bolted to the pulley, the taper on the OD of the bushing pulls into the taper in the ID of the pulley which compresses the bushing against the shaft and creates the interference.  If you are stuck with the use of a straight bore pulley, it can be very difficult to achieve an interference fit and still have assembly and disassembly practical.  I would suggest that you purchase a new pulley manufactured with a tapered bushing.  

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

(OP)
Thx JJPellin.

It is either a pulley with a taper hub & sleeve or reshaft the motor. It is a no-brainer.

My client has been running this motor with this issue (production pressure) for over six months. The end result was the damaged motor bearings due to all the knocking.

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

Taper lock bushings are widely used for an application like this and work very well. Having said that, be aware that  the bushing will crack or split very easily in the key slot.
Have seen several split over the years.

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

Until you can get a proper pulley with a taper-lock bushing, Loctite makes a compound with sugar- like goobers in it that would take up the clearance.  Sorry, I forget the actual name, but your local Loctite rep will know.



Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

(OP)
Thank you all for your helpful tips. I have already advised the client to go for the taper lock coupling.

Mike

Will loctite work for such a clearance (0.28 mm) ?

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

I think Loctite calls it "gap filling sealant" or something like that.  It's _intended_ for problems like yours.

Another alternative is a wrap of .005" shim stock, and regular Loctite.

Again, temporarily, until you get the correct part.


Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

Another thing to consider is that with an 8 groove pully you should be useing a matched set of belts. Other wise the slight differance in belt lenght cause both vibration and lower belt life. I also agree fully with the other guys the pully needs a qd or eq bushing and a tight fitting key

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

The fenner coupling is a wise choice based on experience of hundreds of unit in heavy duty applications including direct coupled diesel engine driven pump sets.

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

(OP)
Thank you all for your posts.

I have two questions.

1. The existing pulley is cast iron. Should I go for cast steel in case of taper lock ?

2. The existing pulley has 4 holes of 2 inches dia centrally in the thin stem area above the central hub. What is the purpose of these holes ?

(One theory is weight reduction, but given the total weight of the pulley, these holes on the thin stem do not save much in weight.)

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

1.  Use whatever material is offered in the size that you need.

2.  My guess is that the holes are intended to provide relief of shrinkage stresses and prevent cracking as the casting cools.  In a much older casting, you'd see curved spokes instead.



Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

Belt matching is almost obsolete, as all belt manufacturer's have tightened up their tolerences. You can still order matched belts, at a much higher price, they just give you belts that are consecutive from the mandrel. For excessive belt whip or turnover, you can get a banded belt, which has an external cover. For excessive vibration, I would recommend the Fenner Power-Twist link belt, as it transmits the proper horsepower, and it's link design absorbs a lot of vibration that normal belts will transmit.

Russell Giuliano

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

(OP)
One final question

I have a 1300 dollar quote for cast steel and a 1000 dollar quote for cast iron pulley.

Is spending additional 300 dollars for cast steel pulley worth it (in terms of better strength, less brittle, durability etc.) ?

Also, are the v-belts different for cast steel and cast iron pulleys ?

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

The cast steel part is less likely to fracture when the maintenance crew drops it.  Stuff happens.

I'm not aware of a preference on the part of the belts.

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

You should caution your installimg guys to follow the instructions concerning NOT lubricating the taper surfaces. I've seen a number of cracked or broken pulleys when millwrights put Never-Seeze or some such stuff on the taper. There will be jacking holes provided for removal, don't worry about rusting or freezing.

Steve

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

(OP)
A feedback.

Motor fitted with cast iron, taperlock pulley. Working fine for the past 3 days.

I thank you all for your valuable tips.

*Nothing exists except atoms and empty space; everything else is just an opinion*

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

You may have problems with cast iron if the alignment is not proper or if you have excessive tension on the belts. I saw the pulleys dusting off (I don't know a better word, let us say powdered at the fit) and ultimately being thrown out of the shaft. Secondly, you should be careful while removing the tapered bush. Many people use screw drivers to widen the gap and this ultimately results in a crack at 1800 position.

Otherwise, it is a good suggestion and decision as well.

RE: V Belt Pulley Bore Diameter

As others have said, A hub retained by simple keyed shaft is really not a very useful power transmission system.  A hard working design carefully evaluated for shear strength of the key and bending strength of the shaft does not stand a chance against the micro-motions allowed by a slip fit pulley, even with a few well tightened setscrews lending a hand.  A strong radial or axial grip  forms the only foundation worth considering.

What type of bearing is at the drive end of the motor? Some bigger motors headed for belt drive service have roller bearings at the drive end to handle the radial belt loads. I'd be sure the replacement motor (or the rebuild, assuming the worn shaft can be replaced economically) is meant for belt driven application. I think if the motor bearing that failed was a ball bearing, its failure is more likely from mis-application than the impact of a loose pulley whacking around on the shaft.   

The design of the belt drive should be evaluated. What was the outside or pitch diameter of the drive pulley? The largest diameter pulleys should be used to reduce the belt tension (installation AND operation)  Larger diameter pulleys cost more, but may require fewer belts, and regardless have lower tension requirement. Some motor specs include a minimum pulley diameter, and I believe that is an attempt to prevent subjecting the motor to unnecessarily cruel belt loads.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources