forging die compression rings
forging die compression rings
(OP)
I am a ME doing die design for impact extrusion/cold forging tooling for aluminum. I am working on a secondary die for an impact extruded 1" square can that forms a shoulder on the closed end of the part, it is a square shoulder that requires approximately 32 tons to form. The die is a piece of D2 54-56RC 2.375" OD x 1.375" thick with a 1" square wire EDM'd inside of it with a shoulder milled into it that is 1.050" square and .250" deep. There is a .138R around the 1" square and a .070R around the 1.050" shoulder.
I am the 2nd engineer on this project and the die was initially compressed by .002" with an H13 40-45RC ring that only had a .437" wall and it cracked. I am redesigning this to have a larger compression ring with a compression of .003"/1" of diameter, which comes to about .007". The new ring will be H13 45-50RC and 6" OD. For a square die does this seem sufficient or should I be looking at multiple compression rings and if yes what materials and sizes for them? Actually any information on multiple compression rings would be appreciated.
I am the 2nd engineer on this project and the die was initially compressed by .002" with an H13 40-45RC ring that only had a .437" wall and it cracked. I am redesigning this to have a larger compression ring with a compression of .003"/1" of diameter, which comes to about .007". The new ring will be H13 45-50RC and 6" OD. For a square die does this seem sufficient or should I be looking at multiple compression rings and if yes what materials and sizes for them? Actually any information on multiple compression rings would be appreciated.





RE: forging die compression rings
RE: forging die compression rings
I will take a look at this in more detail over the weekend, but if you want references for calculation methods and equations related to the use of multiple stress rings, then you should investigate the following:
ICFG Doc. 5/82 Calculation Methods for Cold Forging Tools
htt
Quickcalc software
htt
The ICFG document is 14 pages and thoroughly covers the calculations necessary for optimizing a multiple stress ring arrangement. It is basically an extension of Lame's theory for thick-walled hollow cylinders. The Quickcalc software is based on the same equations and allows the user to quickly review various designs.
Finite element simulation would probably be necessary to truly understand the stresses in this type of asymetric die, but I am guessing that you don't have access to this. You may try discussing this with a university professor like Joseph Domblesky (Marquette University) as part of a student project/case study.
RE: forging die compression rings
If possible, can you post a picture of the failure area?
RE: forging die compression rings
TripleZ has a great point; any kind of stess riser on the OD or ID will set up a crack site. Make sure the finish is flawless.
RE: forging die compression rings
Did the cracking occur at asembly or how many parts were formed? Do you know what the internal forging pressure is?
==========================================
Business Card http://mech.e.tripod.com
__________________________________________
Cycle Heaven.......www.tailofthedragon.com
RE: forging die compression rings
triple2, the corner radii are as I mentioned above, a .138R around the 1" square and a .070R around the 1.050" shoulder. This is where the cracking occurred, it was diagonally across the square and initiated at one of the corner radii. You're absolutely correct about the stress risers and when I pick up the new die Wed. AM I am really going to check the material finish in the corners and look for stress risers.
Pressed, the cracking occurred after about 100 parts were formed. I do not know the internal forging pressures. What I do know is that it takes the 32 tons across the 1" square area and the material is 6061 aluminum in the F temper.
The new D2 die is being EDM'd outside and it is coming in Wed then we will shrink fit it into the original .437" thin walled case with a .002-003" press fit, I need to do this because of the overall die configuration, and then the larger 6" diameter compression ring with a .009" compression will be shrunk fit over the whole thing. I tried to allow for the compression over the final sizing of D2 die I just hope the added compression doesn't crack it at the corners.
RE: forging die compression rings
RE: forging die compression rings
RE: forging die compression rings
RE: forging die compression rings
1) Shrink method. Is this a blind shrink fit where the insert is shrunk into a pocket, a straight-thru sleeve (unlikely I'd guess), or an insert with a stepped OD and a stepped bore in the case? If you have the choice to use the stepped version vs. the blind version, go with the stepped design. The blind hole shrink fit will usually put more compression on the bottom, creating more tension at the top, and making it more likely to crack. This will not be as evident in a stepped OD. The stepped OD will also be effective for constraining the insert under press and during ejection.
2) Finish is important. You will want to look in 3 areas especially. The finish in the vertical choke corners (R.070), the finish in the thru corners (R.138), and the finish at the bottom of the EDM'ed land, primarily in the corner radius that exists there (you didn't mention one). If that transition is sharp, then you also have a likelihood of developing a crack. Use a loupe (7X mag will work) and a soft light. Throw the die on its side, put the light at the back end, and peer down the cavity. EDM should pop out(as will wire lines, etc.). Your EDM shop may rough polish the recast, but he also has to take out enough stock to remove the remnant pitting below the recast layer.
3) Too late now, but when making dies, I usually rough cut the insert out of the die, shrink fit the insert into the case, and then finish wirecut the cavity. My finish cuts will take around 0.030" out of the cavity in multiple passes. It's two setups, but I rarely crack inserts. Carbide occasionally does, but it's rare.
4) Insert material. I'm in a different industry, but we do deal with pressure cracking of material fairly often. Uddeholm make two steels you might consider trying: Vanadis 4 and Isodur K340. One is PM, the other is hot rolled I believe. The grades are very similar in performance, but the K340, due to its non-PM construction, seems to hold up to impact loads a bit better. You should also find that this steel wears better than the D2 you're using. It's a little more expensive, but the price will likely be negligible if measured in tens of thousands of parts.
5) To me, .009 seems a bit much. You'll probably find out in a bit.
RE: forging die compression rings
If your journey into the the suggestions don't solve the issue then you might consider sectionalizing the insert. Reducing the hardness of the insert is one cheaper/simpler test to try.
==========================================
Business Card http://mech.e.tripod.com
__________________________________________
Cycle Heaven.......www.tailofthedragon.com