×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment
4

Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

(OP)
Looking for suggests for an application i am working on. Our process involves using a high viscosity, highly abrasive material in which we control the flow using a pneumatic actuated metal seated ball valve.  Initially we had issues with the valves failing to open (prior to switching to the metal seated valve). We operate at a pressure around 1500 psi and the valve cycles about once per minute.  The issue that we are having now are leaks occuring at the stem. This occurs over a short period < 2mos. Are there any suggests on what i can try, valves, different packing, etc.?  

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

Metal-seated ball valves such as VTI or Mogas are frequently used successfully in applications such as this.  Ceramic valves >EXIST< for abrasive services.  

You didn't say how hot the application is.  If it's not too hot, and o-ring-sealed bushing below the packing helps to keep the grit out of the packing.  

Thw pneumatic actuator is good because it probably does not put a side-load on the valve stem. Rack and pinion wont side-load the stem, nor will a scotch yoke.  Make sure your mounting bracket and coupling are concentric anyway.  

Live-loaded packing will help since it has a spring to keep compression on the packing as it wears.  THe packing stackup should have a junk ring as the first element next to the process:usually this is a braided ring that can absorb grit instead of trying to seal around it.  

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

(OP)
Thanks for the help. the temperature is ambient, and not a issue.  This has a live loaded stem (Manufacturer is Sharpe Valve) but i will check on the o-ring sealed bushing and the junk ring.  I haven't found a ceramic valve that will handle the pressures but will look at VTI and Mogas.

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

We used to use "Burkert" valves for abrasive diamond slurries.

The material does not come in contact with moving parts, and therefore does not foul up the components. The design uses a diaphram, made of polymer, that covers the orifice. The only contacting part is the diaphram on the orifice opening.

As you can imagine, diamond slurry is abrasive; we never had one clog or leak.

Charlie
www.facsco.com

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

(OP)
One other thing to note, we use 2" valves.

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

Have you looked a pneumatic pinch valves?

Basically a large rubber tube inside a housing. When air is applied between the tubing and the housing, it compresses the rubber tube and stops the flow.

I used them for waste drains for the abrasive slurries. They are found in the agriculture industry

Charlie
www.facsco.com

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

Charlie: A 1500 psi pinch valve?????

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

You specifically mention stem seal leaks as the problem.  Many times, it's not the media or wear that causes the packing to repeatedly leak, but a lack of proper alignment between the valve and actuator.  Check how the actuator is connected to the valve to see if there is any side loading.  Do you have a slide-on type coupling or does it clamp on.

The symptom that indicates side loaiding is that you tighten the packing until it seals, then, a shorwhile later, the packing leaks again.  Tighten the packing until is stops and roughly the same period, it leaks again.  On and on it goes until there is no adjustment left.  Also, look at the type of packing used.  For high cycle ambient temperature, would recommend filled PTFE v-ring (chevron) type.  It is common for small ball valves to simply use plastic washers, which are OK for occasional manual operation, but won't last as long when automated with side loading.

bcd

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

You might want to look at Argus or Gosco Valves.  They both have stem guides to prevent side load on the packing.  If you're cycling once a minute 24/7, that's approximately 500,000 times a year so it's very high cycle.  Also, make sure that the valve and actuator are properly aligned as BCD says.  In addition, Chesterton makes a packing set that is guaranteed for 1,000,000 cycles, so you may want to contact them too.

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

Have you considered a slab (or through conduit) gate valve?

The "seats" of a slab gate is perpendicular to the direction of flow, so it doesn't take as much abuse as the gate slide at 90 degress to flow when moving. Also, with a slab gate, there is no tradition gate valve's "seat" in which stuff can accumulate, allowing you to close the valve multiple cycles.

Also, what is "high viscosity"? And, what is "highly abraisive"? That may also help others give you a better suggestion.

"Do not worry about your problems with mathematics, I assure you mine are far greater."   
Albert Einstein
Have you read FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies to make the best use of Eng-Tips Forums?

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

Consider hard surface materials to reduce the abrasion.  Examples such as Deloro Stellite or other cobalt alloys may be helpful.

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

There are also diffusion processes (boriding) www.bodycote.com that will reduce the coefficient of friction and create a very hard surface (RC 97 if the Rockwell scale went that high).  Arcuate cuts in the ball also reduces velocities when you first open the valve.  You might also want to open the valve very quickly to reduce the amount of time the abrasive fluids are directed at the ball seat.

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

I agree with Ashereng to use through conduit is a good idea. Of course the metal seated ball valve is good way, and I don't think the packing leakage is not your choice wrong, I think it the valve have some problem. And the main problem is the stem not in the same axle of ball and below trunnion.

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

(OP)
All, Just catching up on the threads thanks for the  help.  Just a quick update on status.

We're still in the process of trying different packing to address the leakage of stems. Currently looking at UHMWPE material.

I've looked at other valve types but havent found a slab gate valve for the high pressures and room to fit in our application.  I don't have the exact measurement for viscosity but it has the consistancy of a thick cement paste and is ceramic based.

The valve body is coated with Armaloy and the ball is stellite

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

Dear Washl,

UHMWPE can be used as a packing material, however, it is very limited on temperature.  I would not recommend it if you see temperatures above 175F.  My feeling is that you are more likely to be side loading the packing with misalignment of the valve and actuator, than having inferior packing materials.  (look at BCD's comments)  However, if you still feel that it is the packing, Chesterton offers a guarantee on their packing for 1,000,000 cycles.  You can reach them at (800) 263-9140.  They will tell you that it is extremely important not to overtighten the packing.  For packing to work, you need to have a bit of movement or it won't seal properly.  

Also take a look at www.mclassvalves.com.  Gosco manufactures a valve that will work in this application.

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

I have successfully used Valve Technologies metal seated ball  valves on 75% solids fly ash at 15000kPa.

Geoffrey D Stone FIMechE C.Eng;FIEAust CP Eng
www.waterhammer.bigblog.com.au

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

(OP)
The temp is less than 175F. From the Gosco website, the M-class looks promising. It seems to be a bit more robust than what i am currently using.  My guess that comes at a significant cost. How does it handle high viscosity material (>250,000Cp)?

RE: Valve for high pressure , high viscosity, highly abrasive enviroment

I'm not sure how Gosco would work on high viscocity material, but these high end companies (VTI, Mogas, Argus etc) should be able to solve your problem.  You're right about the price though.  Depending on what valve manufacturer you're using right now, you could be 3-4 times the price.  You tend to get what you pay for, but on difficult applications like this, you need to look at cost of ownership.  If you're replacing valves every 2 months, how much does that cost you in labour, lost production, safety?

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources