×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
I have designed a house using my mechanical engineering knowledge and lots of research.  The house will be built in the Pacific Northwest on the Olympic Peninsula.  When discussing my design with contractors in that area, I was constantly questioned about building on a slab.  They kept insisting I should build with a crawlspace.  I hate crawlspaces.  I just can't stand walking around and hearing the slightest thump thump, cold feet, the added expense of a foundation and a floor, and mainly, the lack of thermal mass.

The contractors and builders would state reasons not to build on a slab such as, moisture problems, hard on knees and hips, can't easily re-model and move the kitchen, and lack of insulation.  In talking to forward thinking builders, engineers, and from my own knowledge, I realize that none of these are issues.  There are a few homes in my area on a slab, which are properly built that work well.  I know the owners.  Some are passive solar, but more on that later.

So I ask builders in the PNW why they build with a crawlspace, and have yet to get a real answer.  One answer I get from builders is, “that’s just the way we build here”.  I’m guessing there are several reasons.  Could it be a hold over from when concrete was expensive or non-existent and wood was almost free?  Could it be that builders can get more money for a crawlspace house?  One reason I heard that makes sense is, “We’re building on crawlspaces, making money, so why change?”  I even had one builder state that with equivalent houses, one on a slab, the other on a crawlspace, the slab house will be perceived as a “cheaper” house.

My design consists of a perimeter foundation footing, perimeter walls using ICF’s, and first floor walls made of ICF’s.  Insulation will be on the very bottom by the perimeter footings, then about 2.5 feet of compacted fill, then the internal cap slab.  This is to capture as much insulated thermal mass as possible with this design.  Radiant tubing will be down in the insulated earth box and in the slab.  When the solar collectors have satisfied the slab, they then pump heat down in the earth box for later use.  Such a design will “coast” through a month long power outage with freezing outside temperatures and should only loose a few degrees a week.  And with PV panels to power the radiant pump, a power outage will be a thermal non-issue.  The house will look normal but be passive solar in that most of the windows will be south facing.  No serious calculations were done, just good sound design practices utilized.  So what about the summer?  With a passive solar design, there will be minimal gain in the summer due to the high sun.  And with high thermal mass, the house will be an average of the heat in during the day and heat out during the night.  No forced air needed here.

There is a house on the Peninsula, well actually many, poorly designed and placed with large expanses of glass facing west and on a crawlspace.  When seen in a summer afternoon, all windows are covered with shades and I’ll be the AC is running. It’s the sun.  It’s thermonuclear.  This is with the ambient temperature in the 60’s.  And because of the low thermal mass, it’s conceivable that the heater might be needed the next morning.  Low thermal mass, big temperature swings, and the more active the heating and cooling system will be.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

I don't know how far north... but crawlspaces provide an area of storage and permit warmer construction. SOG foundations tend to be very cold.  It also provides a space for mechanical and often heating systems or HRV's are installed in the crawlspace.  It provides a lower location for a sump pit which improves moisture conditions and the thermal envelope.  The savings in concrete is real, and often used with PWF foundations.  In some northern areas, concrete can be extremely costly.  The perimeter depth to the footings can be reduced using extruded, type 4 insulation.

just some ramblings, Dik

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
Well, if one is stupid enough to sink an uninsulated SOG in the wet earth, they deserve to have cold feet.  I lived on an uninsulated SOG in Louisiana and without question, my feet were cold in the winter.  Concrete availability and cost are a real issue.  But on the Olympic Peninsula, concrete is $70.00 a yard.

Putting ducting in the crawlspace is not good.  There will be thermal losses.  Radiant heat in an insulated slab is much more comfortable and is less expensive than forced heated air.  But the contractor will not tell you that.

Even if what you say is correct, the benefits and comfort of thermal mass overcome the few shortfalls of having the space in a crawlspace.

The best way to control moisture is to not have it present.  Direct the water away from the house.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

You have to direct the water away, in particular in areas which have significant cold weather.  In addition you have to use PEVB to separate the slab from moisture below.

Having said that, my experience has been that even with perimeter insulation and underslab insulation, they tend to be cold and colder without underslab insul. The only manner in which they are warm is if hydronic in-slab heating is used (and I've done several of these).  In these areas, hydronics are more expensive than forced air, although there is likely a payback time.

It's common to put ducting in the crawlspace from the furnace.  The space is relatively clear and most of the heatloss is up through the main floor.

Dik

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
"You have to direct the water away, in particular in areas which have significant cold weather."

Why?

"In addition you have to use PEVB to separate the slab from moisture below."

Why?

"Having said that, my experience has been that even with perimeter insulation and underslab insulation, they tend to be cold and colder without underslab insul."

No way.  Show me the math.

"The only manner in which they are warm is if hydronic in-slab heating is used (and I've done several of these)."

Hydronic will heat the slab, of course.

"In these areas, hydronics are more expensive than forced air, although there is likely a payback time."

Hydronic is more expensive because it is new.  Price out the materials from Radiantec and see for yourself.  Don't think you need a 5K boiler either.  A $300.00 water heater will be fine for the average well insulated house.

"It's common to put ducting in the crawlspace from the furnace.  The space is relatively clear and most of the heatloss is up through the main floor."

Yea, well I've lived in a rental on a crawlspace and when the resistive electric forced air comes on there is a blast of cold air first before the hot air warms the ducts.  In that house, it is cheaper to run all the lights, computers, TV, oven, etc. than to run the forced air.  In that house in the winter it is a waste to use fluorescent instead of incandescent.  Think about it.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

I'm not disputing that you have to direct the water away... from perimeter drains to free drainage as well as sloping the grade away from the slab by 2% min slope.

Dik

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

Interesting,
   The residential construction in my area, and in the very cold ski areas, tends to be about 50/50. When it is all said and done, the homeowner's preference seems to be the final issue. I have dealt with people from all over the U.S. and either system is considered to be the 'cheap' system somewhere. I make no attempt to argue someone out of their preference.

I have lived on both and I prefer a properly built crawlspace. Properly built slabs tend to have a high initial cost, especially if shallow groundwater is a problem. Poorly designed houses, lots of glass, do not perform well with either crawlspace or slab. Well designed houses, from a heating/cooling & conservation standpoint, are not very popular.

I have consulted on many moving foundations and moisture related problems. Either floor system has weaknesses. In my experience, the crawlspace tends to be easier to repair. Over the longterm, most structural and mechanical repairs on slabs tend to be more expensive. The key appears to be to build in a manner which will minimize later repair.

"You have to direct the water away, in particular in areas which have significant cold weather."

Why?  I HAVE NEVER SEEN A WET SUBGRADE/SLAB IN A SKI/COLD RESORT AREA WHICH WAS CONSIDERED COMFORTABLE OR PERFORMING WELL.

"In addition you have to use PEVB to separate the slab from moisture below."

Why?   MOISTURE COMING THROUGH A SLAB CREATES MORE PROBLEMS THAN JUST POTENTIAL HEAT LOSS.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
The "Why's" were not asked correctly.

What I meant was why is water in contact with a basement wall or slab bad.  I'm intereted i the technical reason.  Here is the answer I was looking for.

I was in a hotel in MA in January and the slab was in contact with the snow outside.  There was condensation on the floor in the corner of my room's tile floor.  Water in contact with a slab will conduct the heat away fast because water has high heat capacity and thermal conductivity.  If snow is piled up against the edge or the ground is frozen, the concrete will loose heat fast and condensate will form on the inside.  It amazes me when I see basement walls sprayed with water proofing and dirt piled up on the outside.  Then for insulation, a wall is framed on the inside and insulated with fiberglass.  What a recipe for mold.  I would bet that most wet basement walls get blamed on water "migrating" through the concrete when the actual problem is condensation.  I'm not talking about a genuine crack and water is pouring in, in that case, the basement is really leaking.

A poorly designed crawlspace will perform better than a poorly built slab.  This is because a crawlspace is disconnected from the earth and could not be in contact with large amounts of water.  A poorly designed slab or basement could be in contact with large amounts of water.

But, a properly designed slab or basement will perform better and be more stable thermally because of the coupling with large amounts of dry earth.

I would question the higher cost and I have quotes to prove otherwise.

Search: "high thermal mass homes" to learn more.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

In Coloardo we always try for slab on grade unless the soil is expansive.  Sometime owners are willing to take the risk of slab heaving so we do slab on grade anyway on expansive soil.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
COEngineer, do you insulate in CO?  How much is concrete in CO?  Is radiant heat used often?  Is Radiant expensive and do they use complex systems with boilers?

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

I cant answer you questions laminar, I just design the structural. I am not a contractor.  The nice mountain homes we design mostly do have radiant heat.  Just google it if you want to more about it.  If I am not mistaken, it is all connected to your water heater right? If you want to have slab on grade you need to put drainage around the footing of your foundation.  Also you need to put 4" of clean gravel underneath your slab to take care of the moisture.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

COEngineer... it's generally a separate circuit.  The liquid has to have antifreeze and some other additives.

Dik

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

I guess there are several types Dik.

http://www.radiantcompany.com/system/

I am pretty sure the nice houses I designed are proabably using the system you described Dik.  

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
COEngineer, radiant heat water can be heated in many ways.  There are many different types of systems.  But in most systems, a simple water heater can be used.  Some tie it into the domestic system, some use a stand alone system.  A stand alone system using solar is a good idea.  But keep in mind, with a properly designed passive solar high thermal mass house, not much energy will be needed for heating.  And in the summer, high thermal mass will keep the peaks  low in the afternoon.

With slab on grade, it all depends on the site.  Each situation should be looked at fresh.  Too many in engineering only listen and never research or think on their own.  Keep the water away from the thermal mass and insulate the thermal mass.  How it's done does not matter.  If the site is on top of a hill of gravel, only insulation is needed.  If it's in a flat area, raise it up on some compacted insulated fill.  It is a misconception that water will somehow find the slab and migrate to it.  Shed the water away and insulate the slab.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
We overlapped CO.  There is no need for antifreeze and it might not even be code in a hydronic system.  It should never see freezing temperatures.  Solar collectors sometimes use antifreeze because of freezing, but a drainback solar system is also used.

What exactly is a "nice" house?  I have heard of extremely high quotes for hydronic systems.  It's probably  because of the newness and builders are reluctant to change for fear of eating a house.  Price out the materials and labor and you will see what I mean.  If heating only is needed, it can be very reasonable to install a radiant system.  I know several owners who installed their own because of the high quotes.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

Well,, if you have radiant heat on main and upper floor, then you I usually design it with an extra 10-15 psf.  Nice houses in mountain area are probably at least 3 Million.  It is definately something want to install when you are building it, not an upgrade.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

The Winnipeg area has a Freezing Index of 1904 degree days... and the index for many areas to the north is greater.  The index is likely a little greater than your environs, hence the greater reliance on antifreeze systems.  I haven't heard of a plain water system used in these areas.

Dik

Dik

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
I'm not sure why a system, even in very cold climates, would need anti-freeze.  It's a heating system.  Even if the house was vacant for weeks, I can't imagine the temp dropping below freezing on an insulated slab.  The residual heat would last quite a while.  And assuming a crawlspace house had radiant tubing and did drop below freezing, would it not also freeze the other water pipes in the house?  What about those?

I'm thinking it could be a case of "what's your budget" construction.  A builder asked me that and I said I have no budget, but I do have an idea of what I would spend on building my house and know one will know that but me.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

laminar, the radiant heat goes out to the driveway and deck.  It will be freezing, but you just have to make sure you dont turn the boiler setting to "vacation" unless it is summer time.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
Well excuse me!  Well in that case, yes, antifreeze would be helpful.  But I would bet that with energy prices headed in the present vector and magnitude, that is not a common practice.  I guess for solar heating I would approve.

Whoever you know with heated driveways, see if you can get me invited to the next party!  Got to be a good one.  Salmon, fresh veggies, Cabernet, Chocolates.....

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

Getting back to your original question, foundation selection rarely has anything to do with heating. The primary considerations will be the ability to drain soil from the house and at what rate, the strength and settlement charateristics of the soil and the anticipated severity of frost, as well as the cost of construction.
First you will excavate to below frost for your wall footings. Then you will typically backfill the footings and make grade on native soil. If you chose soil replacement to below frost, youu will have significant costs associated with that work. Mostiure into the slab is controled by perimeter drains and a moisture barrier.Site drainage, including foundation drains is very important, however in residential work it is often done poorly or wrong as often as it is done right. The biggest problem with slab on grade is frost. If the ground freezes and the fill heaves, the slab will split in two. I used to live in NY State and have seen it happen. Once that occurs, the strucure generally can not be salvaged.
The othe reason is that if you ever need to access drains the slab will need to be cut. All first floor water will be in the ceiling, again making repairs or modifacations difficult. These are the reasons I belive crawl spaces may be used in luie of a slab on grade. The great thing about this country is that you can do whatever you want. Me, I would go for the full basement. I would suggest you talk to the local building offical about crawl spaces vs. slabs, as there is probably a lot of local history on both.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

Yeah, we just got hit with 2 bizzards in a row.  I really wish I had heated driveway  smile.  Took me forever plowing my driveway.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
Hi DRC1,  That does make sense but in the Pacific Northwest, it's mostly crawlspace on the west of the Cascades where freezing temps are not an issue.  Water is to a degree but not that bad depending on where the location is.  On the east side where it gets colder and has less rain, there are more slab houses.

The locals are hopeless as they continue to give the reasons I mentioned in the first post.  Could it be as simple as craawlspace is the way they have been doing it and reluctant to change?  I have seen very complex foundations for full height crawlspaces with a dirt floor.  For just a bit more cement, they could have had a basement.

In my design, and as a few other owner builders are doing, ICF's are used down to good ground and the inside is filled and capped with a slab.  The ground and earth box below it will stay very dry.  I might even toss in a bit of umbrella insulation too.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

I have a passive solar house that was built in ’81 in CO.  The solar water panels and system have long been removed. It was designed correctly, from the thermal mass and sunlight respects.  A lot of windows on the south side, overhangs that allow winter sun, but not summer, dark bricks on the northern wall for the sun to heat, slab on grade, it is built into a hill (whole thing is a walk out basement), and good cross ventilation for the summer.

I like the SOG; however, the slab curled when it cured, making subtle peaks at the joints.  This was a pain when installing wood floors and tile in some rooms, and is noticeable in the carpeted rooms.  I have wanted to remodel and would have to pull up the slab to do it (to move sewer), so this is a downfall.

For the heating, there is forced air, with the ducts run below the slab.  In the winter, it only runs at night to counter the leaky windows.  In the winter the house is up to 85 on sunny days, and the heat is only on from about 8pm to 8am.  I think this would be reduced substantially with newer windows.  The debate with my wife is “How energy efficient should they be to not reduce the solar effects?”

I was thinking it would be nice to add radiant heat to the main portion of my house, installed over the main slab.  I have plenty of headroom with vaulted ceilings (up to 16 feet), and few doorways to contend with.  Some of the tank less water heaters I have looked at state that they can be used for radiant heat as well.  Some just use isolation so they can do both the water and heating needs.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
I'm amazed that someone would build a slab with forced air ducts under the slab.  Why?  Forced heat air works just as well with ducts in the walls and ceiling.  If you call forced air good.  I hate it.  It would be much better of course to put radiant in the gravel below the slab or in it.  Nothing should be under a slab but what is necessary.  Drain plumbing only.  I know a sharp engineer who built his own house and has nothing in the slab.  The tub and toilet are up 5" for the drain pipes.  It's really like being on a throne!

If your getting that much temperature swings between nigh and day, your house does not have enough thermal mass.  Is the basement insulated?  Is it insulated on the inside walls?

I would suggest looking into insulating the perimeter ground with wing insulation and pouring a cap on the slab with radiant tubes.  This would solve your curling slab.  What was the reason for the slab curling?

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

For the Curling slabs, do a search in the Eng-Tips.
Lots of discussion.

Placing a topping or capping the slab may or may not be effective.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

Not so much a lack of mass, but the inflow of cold air.  The windows are original, have broken seals, and many do not close well.  If we could fix that, we would be much better off.  The problem is that most of the windows are nearly floor to ceiling, and need to be tempered.  Just for good quality windows, we are looking at over 8 grand (no installation).

Our furnace was out for a few days, and we maintained in the upper 60's at night with 80’s in the day, while the neighbors were continuously running the heat.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

laminar, what is the frost depth in the OP? Around 100"? Also, have you seen a lot of basements in that area?

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
Mitchelon, I don't think there is any frost depth here.  It is maritime and although we did get 6" of snow in December and due for an inch tonight, the winter temps are usually in the 30's.  Not many basements but what you do see is crawlspaces on a slope that are tall enough to be a basement.  Really, I've seen the dumbest construction here and there has not been an architect near this place for decades.  We saw a slab on grade house last weekend, well it was half a slab on grade.  The living room, dining room, and study were SOG and the Bedrooms and Kitchen were crawlspace.  Built in the 90's apparently by an owner / builder / contractor, I can't imagine what he was thinking.  The slab was not insulated on the perimeter and the ground was wet from the recent rain.  It was cold on the edges and the owner was most interested in my suggestions on insulating the edges of the SOG and using plastic and insulation to shed the water away from the edges of the slab.  Without insulation, a SOG is just as bad as a crawlspace without insulation.  Why do people think concrete has a high R value?

Most basements in this area, even new construction, are concrete right up to the wet earth.  What a recipe for mold.  Isn't there a test to take before one works for the county or gets a contractor license?

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

Your lack of respect for builders and the way things are usually done may come back to haunt you.  You dismiss far too easily the way things are usually done on the premise that builders have no reasons other than supreme ignorance or to build a fatter profit.

Crawlspaces are generally chosen over slab on grade for structural reasons.  Perhaps a couple questions may help on your quest for knowledge:

1) What is the expected differential movement of the undisturbed soil at the site?
2) What is the expected differential movement of the soil at the site once 2.5 feet of soil are replaced with fill?
3) Will the fill be compacted?  Or are you prepared for the settlement which will occur?
4) What is the expected settlement of the soil beneath the exterior footings?
5) Will the expected settlement / expansion of the soil cause problems in the veneer on your house?
6) Will the exterior footings be beneath the frost line? If not, heaving will wreck your exterior walls.

Where I work, there are several different soil types.  On one side of the city is clay.  When we design foundations there, it is typically more economical to use a crawlspace (suspended foundation).  If the owner absolutely insists on a slab on grade, the geotech often recommends 7+ feet of soil removal and replacement with select fill.  With this amount of fill, you'll also experience settlement issues.  7 feet is typically the breakeven point for economy between slab on grade vs. suspended.  So for this side of the city, you either get a suspended foundation, or a house that will almost definitely have wall cracking problems, especially if someone built it cheap, like one of the national homebuilders.

On the other side of the city, the soil is a bit better, mostly rock, or weathered limestone.  The norm here is slab on grade without too much fill.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
"Your lack of respect for builders and the way things are usually done may come back to haunt you."  

You bet.  Sometimes I feel that I'm being haunted, like right now!

"You dismiss far too easily the way things are usually done on the premise that builders have no reasons other than supreme ignorance or to build a fatter profit."

No, I discussed this with the local builders, and local engineers.  Local builders just say that that's the way we have always built.  Local engineers like SOG as they design all commercial building that way.

"Crawlspaces are generally chosen over slab on grade for structural reasons.  Perhaps a couple questions may help on your quest for knowledge:"

1) What is the expected differential movement of the undisturbed soil at the site?

Not much, glacial till hard as rock with some clay down deeper.

2) What is the expected differential movement of the soil at the site once 2.5 feet of soil are replaced with fill?

Not much as the fill will be compacted.  (Hang on, we just had an earthquake.... no wait, it's was my 9 year old chasing my 7 year old through the rental we're in and yup, it's on a crawlspace.)

3) Will the fill be compacted?  Or are you prepared for the settlement which will occur?

Yes

4) What is the expected settlement of the soil beneath the exterior footings?

Engineer said everything is OK.

5) Will the expected settlement / expansion of the soil cause problems in the veneer on your house?

Not likely, doesn't on other houses here.  Why should it?

6) Will the exterior footings be beneath the frost line? If not, heaving will wreck your exterior walls.

Frost line isn't very deep here but I'd put wing insulation if it was.

But here is a clincher.  If crawlspaces are necessary here, why do all commercial building have SOG or perimeter footings with a cap slab?  The local engineers all say SOG is no problem and that we even have better soil for it than in other areas that use SOG.

Thanks for your concern.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

I also want to add sometimes they do crawlspace because it is cheaper.  Due to site condition very steep, they might have to import too much material for the basement to work so they do crawlspace instead.

RE: Why Crawlspaces instead of Slab on grade?

(OP)
When the site is very steep, an insulated basement or bermed in insulated wall can be used.  But if there is a benifit to getting the house up high, a view or up to capture some sun if the house is on the north slope, then I think I would use an insulated basement and utilize the space.  I've seen crawlspaces that are tall enough to park a van in.  Makes for an ugly house too.

As far as fill, I've seen new crawlspace construction "push out" a considerable amount of fill which is then trucked out to build the crawlspace.  This is to get the house level with the surrounding grade.

Just yesterday I heard of another reason crawlspaces are the most common new construction method in the Pacific Northwest.  Their reason was that after WW2, many cheap houses were tossed together on uninsulated slabs down in the wet earth.  They were so cold and damp, gee I wonder why, that crawlspaces became the preferred method of construction.  I guess that makes sense too.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources