×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Heat load due to conveyor motors

Heat load due to conveyor motors

Heat load due to conveyor motors

(OP)
Ok, I feel really dumb about this.  It seems like it should be straight forward, but I can't wrap my head around it.

I have a project with about 250 hp of conveyor motors.  These conveyors move product both horizontally and vertically.  Eventually, one of the conveyors moves the product out of the warehouse at a higher elevation than it comes in.

My question is:  Does all the heat from the conveyor motors become part of the A/C load?  I understand that if it was a chilled water pump, a fan or an air compressor I would include it all in the A/C load.  

But I am getting confused in my head because of the change in potential energy of the product (due to elevation change) leaving the warehouse.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

The motors are doing work, which generates heat.  The motor doesn't know whether the energy is "stored" in product as a higher potential energy or not.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

(OP)
Don't get me wrong, I am not arguing, I just want to make sure I understand this.

If a fan is blowing air, the heat from the motor and the velocity of the air all ends up being converted to heat.  This I understand.

However, if in the conveyor, all the energy is converted to heat in the motor...WHERE does the energy to change the elevation of the product come from?

The energy of the moving air turns to heat, but the potential energy of the elevated product does not.  This seems to me to not be an equivalent treatment of energy.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

You have to cool off elevator machine rooms, however the intermittent loperation helps you out. Myself I have never done a building busy enough to need the cooling that an elevator submittal lists.

What goes in must come out. More power goes in than what is required to do the lifting. So friction and heat from the ineffciency of the motor will heat the space.

Take the "V" out of HVAC and you are left with a HAC(k) job.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

So to MAragorn's point, how much of the motor heat is rejected to the room, versus the energy "consumed" by moving the conveyor?  Simply taking 250HP of motors and converting it to heat is (250HP)*(2,542BTUH/HP) = 635,500 BTUH or 53 tons.  

But is all of this heat really rejected to the space?  And now that I think about it, I don't fully understand my conversion number of 2,542BTUH/HP.  I took it from a book, but how does it account for motor efficiency?  A less efficient motor will consume more energy and give off more heat, right?  

I'm confused too.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

Take a look at table 3A from chapter 30 of the current ASHRAE HOF, your 635,500 is pretty good lol, for a single big motor.

That table shows for 'motor & driven equipment' in the conditioned space the gain on a 250 hp motor (91%) efficient is 699,000 so take your number divided by 0.91 and you are right there.

AHSRAE is basically using the motor power divided by efficiency times a fudge factor for how frequently it runs, where 1 would be continuous and as well as a factor for how loaded that motor is and the load factor would get into the service factor at times THEREFORE GREATER THAN 1.

Table 3A shows them fully loaded with both the motor and the driven equipment in the space, with the driven equipment in the space and motor not in the space, and with the motor in the space and the driven equipment out of the space.

The motor in the space only, the gain on the 250 hp motor is 62,900 Btu/hr got to be the efficiency here, 699,000x.09=62910.

With a horizontal conveyor rolling along loaded, what is the motor power doing after the belts are started and inertia is over come? It is over coming the friction of the conveyor (like rolling losses of car, the bearings, drive losses), the friction of the loaded conveyor on the rollers, plus air drag on the load. So when all friction losses are in the space there is heat to the space.

Loaded belt more rolling losses, more weight on the (for lack of a better word) rollers, plus air drag. Belt is running empty, less weight down on those rollers so less friction, less air drag. Less power the motor draws.

With the inclined belts and vertical 'legs' lifting the load there is also the friction mentioned above. I do not see the energy of the lift itself creating heat outside of the heat shed at the motor.

Smaller motors are less efficient than the big motors.

I spent a few years in grain elevators and at times the equipment ran steady such as when loading 30,000 tons on a ship or other times it was infrequent and very intermittent. Some belts ran steady but were unloaded the majority of the time.

Take the "V" out of HVAC and you are left with a HAC(k) job.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

746w X 3.412=2545

Take the "V" out of HVAC and you are left with a HAC(k) job.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

I have that table and see what you mean.  I also see equation 2, which takes efficiency, motor use factor, and motor load factor into account.  My simple conversion of 2,545 BTUH/HP was missing a few things.

I have strayed from MAragorn's original question of potentieal energy.  The motor is working harder to raise the product than to simple convey it horizontally, but both motor and driven equipment are in the conditioned space, so it would seem that all of the heat is rejectrd into the space.  

Now one more question.  Let's take 250HP for example from table 3A.  With both motor and driven equipment in the conditioned space, the heat is 699,000BTUH.  With the motor out and the driven eqipment in, the heat is 636,000 BTUH.  Now where is this heat?  Is it the motor heat that is not in the conditioned space, or is it the heat from the driven equipment that is in the the conditioned space?    

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

Hi Abbynormal:  are you reffering to ahrae handbook of fundamentals?  I have been looking for the same type info on the motors runing in a space and how mauch heat do they add to the heat load.
I have the 2001 ashrae handbook, but I can't find the chapter you are reffering to.  Am I in the right book?
thanks,

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

In the 2001 book, see table 3A on page 29.7

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

I think the only extra heat involved with the lift would be the increase you would see similar to just the motor in the space. The energy of the lift is accounted for in the potential energy of the product and not heat is my thinking.

The 636,000 is the work done by the motor on the driven equipment in the space, what you would allow for in a cooling load. The 62,900 is outside of the conditioned space, similar to a big monster air handler with the shaft extending out of the casing and the motor out of the airstream.

Take the "V" out of HVAC and you are left with a HAC(k) job.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

Sorry I was referring to the 2005 HOF.

Take the "V" out of HVAC and you are left with a HAC(k) job.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

AbbyNormal,

So to be clear, if the 250 HP motor is OUT of the conditioned space and the driven equipment in IN the space, I would add 636,000 to the air conditioning load of the space.  Correct?  

Conversly, if the motor is IN the conditioned space and the driven equipment is OUT, I would only add 62,900 to the air conditioning load.  Correct?  

This is counter-intuitive to me because I would think that the motor would always be a larger heat source than whatever equipment it may be driving.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

(OP)
AbbyNormal, what you are saying is exactly what I would expect, and what I was thinking.

In this case, both the motor and the driven equipment are in the space, so the complete load is added to the A/C load.

I may have accidentally misled, in that there are a number of smaller convetors in series, each with its own motor, all totalling 250 HP.  

I believe that ONLY the portion of the work of the last conveyor that elevates the product prior to leaving the building would NOT be part of the HVAC load.  Except for that all motor loads are included in the A/C load.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

So to be clear, if the 250 HP motor is OUT of the conditioned space and the driven equipment in IN the space, I would add 636,000 to the air conditioning load of the space.  Correct?

That is my take on it  

Conversly, if the motor is IN the conditioned space and the driven equipment is OUT, I would only add 62,900 to the air conditioning load.  Correct?

Correctamundo again fonzie smile or is it Mr. Page?

This is counter-intuitive to me because I would think that the motor would always be a larger heat source than whatever equipment it may be driving.

I think that heat coming off of the motor casing is the inefficiency. That 250 hp example said it was a 91% efficient motor, 699x.91=636, what's left over?

Take the "V" out of HVAC and you are left with a HAC(k) job.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

I may have accidentally misled, in that there are a number of smaller convetors in series, each with its own motor, all totalling 250 HP.

Smaller motors tend to be less efficient than the larger ones. They all run steady at the same time?  

I believe that ONLY the portion of the work of the last conveyor that elevates the product prior to leaving the building would NOT be part of the HVAC load.  Except for that all motor loads are included in the A/C load.

My gut feeling is it will radiate a little more heat off of the casing than the horizontal ones, I don't think it really adds any more heat from the work than the horizontal ones, I guess if you knew how many pounds per hour it was lifting you could correct.

Take the "V" out of HVAC and you are left with a HAC(k) job.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

Thanks AbbyNormal, and it is Mr. Page

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

You're welcome Jimmy

Take the "V" out of HVAC and you are left with a HAC(k) job.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

I started a similar discussion based upon some prior discussions in thread403-158338 sometime back. The link given in the thread by imok2 gives some good leads for discounting the heat load.

ASHRAE 2005 HOF says, as the no load power of motor is generally high, we have to follow the equations without any reduction (or atleast that is what I understood from the book). Check the same page as that of motor heat loads.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

Quark your post was on 'cooling the mechanical room', you have indoor chillers and pumps.

I think the pump motor would be like the 'motor in the space'. Hermetic compressors have their winidngs cooled by refrigerant but the dome can be quite hot and so can some of the discharge piping. I would think treating it as motor in and driven load out would be conservative.

Last hydraulic elevator submittal I had, gave a much higher heat output compared to the "motor in, driven equipment out", however a cooling system sized only for the "motor in" is keeping up. Most likely luck that the elevator is not heavily used.

Take the "V" out of HVAC and you are left with a HAC(k) job.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

I think the comment about "high no load currents" is telling you to "CYA"

Take the "V" out of HVAC and you are left with a HAC(k) job.

RE: Heat load due to conveyor motors

My question was about the redundancy of considering full heat load of the prime mover. Like the OP rightly suggested, there should be some power associated with the equipment that is not converted into heat.

I took the mechanical room as an example. If the full motor load is carried out by the room air then you could downsize the cooling tower to just take care of the conditioned space heat load. However, BHP is associated with the increase in refrigerant enthalpy(first) and this is carried away by the cooling water, rather.

The link given by imok2 discusses the OP's issue to some extent. I request you to have a look into that.

Heat output from the elevator may differ during upward and downward movements. My gut feeling is that there should be more heat output during downward transit.

Having said that, as a conservative approach, I will consider ASHRAE's equations. A bit of pep talk and leg pulling adds some heat load to otherwise cold forumwink.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources