×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

What bottled water is best for consumtion
3

What bottled water is best for consumtion

What bottled water is best for consumtion

(OP)
Hi
Sorry for such a base question I am about to ask.
Actually this does not involve work but my own personal life. But the info I gain I could take back to work with me.
I wish to know what is good water to drink. Out  of bottles.
Is distilled the best for human consumption
Is reverse osmosis the best for human consumption
Is spring water the best for human consuption?

Thanks

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

Plastic is gas permeable, so if you leave any plastic bottle of water in a contaminated room, your water gets contaminated.

Water out of the faucet is just fine for drinking. Cities spend millions of dollars every year ensuring so and proving it to the EPA.

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

Since you are "Marine/Ocean" I assume you want bottled water for drinking while on a boat.  RO water would be the best choice.  It would taste better as the primary reason.

Gary Schreiber, CWS VI
The Purolite Co.

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

Distilled water may be super pure, but it will lack many of the mineral resources your body has grown to depend on absorbing from water.

You might just fill up some reclaimed plastic bottles with water from your home tap.  A lot of that water originates from "springs".  In most locales in the USA it's as clean as any water you'll get from buying a bottle off the shelf.  What's most important, despite the apparent expense in treating it, tapwater is cheaper than bottled, too, fivefold.

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

Have a look at a label from the major bottled water brands (Aquafina and Dasani) and it states something to the effect of "...from a municipal source..."  Yeah, its just tapwater that has been filtered, ozonated, or what have you.  The residual chlorine in tapwater (removed during the "purification process ") is there for a reason.

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

I forgot to ask, perhaps someone else knows....Are there any regulatory requirements for bottled water akin to those for tapwater?  I have never heard of any - who knows what is really in that bottle?

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

(OP)
Thanks for the replies
DMcGrath
I am in Ontario Canada and read that there are tests for over a hundered things in municipal source but in bottles water there are only 3 things checked for by the Food and Drug administration.
I get my water from Water Depot where they take municipal water and run it thru RO an thier filters and UV so I get a feeling of security.
Not long a go in a nearby town (Walkerton Ontario) a bunch of people died from bad town water
Then I have a person tell me that there should be minerals in the drinking water and that RO takes out the minerals and the water leeched out my body minerals.
Hard to know what to believe.
Thanks for the comments

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

The idea of body minerals leaching out while consuming distilled water is already debunked. You should note that cells do die and new cells are generated regularly. Various tests conducted on human upto 30 ppm TDS showed no adverse effects ( the study, of which link I lost, was not carried below 30ppm). Further, if your food intake is balanced, you need not worry about the mineral intake via water.

You can consume water as long as it meets the WHO specifications of potable water. There are about 150 parameters but we check about 10 parameters, in industry. The recent issue of fatality in US, as I read in news papers, was due to E-Coli.

Some of the main parameters (but not limited to wink) are TDS, pH, Total Hardness, Total Alkalinity, TVC (and specific pathogens), Fluorides, Heavy Metals and Radio Active Elements. Minerals in water gives you taste if they are in reasonable proportions.

Anything that is naturally pure is better. Second comes RO water because it is economic to produce.

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

IN the states if bottles water is bottled and sold in the same state, it is up to the state to regulate.  This means in most states there is no regulation.  Once the bottles cross state lines it is up to the fed to regulate.  Last I heard there ws less then ten people in that dept to regulate the entire country.

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

Although Coke's Desani and Pepsi's Aquafina come from municipal sources, they are highly purified at the bottling plant by reverse osmosis and several other high-purity techniques and then minerals are added back to the product for taste and consistency.  If water comes from a regulated municipal source, then it is safe for human consumption.  However, even though it is safe, some people might not like the taste or worry about possible contamination from external sources such as corroding pipe.  For me, I drink tapwater at home, but when I'm working out of town and know I will be consuming a lot of water, I will purchase distilled water and mix it with bagged ice.  Distilled water is cheaper than other bottled waters like Desani or Aquafina.  There is nothing harmful about consuming distilled water.  Humans get almost all of the necessary minerals from food, not water.

S. Bush
www.water-eg.com

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

During the Crytosperidium and guiardia scare in Sydney many of the bottled water products were tested. It was safer to drink tap water.

Remember that your immune system actually benefits from being stressed occassionally. You will build up a natural immunity if you expose yourself.

I travel extensively throughout SE Asia and I drink tap water. My family and friends drink from bottles. I usually suffer less from gastric problems than they do!

If you do live that extra week from spending a mountain of money on Coke or Pepsi bottled water, who cares? If you spent the money on having a good time you would be streets a head. Get a life.

Geoffrey D Stone FIMechE C.Eng;FIEAust CP Eng
www.waterhammer.bigblog.com.au

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

I use tap water most of the time and buy spring water as a beverage.  Spring water tastes better than tap water.

Many codes and standards apply to various tests.  I am not aware of the mandatory testing reguluations.  I have three different gallon bottles of spring water in the kitchen right now.  They list the source.  Some of the springs are in Texas where I reside.  One spring is in Arkansas.  The latter likely places it in interstate commerce.

In the US, tap water is very safe.  This is not so true internationally.  I doubt that tap water is a health problem in Canada.

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

Burying one's head in the sand is not going to prevent someone from becoming ill from drinking contaminated water.

Over 3 million people annually die from avoidable water-related diseases. Dirty water from unsanitary conditions is the leading cause of death of children in Asia, and globally claims the life of one child every 30 seconds.

The most important thing insofar as bottled water goes is that the water has been properly disinfected, packaged, adn sealed. It is not going to make much difference whether the water is distilled, been through a reverse osmosis process, or came from a spring.

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

In terms of Canadian water, I suspect the most important criteria for bottled water selection is taste. There will be enough regulation in place to make sure all the other requirements are covered. Here in the north west UK, my prefered brand is the stuff in the tap. Down south where the water is harder, I prefer the cheapest bottle. In developing countries I opt for sealed bottles, preferably from the fridge. The other things, RO vs distilled etc aren't so important.

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

The original question is asking which is the BEST (of three types) for human consumption.  Setting taste aside, if the goal is to drink the purest water, of the three types mentioned, then the purest is distilled.

S. Bush
www.water-eg.com

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

that assumes that BEST = purest

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

Yes.  From Frankiee's second post, I'm assuming purity is the concern.  Mineral content relates to taste.  The regulatory standards set maximum limits on inorganic, organic, bacteria, and particles.  Their is no limit on minimum amount of contaminants.

S. Bush
www.water-eg.com

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

personally, I think the best water is contaminated with barley, hops and a small measure of alcohol but that's a topic for another thread!

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

Distilled water can dissolve the enamel on your teeth.

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

civilperson,

Your statement is correct, if tooth enamel is exposed to a continuous rinse with distilled water over a period of years.  In this application, however, distilled water is only contacting enamel for a matter of seconds before being replaced with saliva.     

S. Bush
www.water-eg.com

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

Here is a link to information published by a trusted source, the Water Quality Association.

http://www.aquaprix.com/LowTDS.pdf

It was interesting for me to note that only distilled water is consumed by personnel on U. S. Naval submarines.  The Navy has studied this and feels it is safe.

There are many other interesting facts, as well.

S. Bush
www.water-eg.com

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

In the US, the federal Food and Drug Administration regulates bottled water production as a food product.  I have not made a comparison of FDA regs versus EPA's drinking water regs, so I can't state an opinion as to which is more stringent.  As other posters have stated, the vast majority of US water suppliers do a very good job with maintaining compliance with EPA standards.  I personally refill a bottle from my local public water supplier.  As a side note, most people drink bottled water as a convenience, and not as a risk-avoidance technique.

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

I find myself amused that a popular brand of bottled water is "Deer Park".

I've been to Deer Park (TX) which is in the middle of refinery row.  I ain't drinkin' Nothin' there!  

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

I have not seen Deer Park water but know the Houston Ship Channel well.  Some of the spring water that I buy comes from the Jasper, TX area.  This too seems curious.  I have spring water from Arkansas too.  I prefer the spring water from Utopia - the south end of the Central Texas Hill Country.  No industry exists in the Utopia area; but agriculture nearby could polute the ground water.

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

Deer Park refers to a vacation resort in the Appalachian Mountains of Wsstern Maryland, not texas.

http://www.deerparkwater.com/KnowH2O/OurSources.aspx

http://www.mdmunicipal.org/cities/index.cfm?townname=DeerPark&;page=home

aitch2oh, if you want to compare the FDA standards to the EPA standards, here is the link that has a side by side comparison:

(http://www.bottledwater.org/public/pdf/IBWA05ModelCode_Mar2.pdf

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

I like carbonated water if not beer in countries where I don't trust the water for myself.  It is amazing how you can shove a cap on a bottle and it looks unopened.  While I appreciate stanier's comment on stressing the body, after 12 hours I was ready to have control back and feel I have stressed it enough.  Plus I would rather risk my health for the food.

RE: What bottled water is best for consumtion

This is a great post.  Here is my 2 cents:

-I don't trust TAP water.  EPA regulations are designed to allow the treatment we currently have and slowly add tighter regulations, otherwise many municipal water systems would be shutdown, especially in rural areas.  Many rural water have some pretty nasty water that can give you cancer and passes current EPA standards.

-Reverse Osmosis does not make pure water.  Small non polar molecules can pass through.

-Distillation does not make pure water.  Substances with similar boiling points to water will not be removed.

-I try and drink bottled water.  If you read the bottle, it tells you how it is processed.  Microfiltration does not remove and dissolved materials, just solids.  Carbon filtration removes organic contaminants, reverse osmosis removes all ions, and ozonation oxidizes everything.  I like RO water with added minerals the best. I think it tastes good.

-Some municipal systems have very good quality water and some don't.  Probably the best thing to do is get your water from a variety of sources.  This way you won't be continuously exposing yourself to water with contaminants that build up in your body over time.  Pretty much all municipal and bottled water is pretty safe from bacteria and virus.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources