Rafter Joint
Rafter Joint
(OP)
We are constructing a steel framed building with rafter spans of 24m. The steel has been fabricated in the factory by full strength butt welding of 2 x 12m long beams. This fabricated beam has then been delivered to site.
Our Client now claims the beams should not be welded in the middle. I am aware that for RC construction joints should be at 1/3 span or an area of low stress. However for steel construction I am not aware of any such requirement in fact it would seem unusual to me to contemplate cutting beams to introduce additional joints at a location other than midspan.
Am I wrong, is there any code requirement to locate joints away from midspan? Alternatively is there any statement anywhere that this is ok...
Our Client now claims the beams should not be welded in the middle. I am aware that for RC construction joints should be at 1/3 span or an area of low stress. However for steel construction I am not aware of any such requirement in fact it would seem unusual to me to contemplate cutting beams to introduce additional joints at a location other than midspan.
Am I wrong, is there any code requirement to locate joints away from midspan? Alternatively is there any statement anywhere that this is ok...






RE: Rafter Joint
RE: Rafter Joint
Incidentally, what type of construction is this? Is the rafter simply supported, in which case the maximum bending stress will be at mid span as you state, or a portal or moment frame, when the moment at mid-span will be less under vertical loads?
VB
RE: Rafter Joint
I am certainly not the most experienced poster here, and I will be quite curious to see what some of these guys have to say, however I cannot see a reason for a joint. Even if you calculate the thrust due to thermal expansion and use it as a load case on your wall (never a bad idea when someone brings something like this up), I would hazard a guess that it's going to be minimal and, therefore, inconsequential.
Keep us up to date!
Regards,
YS
B.Eng (Carleton)
Working in New Zealand, thinking of my snow covered home...
RE: Rafter Joint
If you beam is like this
______________________________
| | |
Then yeah usually you want to splice the beam at the inflection point (where moment is 0) so all you have to worry about is the shear at the connection. If you splice it at anywhere else (in your case looks like it is only 1 span simply supported), then you just have to make sure the connection is strong enough to the moment I guess. I dont have that much experience either with big beams like this.
RE: Rafter Joint
If you weren't designing the building the issue might be that the center reaction for a beam continuous over two spans is 10/8wl compared to wl for two simple span beams.
My fab shop is famous for wanting to use one long rafter instead of two. They usually fail to account for the fact that they are now putting more load on the center support beam .
RE: Rafter Joint
RE: Rafter Joint
The splice is normally done as a bolted connection for transport and to avoid site welding. It is even better structurally if it is fully welded (butt weld in the flanges, fillet weld in the web).
As the structural engineer, you need to point out to the client that this is a perfectly acceptable way of joining two pieces of steel together. Point out that some welded beams are actually formed by welding plates together into an I shape.
Regards
csd
RE: Rafter Joint
RE: Rafter Joint
The beam is fabricated from 2 x 12m beams. They are welded with a full penetration butt weld at flanges and web. An additional splice plate is added with fillet welds to each side of the web splice (I don't think this is needed).
The rafters (beams) are bolted to the columns (which to clarify a couple of points mentioned in the responses are 24m apart). These beams are the roof rafters so the loads are deadload, service load plus a small allowance for people working on the roof.
The Client thinks that the beams should not be welded at midspan and that they should be welded at a point of lower moment. My point is that as the joints are equivalent to the strength of the parent material it would be a bit ridiculous to cut the 12m means to weld them together again to make the 24m beams from 3 pieces.
RE: Rafter Joint
RE: Rafter Joint
RE: Rafter Joint
With full penetration welds done in the shop you should have no trouble.
Just as a side note, in the US, with special permits the company I work for has shipped glulam beams 105' long. Regulations very from state to state. Here in Minnesota some one was able to ship a 250' long industrial dryer.
The big reason for limiting length in most cases is cost. When the load reaches a certain point it requires police escort and there are restrictions on when the load can be moved. It might cost a contractor more to move a 100' beam 20 miles than to move a 75" beam 500 miles.
RE: Rafter Joint
Just tell them 'may pen rai'(it doesnt matter)!
sawasdee (goodbye)
csd
RE: Rafter Joint
khawp khun khrap. phom ja bok kow....
RE: Rafter Joint
I have been there a couple of times, and picked up a few terms.