×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

changing speed of pump

changing speed of pump

changing speed of pump

(OP)
Hye,
I have a 40" centrifugal impeller in a slurry pump.
Sometimes, in case that lower duty required, we change to 38" impeller.
I want to install speed reducer, instead of impeller changing.
What should be the speed reducing, so pumping will be equivalent to the one with 38" impeller?

RE: changing speed of pump

The two impellers cannot be exactly geometrically similar if they both must fit in the same casing. So similarity laws would not be exactly true.

But head should be proprtional to size squared. So the 38 inch impeller would give
(38/40)^2 times the original head at the same rpm.

RE: changing speed of pump

Micy,
Considering energy consumption you may not get much benifit but in operational point of view it will be of great use. The capacity of the pump is directly proportional to the diameter and speed of the pump. So the new speed of the pump will be (38/40)times speed.

But it's always better to check the actual duty point at which the pump is running. Then you may further reduce the speed and can conserve some energy.

RE: changing speed of pump

Before considering freq. control you should perhaps be made aware of the laws of affinty for pumps:

n: normal
x: new speed
Q=flow
H=head
P=power

figure out the units youself: Strick SI units will work with no "factors". If you use american/brithish unit you will need some factors)

Q_n/Q_1=n/x
(H_n/H_x)^2=(n/x)^2
and
(P_n/P_x)^3=(n/x)^3

This is with the assupmtion that the efficiency remain constant. In practise this is _NOT_ true but normally for small changes its not important.

From these formulas you can see that a different speed corresponds to parralel shifting of the pump curve. Since your sysm resistance curve remains constant you should be able to select the new speed grahpically.

Best Regards

Morten

RE: changing speed of pump

Also remember that changing the running conditions of a slurry pump can change the wear life of the parts. You might want to check w/ your pump vendor for recommendation.

RE: changing speed of pump

since your application is working with both the 40" dia and the 38" dia, it would seem that you are generating sufficient head with the 38" impeller. Hence, as previously mentioned, you are looking at a volume reduction of 38/40 or about 5%, and that is what your desired speed change should be.   Note, you could run with the 40" impeller and slow down, or with the 38" impeller and speed up.  However, the impeller and suction plate wear will increase with the speed up option.
good luck
mac

RE: changing speed of pump

Are you thinking of a VFD or some mechanical speed reducing system, perhaps fixed?  If VFD, you have complete flexibility of what % speed to run at, and you can easily tune your pump to system performance requirement at any point in the future.  These are expensive, but compared to swapping impellers, should pay back quickly.

I wouldn't assume that the 38" impeller was perfectly chosen for your low demand condition, so trying to match this exactly with a calculated speed reduction may simply be an engineering exercise where application of infinity laws is imprecise.

Steve

RE: changing speed of pump

System and pump charecteristic determines the operating point of your slurry pump. If there is a significant static head in your system. Pump efficiency may decrease. I will not advice VFD  because you will be loosing 4-5% to cover the VFD losses.

RE: changing speed of pump

To 315636: Thanks for the feedback.  My rule of thumb, coming from VFD representatives is to expect 1 to 2% loss in the VFD.  I would be real interested in seeing or hearing of any real world experience (from recent years, considering improvements in drives) that would show the rep's claims to be a little too optimistic.

What do you think about what I call "lack of a magic number" in terms of pumping capacity needed? i.e. neither 40" or 38" is a magic number, but puts the process somewhere close to where it needs to be, and always higher if the system works at all.  If the real process demand were 5% less in each case, slowing down the pumping rate GPM would lessen the head losses associated with the flow, perhaps paying for the VFD losses.  Just an idea.  We don't pump too much slurry here in Hawaii, perhaps the viscosity would mean a limited effect on flow head losses, compared to flow rate....?

PacificSteve

RE: changing speed of pump

315636

Generally advicing against VFD becuase it uses 3-5% of when may installtions throttles 20-30% of the energy seems like a bad advice. The question deals with a situation where a 40" impellar can be replaced with a 38" implellar. A rough estimation of the saved power would then be: (1-(38/40)^3)*100%=14% For such a large installation this could be serious money.

Best Regards

Morten

RE: changing speed of pump

I have heard of the VS coupling and the KS coupling. It is an electrical componenet which is installed between the motor and the pump. I have seen it being used during start up of the slurry pump. They keep the speed minimum thus increasing the torque and reducing the power required for start up. I dont' exactly know whether it will be useful for your purpose. May be somenone can help you at this point.

all the best.

RE: changing speed of pump

Pacific Steve,

Don't let the VFD guys pull the wool over your eyes.  That was the efficiency for the switching portion of the drive only.  The transformer losses to go from AC to DC are not included in the 1%-2% losses they talk about.  The best drive effs I have seen are about 96%.

I worked on a project with a 2000 HP VFD where there were LD clauses for unit (pump/motor/drive string) efficiency.  I had one VFD mfg claiming 96.8%.  I told them that if the overall pump/motor/drive eff was off (at full speed), we would pull out the drive, run the unit across the line, and measure the eff again.  If the efficiency rose by more than 1/96.8% I would hit him with the associated penalty. Suddenly the guaratee dropped by 1.1%!  

RE: changing speed of pump

Slagathor,

Thanks for the tips.  Its like pulling teeth to get good info from the manufacturers, but I like your strategy.

PacificSteve

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources