×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

concrete failure along steel surface

concrete failure along steel surface

concrete failure along steel surface

(OP)
Hi everyone; looking for some great tips on this one.

There has been a failure of a concrete bulkhead(headwall) at the mine where i work.  The likely cause of this failure is from a loader dumping above this headwall and the vibrations travelling down thru the steel and into the concrete surrounding the steel.  

I am advising for the existing concrete to all be chippped away, the rebar to be replaced and fresh concrete to be installed ( a basic reno job).
My questions are:
Is there a material that can be placed between the steel and concrete to dampen the vibrations.  perhaps high density rubber or some form of structural insulation?
Also; how long should the concrete be left to cure before introducing it to vibration and stress?

thnks a bunch............

RE: concrete failure along steel surface

You do not want to place anything between the rebar and the concrete.  The purpose of the rebar is to reinforce the concrete, typically in tension, but also in compression and shear in some instances.  It is imperative that the concrete and steel bond well together for this to work.

Your presumptive cause of failure does not seem plausible.  The actions you have described result in low frequency vibrations.  I suspect the magnitude of the load is more prominent as a cause than the vibrations that occur as a result of the load.

If you could describe the way the concrete failed it would be a bit more helpful.

Concrete transmits vibration, not just the steel.  Yes, they transmit sound wave at different velocities, but both are fairly high, particularly with low frequencies.  High frequency sound or vibration in concrete gets dispersed because of the voids and other discontinuities and path interruptions that occur in concrete, as high frequencies generally tend to have low amplitudes that can't "jump" the discontinuities.

RE: concrete failure along steel surface

I agree the cause of this incident is unlikely related to vibration.  In order to  get an idea of the structure, is this a surface or underground location??  What type of machinery is dumping the load??  A 2 yard scooptram or a 200 tonne rocktruck??  

How long has the structure been in place  days / weeks / years??   

Any nearby blasting with high peak particle velocities???



RE: concrete failure along steel surface

(OP)
thanks for the replies .

the machine that is dumping into the the hopper above the concrete headwall is a 988 loader; this is above ground inside of a building.
the concrete has just disintegrated; falling out onto the floor in large chunks.  the concrete that is still in place is attached to the rebar that was used to reniforce the concrete.
if vibration isn't the problem perhaps the caocrete needs to be thickened to supply it with more mass to provide strength?

eli.

RE: concrete failure along steel surface

concrete needs to cure until it has reached it's design strength - which you need to establish.  It sounds like you may need a structural concrete suitable for heavy, dynamic loading 4,000 or 5,000 psi.  You need to also check to make sure you have sufficient steel.  You can make this renovation, but until you check the design, you may find that you will continue to have problems.

RE: concrete failure along steel surface

  Sounds  as if you are suffering failure due to impact and/or abrasion.  Headwall is a term I am not familiar with so Im having some trouble envisioning the exact geometry.  Nevertheless it also sounds as if repair work will cause a significant interruption to production.  You should probably investigate the use of steel wear plates or used rail to protect the concrete from direct impact from the load in the 966.... if its sulphide rock, there are some really heavy  stones in that bucket.

RE: concrete failure along steel surface

I am currently designing a retaining wall to resist the impact from a CAT 988G loader.  The wall I am replacing was damaged severely from a combination of the loader impact and steel corrosion (caused by the rebar being exposed to large cracks from the impact force of the loader).  Due to limited area, the client opted for bollards filled with concrete to protect the wall rather than pour a ~25' wide 2'-6" thick footing for a 3' thick wall.  The bollards are placed so the tires hit them when the loader's bucket is over the load-in pit.

You need to realize that the loader weighs 110k without any attatchment or load.  It will be very expensive to build the monument required to keep the loader from demolishing the wall.  However, bollards may not be feasable in your case.  If there is repeated abrasion on the wall, you may want to look into some type of high strength coating on the concrete surface.  I used Permacoat 4000 as manufactured by chemproof (www.chemproof.com).

I hope this helps...

RE: concrete failure along steel surface

elibintner,

sounds to me like you need to talk to a structural engineer with heavy industrial experience on this one, it is not something that can be commented on accurately without actually seeing the site.

There may be other peripheral clues on the site that a more experienced eye would pick up.

The most important thing that you should be aware of as an engineer is the limitations of your knowledge.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources