×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant
2

Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

(OP)
I am investigating the best method to abate hydrogen sulfide at a wastewater plant. We are looking to install a Biofilter. The Biofilter advantage is that it does not require any hazardous chemicals to operate. We used it sucessfully at one of our lift stations, however it does cost more up front. Does anyone have experiences with H2S treatment with the Biofilter or other technologies?

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

You may want to look into applying Magnesium Hydroxide in your system. It is relatively inexpensive and it eliminates odor problems.

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

I would like to know abou the advantages to use nitrate solutions to solve the sulfide production problems? I need to knoW procedures and enterprise that do the addition of calcium or sodium nitrate.  

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

Have you checked for H2S in your sewers lately?  We are experiencing excess H2S in our interceptor sewer which is corroding the crown of the RCP.  We are trying a nitrate salt, Bioxide, to suppress the H2S and it seems to be working well.  We pump about 20 gpd into a wet well in the upstream lift station which gives us about a 5 ppm residual going into the interceptor sewer.

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

I am currently designing a large sewage gravity filled interceptor sewer (10 km long at 3.6m internal diameter).  We have the potential to generate large volumes of hydrogen sulphide which can be expelled at a high rate when a storm surge advances along the sewer.

Our solution to treat the gas is to use activated carbon.  essentially, the sewer vent passes through a "dustbin" (or garbage can for my US cousins) filled with IVP-type activated carbon.  This is able to remove 98% of H2S at a relative humidity of 100% with a flow of 0.45 cubic metres per second.  The carbon has a finite lifespan but replacement is simple.  You lift the lid off the bin, hoover out the used up carbon and replace it with fresh carbon.

Regards  

Andy Machon
Andy@machona.freeserve.co.uk

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

(OP)
Ginger,

Can you tell me what's the approximate changeout for the carbon unit and the material cost?

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

hapm

Sorry for delay in replying, my 10 year old son inverted a cup of tea into the keyboard!! It has taken me a few days to replace the keys.

I will need to consult my data at the office but I think the prices are affected locally so you would get a better handle on the prie by approaching a carbon supplier close to you.  For the flows we have I believe that the 1.5m diameter, 2m high nbin will last about one year on our contract.  I will try to get the prices for tomorrow.



Andy Machon
Andy@machona.freeserve.co.uk
 
 

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

hapm

OK,  The units we have installed are 2.22m diameter by 1.765m high and look like black polyester/polypropylene trash cans with a 250mm diameter inlet and outlet.

From our suppliers literature:-  The unit can purify air streams of up to 1500 cubic metres per hour by activated carbon adsorption when using IVP carbon. The pressure drop to acieve this is 3000 Pascals. There are 510 kg of carbon pellets in the unit which can remove up to 60% of its own weight in pollutants.  

The rate of carbon replacement is entirely dependant on the amount of polluted gas you put through the unit (but you could work this backwards from 60% of 510kg and relate this to your polluted gas H2S content to get a rough idea I suppose).
Your carbon supplier should be able to visit site and test the carbon you have to determine what life it has left.

A new unit of this size is about £5000, but I don't have the figures for replacement carbon

Hope this helps

Regards

Andy Machon
Andy@machona.freeserve.co.uk
 
 

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

(OP)
Ginger thanks.

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

I know of a facility that uses ferric chloride injection upstream to control HS formation/release.  If interested, I can get further details (dosage levels, contact names/numbers, etc.).

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

(OP)
I'll check on your ferric chloride and may followup with you later if that's ok with you. Thanks.

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

Does anyone know of a standard method or emissions factor for calculating h2s emissions from wastewater (lagoons, etc.) -- or especially anyone who has expertise in this area?  Thanks

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

Have you ever thought designing the system in HDPE?

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

We have constructed a ferrous sulphate dosing unit to eliminate problems occuring at generators using methane. It was located at the main inlet of the treatment plant. But i remember we had long discussions about where to locate the unit. Ferrous sulphate is a by pruduct of steel indusry and it was very cheap in the area where the plant was located. Since the plant has 700,000 m3/day capacity, we used ferrous sulphate instead of ferric chloride. If interested, I can give further details.

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

Are you sure of your 500 ppm H2S.  This will make a very corrosive gas/solution when mixed with water.  I had all sorts of trouble when H2S levels were above 100 ppm with a Dual Fuel Diesel Engine with valves pipework and gas compressors failing due to this problem.

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

(OP)
I have installed a "biofilter" system which extracts H2S from contaminated air by converting it into elemental sulfur. The initial cost is relatively high (approx. $700,000) but the long term operating cost is low. The filter media consists of trays filled with compost like material containing microbial flora that break down H2S. The elemental sulfur accumulates in the compost. The compost is replaced as the sulfur builds up.

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

You could try nutriox, we use it in terminal pumping stations in the UK.

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

Biofilters have been installed by Bovis Lend Lease on plants in Australaia and New Zealand. Dersign has been by CH2MHill. They are fine for H2S but are challenged if you have ammonia. So a lime stabilisation plant would be challenged.

Key issue is to cover the unit to prevent drenching by rain water but provide sprays so you can control moisture. Apart from that the costs to run are minimal once the right mix of soil is establish.

For smaller sysytems Cleanteq in Melbourne manufature containorised units that are fully equipped. Useful for small towns.

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

Hi, I am involved in the operations of a waste water treatment works which handles 90 % domestic sewage and 10 % treated industrial effluent. At present the foul odours are treated with a caustic scrubber system. I want to know the impact on the aeration basins if the foul air is injected into the aeration basins. Volume of air will be 100000 m3/h with an average 400 ppm h2s. volume of the aeration basins will be 15000 m3 with an MLSS of 2500 mg/l.

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

H2S is only one of the many facets of Digester gas quality.  A simple answer cannot be given to the question on removal of H2S without addressing all gas quality issues especially if burning in a gas engine.  Major reduction in O/M costs (approaching natural gas O&M) can be achieved with a properly engineered solution.

This typically would encompass dehumidification, dust removal, H2S reduction, Siloxane removal, pressure management and temperature management.

Some engine suppliers don't necessarily make this obvious as it is not their core business to provide the technology or expertise in this area and they are happy to rebuild engines and sell more parts.

Feel free to contact me if you want to know more.
email warwick.cutfield@meritec.org

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

Magnesium Hydroxide will reduce H2S levels in sewage and has the added benefit of aiding sludge settling in clarifiers and digestors.  Much better and cheaper then using hazzardous chemicals.

Mike Bensema
www.dutchmenservices.com

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

Any comment on the ferric Chloride injection into the anaerobic digestor for H2S control.  Can somebody refer to site or excel spreadsheet for calculating dosage required.  We have a scenario of 800 - 1200 ppm in 35000 m3/d total gas produced.

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

Faced with the problem of high gas cleaning (H2S removal)costs, resulting in high power generation costs using gas engines, we evaluated some 26 different systems. Finally we narrowed down to 4 systems with the potential for low gas cleaning costs.
We have now tried out one system which removes H2S down to well below 100ppmv from the biogas generated from distillery spent wash at a cost of around 0.5UScent/m3 of gas cleaned....considering all costs (fixed, operating, financing, etc).  But I am wondering if the ammonia, siloxanes etc will change this scenario if we try biogas from other sources.........can anyone advise the level of and impact of (biogas) ammonia and siloxanes, etc on equipment?........and to what level removal of these is required?
Thanks all.
atulbhalla46@hotmail.com

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

Thanks to Stanier for the referral. I am from CleanTeQ in Melbourne, Australia who manufacture compact BioFilter systems for many industries, including wastewater treatmment.

Point sources treated include manholes on rising mains, pump stations, inlet works, sludge digesters etc.

Generally BioFilters are used individually to treat H2S levels up to 30ppm. Above this level you would probably combine them with other technologies - Caustic Scrubber/BioFilter or BioFilter/Activated Carbon systems are variations on this theme to treat variable emissions.

BioTrickling Filters are also now being developed to treat highly variable H2S emissions up to 500ppm. BioFilters or Activated Carbon may then be used to polish emissions.

Hope this information is useful.

ctairman
info@cleanteq.com

RE: Abatement of hydrogen sulfide gas from wastewater treatment plant

Dear All, check out www.zeolife.co.uk , they are manufacturing bespoke H2S Filters using Natural Zeolite,
markbaty@euremica.com

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources