Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
(OP)
3/4" dia ladders rungs, 3/16 fillet welded all around, each end, to flat bar 3/8 x 3 stringers. The rungs do not penetrate the stringers.
Are the supports a fixed or pinned connection?
Thank you ...
Are the supports a fixed or pinned connection?
Thank you ...






RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
Why are you considering this? Are you designing a unique ladder? Most of ladder designs are standard and are well proven.
Keep it simple.
Regards,
Lutfi
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
Does OSHA still have design requirements on ladders?
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
http:
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
Regards,
Lutfi
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
When checking into OSHA standards on ladders, also hunt up their proposed standard- be aware of upcoming changes.
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
If, however, your rung was welded to a 28 gage steel plate, or perhaps (getting silly) - a 3" wide wet noodle, then it would approach a simple span condition.
With a typical 3/8" x 2 1/2" steel stringer bar on each side, you most certainly would have to model the steel to see, but you'd be really wasting your time. Just design the durn thing as a simple span.
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
In the past, I have figured ladder rungs to be required to support a 200 lb concentrated load at mid-span for a conservative pinned support. Similar to what JStephen stated, even with the required minimum 16" rung span, the required Sx (w/o safety factor)for this condition is equal to the actual Sx of a typical A36 3/4" rung, based on Fb=0.6Fy.
According to http
"Each step or rung of a fixed ladder (not implying the connection) must be able to support a load of at least 250 pounds applied in the middle of the step or rung." I ask, is this a revision to a former standard? Further, when researching pre-fab stair treads, a load table in a McNichols catalog states: "Maximum tread length based on 300 lb concentrated load ... at center of tread length." Is McNichols suggesting a revision? In my opinion, the reality of this situation is that when combining engineering with an apparent societal condition, at least in the United States, people are getting larger and thus heavier. I believe we need to consider this.
Considering this, the 3/4" A36 does not calc as acceptable for a pinned connection. Am I wrong? Am I splitting hairs? Am I inducing complexity in engineering? (Please, I do not intend to elaborate that thread)
Thank you all very much for your comments. Any more thoughts?
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
However, you're wise to consider that your actual loading may exceed that.
If you're expecting that the workers will be ferrying tools and equipment up the ladder, I'd definitely increase the load.
--------------------
How much do YOU owe?
http://www.brillig.com/debt_clock/
--------------------
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
Through the use of the intent of this forum, considering the section props of the side stringers, I have concluded that, with all-around fillets I will consider the end connections as fixed, which, by far, exceeds what is Fb.
Last thoughts; Yes, ladders have long been considered a proven miscellaneous structure. I appreciate that. However, considering previous comments, we tend to be conservative for various reasons. For those who may want to consider wider ladders with longer rung spans, not necessarily wanting to increase the 3/4" bar size, having formerly worked for a fabricator, I have seen ladder rungs inserted into holes in the siderail stringers and then either filleted on the inside or butt welded on the outside. Something to consider ...
Thank you all for you input ...
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
Realistically, when you climb on these ladders, they don't feel marginal in strength. A bending failure in the rung just means a bent rung, not a broken rung (the welds on the ends are much stronger than the rung itself). A better reason to increase rung size would be for a better grip.
Inserting the rungs into holes in the stringers doesn't increase the rung bending strength. I have seen this done, but to be honest, I think it got started in the days of riveting and just never died off. I've never actually heard a reason for it other than "That's the way we've always done it!"
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
As you may have noticed, I'm green in determining the difference between a pinned and fixed connection - I may even need to post a thread asking the real difference between the two when referring to a continuous multi-span beam.
I do understand that inserting the bar into the strigner holes does not increase the rung Fb, but, if the holes were no greater than 1/16" dia larger than the bar, would not the fact that the "top flange" of the bar, coming in intimate contact with the top of the hole, along with the all around welding, contribute to the fixity of the connection? I realize I'm going into more detail than necessary for this particular application, but, I'm simply trying to better understand a fixed connection.
Thank you for your time.
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
Perhaps design them as acceptable when pinned but realise there is 'some' extra capacity, due to fixity? Just a thought.
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
However, it does not mean that the connection as a whole cannot rotate. To use JAE's example, the angle between the rod and the wet noodle may not change, but you can certainly imagine the wet noodle bending and rotating as the rod tries to deflect. Then the deflection and moment diagram of the rod will look very similar to that of the rod as a simply-supported member. Depending on the stiffness of the connecting member, some of the moment in the rod may get transmitted to, say, your plate, runner, or wet noodle. Because of this, you will have less moment in the rod, but it won't be the same as if the rod were connected to a fixed support. Remember, a fixed connection and a fixed support are two different things. A support is assumed to have infinite rigidity, whereas your runner or wet noodle at the connection is elastic. When you do your model of the rung then, you will have most likely pinned supports with a rotational spring support. The stiffness of the spring will help prevent the rod from bending but not as much as a fixed support. The stiffness of the spring will depend on the appropriate stiffness of the supporting runner or the ladder.
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
RE: Ladders Rungs - Fixed or Pinned?
This is like an I-shaped beam terminating into, and welded to, an I-shaped support "girder" (beams at 90 degrees to each other). Because the support girder, being I-shaped, has small torsional stiffness, the reaction delivered to it by the beam will be a vertical force, with little or no moment. All the connection stiffening in the world won't change that. Replace the I-shaped girder with a closed tubular shape and the connection now has the potential to transfer moment in addition to the vertical force.