Sizing Breaker for Pump
Sizing Breaker for Pump
(OP)
I have a 45KW Centrifugal Pump running on 400V with FLC =85A and AutoTrans Starter. How should i size the MCCB protective breaker ?
Thanks
Thanks
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS Come Join Us!Are you an
Engineering professional? Join Eng-Tips Forums!
*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail. Posting GuidelinesJobs |
|
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
thanks
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
I'm not familiar with AT starters I'll let someone else hit your MCCB question.
Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
This is for a conventional inverse time breaker. The starting current factor of 8 is for direct online starting.
The starting current with an autotransformer starter will be much less. That's the point of autotransformer starting.
Although the Canadian code is somewhat harmonized with the NEC, the use and rating of instantaneous trip circuit breakers is one area with significant differences.
You had best state your location and the codes that you are subject to and let someone with local knowledge answer this.
respectfully
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
So based on the motor / pump load, what kind of starter is hest for me? DOL , Star-Delta or AutoTrans ? Is it true that if i were to select DOL, i'll have to size my breaker to 8x the FLA of the pump ? and howabout for S/D starter?
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
DOL is the cheapest but can give voltage sag issues to surrounding equipment if your power source is spongy (dimming lights, resetting equipment, extinguishing HID lighting, raising your metering demand factor). Depending on the driven load it can also cause more wear and tear.
As I said autotrans is not in my experience.
The favored starter around here is a Soft Starter. These are electronic devices that let you set the maximum inrush current and the length of the starting time. They provide very gentle starts and disturb the power source the least. They can even allow starting some motors from sources that they couldn't possibly be started from normally.
They aren't cheap but they are starting to compete favorably with other systems like S/D as they are coming down in price. Your motor size is just at the top of reasonably priced units. You should at least research them. Scotty will tell you a make or three to look at.
Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
Relaxjack, the type of starter you select depends on what your goal is.
Reduced Voltage Auto Transformer (RVAT) starters can provide the best bang for the buck in terms of line current to motor current because of the transformer action. Their limitation is in that they only have 3 steps of adjustment, 50, 65 or 80% voltage so if one of those doesn't work you have to take a big step to the next size up and that means more torque that you may not need. They also trade one big torque hit for two smaller ones, not as good for the motor as soft starters. Lastly they are very large and heavy and have a limited starting duty, usually much lower than the motor they are controlling. I only recommend RVATs when there is a severe problem with voltage drop or an undersized portable generator.
Reduced Voltage Solid State (RVSS) have infinite adjustability so they can be tuned to provide a very smooth transition-less acceleration, no excess torque (unless you want it). They are best for the load and motor, but motor current = line current, so they are a compromise when it comes to their effect on the incoming line voltage. Still, most people get along fine with them. They take up less space and floor weight than RVATs and typically have the same or better starting duty as the motor. They also cost less than RVATs (unless you are shopping poorly), and if you have a pump, they can be very handy for soft stopping to reduce water hammer. RVATs can't do that.
Forget Start-Delta, too many potential problems. I know that lots of people use them, but that's just because they are cheaper than RVSS. If they really knew what they are doing to the motor, power train and power supply they would run away.
http:/www.jraef.com
Eng-Tips: Help for your job, not for your homework Read FAQ731-376
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
Given the low inertia and the speed/load characteristics of centrifugal pumps, direct online starting will work well on all but the weakest systems.
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
The only thing you may have trouble with is the breaker's instantaneous trip settings. Motors who's LRC is 800% of FLC rather than the usual 600% are typically the new high efficiency motors. One aspect of their increased efficiency design is often a tendency to have higher peak magnetization current, the brief instantaneous inrush that happens as the stator core becomes magnetized. In standard motor designs this has been from 800 - 1300% or FLC for less than 1 cycle, and the instantaneous magnetic trips of circuit breakers were adjustable to those levels to accommodate it. In the newer energy efficient designs it can be as high as 2000% FLC and some breakers are not capable of being adjusted high enough, or the default settings from the factory will be too low and nuisance trip. It's not a big deal, just something to look out for.
http:/www.jraef.com
Eng-Tips: Help for your job, not for your homework Read FAQ731-376
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
jraef; There is a note in the 2006 Canadian Code that says that instantaneous trip breakers may be provided with a "dampening means" to allow ride through of the first cycle transient.
The CEC also allows a setting of 215% of locked rotor current for instantaneous trip breakers.
A conventional inverse time with instantaneous trip breaker will often have an instantaneous setting that is 500% to 1000% of rated full load current.
For a 100 amp motor load, the breaker would be rated at 250 amps.
The instantaneous trip will be adjustable from 1250 amps to 2500 amps.
I hope that this explains how we get a motor started when the starting current appears to exceed the rating of the circuit breaker.
respectfully
RE: Sizing Breaker for Pump
Do you realize that there are breakers just for motors? You buy them for the motor's FLA, (plus a little), Then they have a screw adjustment that you set to a point that just allows the motor to start without tripping.
Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com