×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....
2

You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

(OP)
All,

I am looking for a means to power an LED through vibration.  The vibration would come from an engine being on and the LED would only be on when the engine is on.  I've seen flashlights that you can shake and they will store a charge for a period of time.  I am looking for something that will provide a continuous flow of current and also charge a rechargable battery at the same time.

Regards,

Rich....viking

Richard Nornhold, PE

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

It all depends on what vibration frequency and amplitude you have available. A little device with a coil and a neodym or other rare earth magnet will certainly generate power enough to light an LED. It is mostly a question of selecting the right number of turns and the right magnet. I would say it is much easier than making a potato light the LED.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

(OP)
skogsgurra,

What if we vibrated the potato?  Would this make it easier?

Regards,

Rich....viking

Richard Nornhold, PE

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

Vibration is a small movement whereas a larger movement is preferable. If either the coil or the magnet were lightly suspended by springs (or springy material) the motion amplitude could be amplified to give a more usable motion range.

I guess the first step is to try some simple experiments with coils and magnets to see what order of magnitude you need. Make sure you use schottkey diode(s). Don't use a bridge rectifier. Either do it half wave or centre tap the coil and do a bi-phase bridge (two diodes).

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

(OP)
logbook,

We were figuring on using springs to amplify the motion.  On the electrical side of things, please explain why the use of shotkey diodes?  Is this just for rectification purposes or is this to protect the flow of current back from the batteries?  Sorry to ask, but you are talking to a slow witted mechancial engineer.

Regards,

Rich....viking

Richard Nornhold, PE

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

The Shottky diodes, presumably, were suggested because their forward voltage drops are smaller than that of standard junction diodes, ~0.2V vs. ~0.7V.

TTFN



RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

You presumably have a rotating shaft somewhere... Why screw with this 100 hour project?  You could run a toy motor with an O-ring and have some useful energy.  Or use a rubber follower and just let it run on any rotating member. Or worse but still better 'make' a generator by clamping two magnets on a shaft and have them pass a coil. (still a pain in the butt)

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

Any chance of wrapping a few coils around your alternator on the outside?  Better yet, just tap into the alternator itself ;)

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

I would skip the diodes. Just connect the AC to the LED. You will not have enough voltage to destroy the LED with reverse voltage. And your magnetic circuit will not saturate from the DC component. No probs. And, yes, shaking the potato will probably be good. But it will not light the LED.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

Getting an LED to light with power generated by vibration is probably not too difficult to do, but charging batteries could  be substantially more difficult.  I agree with ItSmoked and Macgyvers2000; can you just generate the power from the rotational motion somewhere on the engine?  You'd probably be able to get a LOT more power, much more easily.

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

I question whether you could generate enough.  If the engine shakes that much, you have a design problem.  Second problem is are you going to read this in sunlight? I have my doubts of the success of this project.

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

Prediction: another long thread...

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

If you slice the potatoe, will you have a self powering chip?

Will dicing a potatoe cube it's power output?

Will you get more voltage from a potatoe if you slice it up and then stack the slices (AKA Pringle's cell)?

Are Potatoe Buds (dried potatoe flakes) AKA a 'dry cell'?

This could get long indeed...

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"It's the questions that drive us"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

Hahahah not with my help!  Besides why wouldn't the LED and diodes and 'what all' shake apart soon anyway..

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

Is this a school project ?

I recall when I was about five, we used to stick plastic features onto potatoes to make funny faces.  This will not help you with your project,  But I thought I would just mention it.

Making an engine driven vibrating potato light up sounds like much more fun. We never had anything like that when I was a kid :o{

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

Just don't fry the potato(e) (big fan of Dan, who was that Vice President).  Oil is an insulator!

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

Easy now. There are people trying to solve an engineering problem here.

Analysis:
Q1: Is this a school problem?
A1: Do not think so. Then we would have input like "A piece of machinery is weghing 10 pounds. It contains a rotating member weighing 5 pounds. The rotational speed is 1800 RPM and there is an imbalance that can be represented by a 2 oz mass positioned two inches off the rotational axis.

We do not have such a specification -> Probably not a school question.

Q2: Would a school kid be mature enough to make the heading about the potato?
A2: No. School kids are way too serious about "science".

Q3: Will there ever be enough energy to light an LED?
A3: Yes, probably. It takes only a few milliwatts to make one of those new LEDs shine very bright.

Conclusion: This is serious engineering stuff. Don't ridicule us/those that work on the problem.  winky smile

BTW, DQ is one of my absolute favourites. A natural born comedian!

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

You are quite right Gunnar.

A suitable ac voltage should light a Led, without any additional rectification.  And I like the resonance idea, either with a mechanical spring/mass, or a tuned LC tank circuit. You would just need to be fairly sure of your exact vibration frequency, or it might cause more problems than it solves.

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

My favorite DQ quote was him standing in front of a large crowd in Latin America and says, "It's times like these I wish I had studied Latin harder in high school..."  What a moron ;)

Some of the higher quality/efficiency LEDs on the market the last couple of years are very low power.  A 2-3mA draw makes them uncomfortably bright, so if you're willing to pulse them for short current draws, this is indeed a workable project.

The last several years has seen "body" powered items, objects powered by the typical movement of a person as they go about their daily life.  There's enough power to keep a real-time clock going, as well as an LCD display.  Don't have the time to Google right now, but that would be a good thing to look for.  I don't remember if it was typically piezo or magnet/coil setup.  If a body can create enough power for that, I see no reason why an engine can't light an LED.

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

(OP)
All,

Sorry I didn't check back sooner.  I've allowed there to be discontent among the masses by not answering questions.  This is not a school project.  One of the areas my company is involved in is consumer product development.  We see a lot of strange ideas and some that you figure would never sell, sell like crazy.  We are working with a motorcycle aftermarket parts company on a design for a lighted LED foot peg.  One of the requirements was that this unit would be a direct replacement for the existing foot peg.  This means they don't won't the customer to have to run wires back to the electrical harness and/or battery.  We starting kicking around ideas and one of them that came up was similar to the faraday flashlights that are now on the market.  This is the concept we are trying to implement, but a couple of questions came to mind and that's why I turned to the experts.  

Yesterday we went out and bought one of the flashlights (very expensive $20) to take apart and experiment.  The answer to the question is that you can generate enough power to charge two 3V batteries in series and light the LED.  The problem is that you need at least 1.5" of actuation on the permenant magnet.  We haven't ruled out this concept, but we are looking at using a small air scoop and using a rotary vane to provide the needed power.

Thank you all for your feedback and I apologize for creating a potentially unending thread with my eye catching "Potato" subject.  

Regards,

Rich....viking
  

Richard Nornhold, PE

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

I recently encountered an arts student who was using potato batteries to light leds.

At last count she had about 20lbs of less than fresh potatos (or potatoes) lighting several dozen leds.

I forget exactly what the object of the exercise was, since it was artistic & I'm a rude mechanical as it were.

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

You are not going to get the energy you need from a piezo to light LEDs continuously. Just look at the flashlight - mass/distance/velocity of that magnet through the coils to charge a supercap, and how long you have to shake it to charge it up. Now think of the mass of the piezo lever (a few grams) and the vibration distance (a couple of millimeters) and the efficiency of an inexpensive piezo - a no-go approach.

"Parasitic power" or "Power Harvesters" are being investigated for all sorts of sensor and low-power RF applications. However, due to the limited power nature of such devices, the applications are very limited, and very specific to the application.

Put an AA battery in the footpeg. Use the piezo (or other vibration sensing device) to detect when the motorcycle is in use. Add a small light detector to determine when not to turn of the LEDs.

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

This all reminds me of an interesting and obscure problem I was tasked with solving many years ago.

The requirement was to develop a sensor for a personal alarm worn by a firefighter that detected body movement. If the firefighter stopped moving the thing would wail.

One of the specifications was that the sensor needed to be sensitive enough to detect slow shallow breathing (as in sleep) if desired, but the same sensor must also be robust enough to be repeatedly dropped two metres onto hard concrete without damage, or stand total continuous immersion !

I experimented with a spherical bubble with multiple internal wire whiskers and a blob of mercury. The mercury rolled around and shorted out various combinations of the sensing wires. A microcontroller with three eight bit ports, energised and sensed these whiskers. It was very sensitive to tilting or acceleration in any plane. If dropped, the mercury just splattered and reformed.

This idea was never taken up, so is free to anyone that wants it.

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

Mercury!!! My gawd man that's the death!!  You would've killed all the firemen!

I can think of a bunch of ways to sense that motion.  Be hard to choose.  Sleeping verses respiratory arrest... That does sound a little hard.

I saw a "Dirtiest Jobs" where they were burning down a crack house in Santa?Clara and the beepers kept going off every time they stopped to talk.  Struck me as madly ridiculous. Like the solution sucked worse than the problem.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

It was over twenty years ago when I was asked to look at this.

But I wonder if any of those devices would withstand several drops onto concrete without any damage or loss of sensitivity? or survive a lengthy spell totally immersed ?

The commercial units I have since seen use a mass and a piezeo ceramic wafer. Very sensitive, but also too fragile.

Yeah, mercury batteries are lethal too, hehehe.

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

<sigh> It seems our (mine and nbucska?) questions about Rich's business and what services he offers were considered "personal questions" and removed.  Whatever happened to getting to know the people you're helping?  My replies to an engineer will be vastly different than to a marketing guy at the same company, and may change based upon the end-product, so why delete potentially useful information?  Too odd...

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

macgyvers2000; Do not take it personally.  It wasn't your questions. It was nornrich's answer and only  because he unknowingly made the cardinal sin...of including an email address. This is considered highly verboten!!  Emails SHALL NOT be included in posts. Ever!

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

If it's a gas engine why not power a small neon lamp from a coil or ignition lead using an induction pickup.

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

kontiki99; He's trying to ditch the wires on this bit of 'bling' otherwise the user won't make the buy.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

What do those flashing sports shoes use to power the LED?
My Godson's doesn't have provision to fit a replacement battery if that's the power source, but they might just be being treated as disposable, I suppose.

"I love deadlines. I love the whooshing noise they make as they go past." Douglas Adams

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

They use batteries that go dead in about 3 months.  Then ..dang! you need to buy new shoes!

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

3 months is about the lifetime for a pair of kids shoes, so that's fine :)

I've always wondered, though, about the number of battery cells (and chemicals/heavy metals) sitting in landfills specifically because people buy things to be disposable.  As an LED guy, I love the shoes, but I have to ask "As an environment killer, do we really need such an item?"  Maybe that makes me a hypocrite...

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: You can get electricity from a Potato, but.....

I do not know how/if they corrected it.  The LED shoes used to have a gram of mercury in them for the on/off control.  Minnesota won a lawsuit with LA Gear since there was no "proper disposal plan" for the mercury.  Wisconsin then passed a law prohibiting mercury as part of clothing. Illinois has outlawed mercury as well:  http://www.epa.state.il.us/mercury/mercury-illinois.html    

It really is amazing what we have thrown into our landfills.      

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources