×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Plate bending deflection in 3D

Plate bending deflection in 3D

Plate bending deflection in 3D

(OP)
Does anyone know of a formula (or a reference) for the bending of a plate under a uniformly applied load simply supported at the two extreme edges? I'm not only interested in simple beam type bending of the plate but also the lateral deflection caused by poisson's effect. The only solution I can find is to solve the fourth order PDE by Levy's method. I've also tried www.xcalcs.com but this gives inconsistent answers, although it does try to offer a numerical solution of sorts.

corus

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

Which sheet specifically were you using at www.xcalcs.com ? There is (was) none corresponding to your description.
Now it is there (freshly added): you find it under Plates -> Simple bending -> Rectangular -> 2 opp.supp,2 free
Please come back if you find any inconsistency.

prex

http://www.xcalcs.com
Online tools for structural design

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

Very impressive web site, prex. Thanks.

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

Prex, how would I go about solving this problem on paper? Where did you find the fomula for deflection of a plate with these boundary conditions? I saw the formula on the xcalcs.com website but I'm confused as to how I can calculate a deflection using it.


Cheers

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

You can't do it by hand, or at least there is no simple formula (not even a series expansion) that I know of.
The solution at xcalcs is an approximate one obtained by energy minimization: it requires the solution of a large linear system of equations.
But why would you want to do it by hand, as you can have it done for you by a computer?

prex

http://www.xcalcs.com
Online tools for structural design

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

you could consider your plate as three sections, the middle one supporting the load. the reactions (for the middle strip) being pinned (or cantilevered) at the supports and a distributed load into the adjacent strips; the adjacent strips react this distributed load at the supports.

the middle strip is then a beam with a point load and an opposite sense distributed load; easy enough to calculate the deflected shape for different distributed loads (different reactions into the adjacent strips).  The adjacent strips are beams with a distributed load, simple enough.  

good assumptions (the load distribution into the adjacent strips) would have very similar displaced shapes.  if you wanted a challenge you could include the torsion effect (the adjacent strips have the appled load offset from the edge reactions.  and/or include more strips.

or you could assume a deflected shape, say every point at a distance from the load deflects the same (circles); with zero slope at the load point and some power series (at least a cubic, to fit with the distributed loads, possible quartic) defining the displaced shape.  this will tell you something of the twist on the adjacent strips.

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

Actually, you can do it by hand.  The solution set is based on boundary values imposed by the fixed edge and point placement of the load, partial differential equation with constant coefficients.

For sure the Fourier Series will work, but there are more classical methods which involve the steady state and transient solutions in the form X(x)Y(y), that is, single valued functions that are separable in the differential form.

I would try advanced textbooks in mathematics such as Partial Differential Equations.

Kenneth J Hueston, PEng
Principal
Sturni-Hueston Engineering Inc
Edmonton, Alberta Canada

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

(OP)
prex, the web site is good, and eventually I managed to get the answer and the result is the same as that obtained by FE. Unfortunately I need to pass on the formula for a general case to someone who will not have access to the internet while at work. Text book solutions I've found only apply for other cases, such as simply supported on all four sides. The only resource I've had is to work through the series solution of the PDE myself. The problem now is what boundary condition to impose at the free edge. Is it d^2w/dx^2 = d^3w/dx^3 = 0?

corus

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

(OP)
Forget that last line. Are the boundary conditions at the free edge that d^2w/dy^2=0 and that Syy=0 ie. u.d^2w/dx^2+d^2w/dy^2=0 ? where u is poisson's ratio.

confused

corus

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

In using energy minimization it is not necessary to impose any boundary condition on free sides, as the free side condition corresponds to an energy minimum with respect to any other condition, and is hence automatically generated.
For a free edge parallel to y axis the boundary conditions should be:

2w     ∂2w
--- + ν --- = 0
∂x2     ∂y2
3w          ∂3w
--- + (2-ν) ----- = 0
∂x3          ∂x∂y2

Good luck!

prex

http://www.xcalcs.com
Online tools for structural design

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

It is ALWAYS a good idea to check any computer calculation by hand. For the hand calculation, consider looking up Formulas for Stress and Strain by O'Rourke. They have formulas for bending if square, rectangular, round, oval, etc. plate for many, many, many boundry conditions.

Happy Hunting.

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

(OP)
Thanks prex, I've confirmed your expressions in a book by Timoshenko and Gere today and will now be able to solve the PDE, hopefully.

Hookem, Roarke doesn't have such formulae for plates with only 2 sides simply supported as normal practise would be to consider the plate as a beam and ignore the poisson's effect.

Many thanks to all.

corus

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

Corus - can you give me an idea of the sort of application where this effect is important?

Cheers

Greg Locock

Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

(OP)
Greg,
Bending of sheet metal, levelling, uncoiling thin plate etc.

corus

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

(OP)
In producing an analytical solution to the problem I find that the numeric solution using both MathCad and Excel give slightly different results (about 1 or 2%) to those obtained from Xcalcs.com and an Abaqus FE model (for which both give the asme answer). Do both MathCad and Excel use single precision numbers such that the difference I find can be explained by rounding errors?

corus

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

Excel uses for sure double precision numbers, and so does, I suppose, MathCad.
As I understand you are using a series expansion, what about a very slow convergence, as is often found in similar situations?

prex

http://www.xcalcs.com
Online tools for structural design

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

(OP)
nope prex, I looked at that. The solution converges rapidly and only the first two terms are needed, if that. The problem lies with the multiplication of a number raised to the power 4 multiplied by a very small number giving an answer that has a small but not insignificant error. I'll look at the maths again to see if an alternative exists.

corus

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

corus:  Have you tried it in Octave yet? Octave would be a serious number cruncher.

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

corus, et. al.,

This is a relevant topic for the work in which I am involved, whereby a mirror in the form of a flat solid bar is polished, and then bent into an elliptical shape.

One of the problems is the so-called "anticlastic" bending, in the perpendicular axis.  A typical mirror might be around 5 inches long, by 0.6 inches wide, by 0.15 inches thick.

I am new to this sort of problem, but I am interested in seeing how the effect might be altered by making the cross sectional shape of the mirror trapezoidal rather than rectangular.

Jon
http://ssg.als.lbl.gov/ssgdirectory/spear/spear.htm

Jon Spear
Berkeley Lab
www.lbl.gov
http://bcsb-web.als.lbl.gov/Staff/Newstaff2.htm

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

(OP)
jdspear,
For analytical solutions other than rectangular then you'd be better using finite elements. I'm not sure how a trapezoidal section would help (presuming that is the section about which you'd be bending the plate) but perhaps starting with a curved plate that would then bend back into a flat shape might be better. If you were starting with a flat plate then you'd have to bend it about two axis in order to eventually get a curved plate that was flat in the other direction, if you know what I mean.

corus

RE: Plate bending deflection in 3D

Reference: Kent"design and Production" 12 th Edition Pg. 8-31 thru 8-35 will give you all the formulae on deflections and max. stresses (radial and tangential) that you may need for flat plates.  All formulae can be used by hand.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources