×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

SE Reciprocity Question
4

SE Reciprocity Question

SE Reciprocity Question

(OP)
Just found out that i passed the NCEES SE I&II exam in Ohio.  While I am real excited about it, I realize that i still have a few questions about the process.  I was too busy worrying about passing this past year to think about these items.  
The ultimate goal is to get the Illinois SE and possibly a few west coast states.  
1. Has anyone had experience with obtaining the Illinois SE using reciprocity (not CA,WA,NV,ID,OR, etc)?  
2. Also, will Ohio actually allow me to call myself an SE?  This seems like a very strange question, I know, but I cant find any documentation on the SE license in Ohio other than the fact that the exam is offered.
3. Are there any east coast/midwest states looking to adopt the SE requirement?
4. Will an Ohio SE open any doors for me?

Ted

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

It sounds like it would be worth a call to the Ohio board as to calling yourself a structural engineer.  I would think yes, but it's entirely possible that any registered engineer could use the term.  That is, if there's no law, then it's not prohibited.

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

Having an Illinois SE will not allow reciprocity in any of the western states that I'm aware of.  

More confusing, is that the Illinois SE is more binding than most other states with SE requirements.  The confusion begins with model law, title act and full licensure.

I would advise you to call the Ohio board and other boards that you are interested in.  Also check out the local SEA organization and the STRUCTURE Magazine for more information.

Regards,
Qshake

Eng-Tips Forums:Real Solutions for Real Problems Really Quick.

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

Galambos - I was licensed with a PE in a number of states via EIT / PE exams plus experience.  I then took the SE1 and SE2 and then applied to Illinois and was licensed as an SE.

One state I'm licensed in is Nebraska which has instituted an SE designation for those who pass the SE2 exam.  Doesn't have any legal ramifications other than allowing you to call yourself SE.

They are in the process of studying the concept of actually converting to an SE license for either all structural projects, or specific projects of major magnitude.  This is in response to a national trend in this direction.  Some states are into this process while others are status quo with the PE applying to everything but the individual's ethics determining what areas you are capable of practicing in.

Qshake and JStephen have a good point - call Ohio Board to see what they require.

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

2
(OP)
thank you all for your input.  

JAE, what state was your SE I&II in that allowed you to get the Illinois SE?

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

The SE I and II were taken in Nebraska but they are NCEES exams so it doesn't really matter where you take them.

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

(OP)
JAE,

I ask because i attended a masonry seminar where i met a few IL SE's from Wisconsin.  they claimed that IL required them to take their exam in Illinois and that other states NCEES exams would not qualify them.  But, i see that there was a rule change in 2004, which might affect this. certainly, i will be calling the board myself, but i received my passing notice on friday afternoon.  its like a new toy that you cant play with!

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

I took the SE I and II in about 1992 - 1994.

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

Is your name really Ted Gallambos?

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

Is there a reason you don't want to call the Illinois Division of Technical Registration and talk to someone?  I know that these type of calls can be frustrating, time consuming, etc., but if you get the right person they've heard the same question a hundred times and have the answer on hand.

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

(OP)
jed,

i have contacted them.  if you read my threads, you would see that i got my notice this weekend after there office was closed.  i have worked on getting this license for 1.5 yrs now, and was just anxious to get the questions answered.  if you notice, there were other questions i had that were not "answerable" by the boards.  and no... my name is not really ted galambos

ted galambos

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

I thought I recognized that name- if I remember right, the commentary of AISC-ASD refers to him a number of times.

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

I thought he was a shortstop for the 1942 Brooklyn Dodgers.

RE: SE Reciprocity Question


I have a steel text "Basic Steel Design with LRFD" co authored by Theodore Galambos

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

Please keep us updated on how this works for you.  I too have wanted to take the SE in Ohio.  They just make the NCEES test available, which is nice.  When I looked into it, they wanted a ton of money to proctor the test.  It was something like $1200 for both tests.

I never could figure out if we could get receprocity to Illinois.

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

(OP)
ahunt,
i got an email response from illinois.  they stated "If you meet the Education and Experience requirements of Illinois, then Illinois will accept the NCEES SEI & II exams taken in any jurisdiction."  hope this helps.

by the way, how come you need the test to be proctored?  do you mean the illinois test?

ted

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

At one time I asked why the cost was so high.  It was something like $500.  They said they had to hire someone.  It didn't make sense to me, but the cost was enough to tell me to go away.  I would expect it to cost what a PE test would cost.  For some reason, a markup seemed to be envolved.  This was some time ago, they had just started to offer the tests.

In a couple years my company plans on targeting Chicago.  So the Illinios issue will be very much alive.

Aaron

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

Ted,

Hearty Congratulations on passing both exams.
I would appreciate your input on the following questions.

a) Approx time you took to study both 1 & 2 exams
b) Reference Books that are worth buying for both exams.
c) Focus areas in the exams.....any tips.

Thankyou.

Parisha

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

(OP)
Parisha,

thanks and in answer to your questions...
a.)  i tried studying 2 hrs a night for three months M-F, but i had been on-site and out-of-state for a major baseball stadium construction project for both exams which usually interfered with my time.  most of my study time came from studying for the civil PE the year before and somehow i retained it.

b.)certainly you MUST have every book on the NCEES list and the most up-to-date.  it would be a real shame if you showed up to the test and missed a few points because you didnt have the right references that you knew about ahead of time.  it would be even worse if you failed because of it.  but, outside of the recommended references, i think you should try to acquire:

-  the Wood design book by Breyer,
-  steel design book for salmon and johnson(not necessarily the latest since ASD is still permitted on the exam),
-  the latest concrete design book by MacGregor.  btw, this is the best text book i could ever recommend.

-  the SERM by williams (although i am not a big fan of it).  this will help with bridge problems, assuming that you are a building guy.

-sample questions from NCEES for the SEI and SEII

c. focus areas for the SEI should DEFINITELY be rigid and flexible diaphragms and shearwalls.  these come into play with all materials. the PCA manual helps with rigid diaphragms, the Breyer wood book is great for flexible diaphragms, and the seismic book from ppi2pass.com fills in the gaps.
also, this exam is MIND NUMBING. i finished the civil pe with 1.5 hrs left. i had 10 minutes left for the SEI.

for the SEII, i would recommend studying the IBC 2003 seismic provisions and know it backwards and forwards because NCEES guarantees that seismic will be on the exam.  i would recommend xeroxing this chapter and picking it apart with a highlighter and red pen.  i studied this every day for a month.
by this point in your career, you probably should not have to study wind or loadings, but it wouldnt hurt to relook the portal method and some other indeterminant methods.  i imagine you should also know two materials solidly at this stage and will have to study the other two. for me, i knew concrete and steel well, but had to look at wood and masonry more in depth.

let me know if you need anything else.  hopefully someone else finds this informative, too.  

ted

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

I recognized your name immediately.  It's hard to accept that you have licensure issues, as you have virtual "Rock Star" status among engineers!  You gave a talk at a light-gauge steel seminar I attended, and it was terrific.

Thank you for your service to engineers, to the profession, to society.

the rattler

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

(OP)
im not sure if you are serious or not..but let's be clear that i am not the famous theodore galambos of minnesota.  does anyone really think that dr galambos would actually post messages on the web?

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

He very well could- but he probably wouldn't be asking questions about the SE tests and licensing.  I don't know the guy, but if he was writing important stuff 20 years ago, he's probably retirement age now.

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

Parisha,

I also passed this last SEI and SEII.  I found the 3 books that Kaplan AEC sells as structural exam preparation for a really reasonable price, all by Alan Williams were excellent, and there is a chapter in one of the books that will help with the bridge questions.

akastud

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

Ted Galambos is not Dr. Ted Galambos, otherwise he would have clearly stated that you needed the LRFD edition of Don Breyer's book.

I am on a continuing education planning committee at the University of Minnesota with Dr Galambos.  The committe plans a yearly Structural Engineering Seminar Series.  

It is my understanding that he has retired from the university.  However he still seems to be some what active.  This last spring Dr. Galambos presented a seminar for the 2006 SESS.  As usual he was among the most popular speakers.

AS a graduate of Iowa, I never had the privilege of taking a class from him.  However every one I know indicated he was a very good instructor.

And no I am not famous.  My only claim to fame is that some editions of Don Breyer's  "Design of Wood Structures" book reference a paper I co-authored with another individual.  

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

RARSWC - the only thing I have to say about your post is............................................................................GO CYCLONES!............................

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

Hi Ted!
Hey, I just wanted to check in and see if you had luck with reciprocity in Illinois.  I'm just starting the process.

Thanks!

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

(OP)
ahunt,

its currently being processed right now, so i will be able to let you know in 4-6 weeks.

RARSWC,
dr galambos would recommend the ASD version of Breyer's book, since LRFD wood design is not permitted on the exam. talk about name dropping, sheesh.

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

Ted,

Thank you for your valuable suggestions and recommendations.

Question: SE-1: Was it similar to the PE-structural depth exam.

Question: SE-2: Did you have a design checklist for the essay type questions in the exam. Also, did you use moment distribution in any of the exam problems.

Compared to the SE-1, how tough did you find the SE-2 exam with regard to preparation/solving problems/level of difficulty.

Thank you for your input once again.
Good luck with the IL paper work.

Parisha

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

Parisha,

One signs a confidentiality/non-disclosure agreement upon sitting for these tests. People in this forum should not really answer very specific questions (moment distribution?) regarding actual exam content.  Look at the NCEES study guides as to what they imply one should know.

Study hard, be able to get to references fast, and be able to think quickly on your feet.  Both of these tests are "academic" in nature and emphasize speed, which is not the case in the real world. You do not get "partial credit" on a column design that will actually be built.  

I took (and passed) the SE1 and SE2 ten years apart, but I would seriously consider taking these together, if your Board offers the opportunity and your brain can take two 8 hour days like that.

I too found that the Alan Williams books were excellent "nuts and bolts" study guides.

RE: SE Reciprocity Question

(OP)
Parisha,
 
sundale is right.  i cant answer your moment distribution question. as far as the SEI, it is much more difficult than the Civil PE structural exam.  i finished the PE with 1.5 hrs left in each session, while i finished the SEI with less than 10 minutes left in each session.

i would defnitely recommend a seismic checklist for IBC 2003 and ASCE 7-02 combined for the SE II.  i would hope that you wouldnt need a checklist for the different materials, if you are taking the SE II exam.  people say that it is a 'luck of the draw' exam.  

since they are two different types of tests, it's not easy to say which one was harder.  although, since the SEII exam is in essay format, it was a little nerve-racking (sp?) to think that someone will be grading your actual calculations and presentation rather than just little, filled-in circles.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources