×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

(OP)
I have 34.5KV line to 4160V.  On the primary side of the transformer there is a vault with a disconnect switch (3 phase).  This is fed from an overcurrent protection device some distance away.  There has been problems with the disconnect switch so Im looking into getting rid of it, and I was wondering if it is "legal"?  Is there NEC code requiring the switch, and/or any other issues that might arise from getting rid of the switch.

Be Safe.

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

In general, the NEC probably does not require a local disconnect at a transformer, but at 34.5 kV, I'd want to be sure that there was a reasonable way to isolate the transformer and a place close to the transformer where protective grounds could be applied to the transformer primary for worker safety.  

But if this is owned by a utility, the NEC does not apply.  

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

(OP)
Thanks for the input dpc:

This XFMR is owned by our facility.  Our overcurrent device is ~ 800 ft away and we can apply grounds there.

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

What problems are you having with the switch?

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

(OP)
We have had some mechanical issues with the switch opening/closing, but more recently and more importantly we had a switch burn up.  I'm not sure of the details, but I will know tomorrow and post them here.

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

If you have any overhead line between the overcurrent device and the transformers, you really need to apply safety grounds  close to the transformer.  

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

(OP)
These lines are in conduit (underground)

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

(OP)
To Zogzog:

The insulation around the switch had moisture build up on it.  This created a low resistance to ground resulting in some arcing and ultimately causing damage to the switch, insulation and vault.  NOTE: we do have heaters inside the vault to avoid this problem but it seems they had some type of failure.

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

Most switches at 34 kV are  not rated to interrupt the load or event a transformer without load.

What kind of switch do you have in this facility?.
Did you check with the switch manufacturer for this application?

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

(OP)
This is just a disconnect switch on the primary side of a 34.5KV to 4160V transformer.  The switch is located inside a vault.  It is not intended to be operated under load.

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

Are (were) the heaters working? You can replace the insulators in that switch probally for less $ than removing it and splicing.

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

(OP)
The heaters were not working.  These heaters are notorious for not working and this has to do with the fact that they cannot be serviced while the XFMR is under load.  So we are looking into removing the disconnect and desiging a vault with a heating mechanism that can be extracted from the vault (while under load) and serviced.

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

Have you done any service work on the switches. ie lube the mech, clean and wax the insulators, check the switch operation. As earlier stated it would be cheaper, to repair and do proper maintenance vs replacement. I agree you need to modify the heater situation.

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

(OP)
Dewone:

I agree with you and zogzog that it will be cheaper to service the switches rather than removing them.  We our using a silicon to lube the mech., we do check switch operation periodically, and Im not sure how often the insulators have been cleaned.  We will be changing to a more reliable heater and possibly putting a screw plug type heater into the side of the enclosure with a metal casing surrounding it thus allowing us to replace the heater element without de-energizing.  I was interested in removing the disconnect switch because we will purchasing new Primary subs and will likely get rid of the disconnect switch being that it is "legal" to do so.  However we still need to heat the vault to ensure no moisture build up on the primary side of the XFMR.

thanks.

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

If you are getting new primary subs, mount the close/trip switches near the entrance to the sub away from the gear. This option dosent cost much more to do and can eliminate the arc flash hazard for switching. Few people do this and it one of the best safety upgrades you can do. Also look into putting IR windows in for IR scans, all OEMS have these now.

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

(OP)
Im not sure exaclty what you mean with the close/trip switches ... currently we have a close/trip switch followed by a SF6 CB about 800 ft away from the PSub - this runs gto a HV disconnect inside a vault on the primary side of the sub, then we have the XFMR and switchgear.  

Thanks for the info. on the IR scans I will look into putting those on the vault doors of the new subs for preventive maintenance.

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

I was refering to your 5kV gear. I reread your post, I guess you are only replacing the 34.5kV equipment.

RE: Vault disconnect switch on Primary Subs

(OP)
Thats correct.  We havent had any problems with the 5kV gear.   On my previous post I was refering to IR windows on the vault doors...  not IR scans :)

Thanks and

Be Safe.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources