×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Final Salary Pension Stories

Final Salary Pension Stories

Final Salary Pension Stories

(OP)
I just got out of a management communication concerning our company's final salary scheme and how they (read we) are going to reduce its deficit.  Simply put, our "final salary" is now going to be today's salary index linked, but with the annual increase capped.  A few years of hyper-inflation above the cap and it'll all be worthless.

Anyone else got any similar stories about their final salary pension?

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

Who's got a pension?

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

I've got a pension at work (and a 401k), but no interesting stories.

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

You have a pension.

"Do not worry about your problems with mathematics, I assure you mine are far greater."   
Albert Einstein
Have you read FAQ731-376 to make the best use of Eng-Tips Forums?

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

If you can count 2% of salary per year, I have one too.

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

(OP)
Well, in the great UK tradition of final salary pensions, ours was to be 2/3 of final salary.  Now it's 2/3 of today's salary plus inflation.  Ok if you're 60+ already and at the top of your promotion tree.  But I'm not yet 40 and would hope that my salary exceeds inflation.  Plus there's that hyper-inflation worry.

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

It's not unsual to cap final salary pension schemes to something like 4% rise per annum. Companies can get away with it now because inflation is so low and people don't expect inflation to rise, which makes me think that people have the memories of golfish.  Historically , inflation used to be 20-25% and there is concern now that world inflation will rise again so the value of your pension may disappear if history repeats itself.

Your value of 2/3 salary assumes that you have worked for the same company for 30 years or more. These days jobs aren't for life and you can expect to change jobs, or the company to be sold with loss of pension rights before you retire. I wouldn't bank on your pension in any event but think of it only as an investment for when you have to sell the Big Issue.

For horror stories you only have to look at what happened to the pension fund run By Robert Maxwell of the Daily Mirror and the millions he stole, or the employees of Enron who lost both their jobs and their investments. These days your pension will apparently be stolen only by the ravages of inflation. My guess is that some deserving stockbroker or investment banker will do very well out of your fund when inflation and interest rates rise again. That's not classed as theft though, stangely.

corus

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

Hi corus,

I was one of the employees of Enron at the time of the collapse. Our pension was always a 'money-purchase' scheme, not final salary, which I have a great deal of scepticism towards. We didn't lose our pensions in Europe, unlike the States, because of the way the pension scheme was implemented. Northern jobs weren't lost either, but the trading guys in London all went. The London employees supposedly were ransacking the place for anything saleable after their expenses and salaries were unpaid. An acquaintance was reputedly playing Quake on a £60k data server which had come into his posession.

My parents, and especially my father, were caught up in the Equitable Life debacle. His pension was being reduced on an almost continual basis in order the meet the costs of funding those members with guaranteed benefits after Equitable's financial mismanagement left them unable to meet all their commitments. Meanwhile the directors of Equitable Life are sitting pretty, having orchestrated the greatest pension mess since Robert Maxwell's efforts. I fail to see why their earthly assets can not be seized and sold to shore up the pensions of the customers whose retirement they stole. I would cheerfully see them sold into slavery.

----------------------------------
  I don't suffer from insanity. I enjoy it...

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

If there is any way to take your pension in a lump sum, then do it.  When I retired three years ago I got out of the plan with a big check that I rolled over to an IRA.  I'm managing the IRA and have increased its value 12% per year.  Three more years of that and I could re-invest it in a money-market fund or CD's and live modestly off of it for the rest of my life in pretty rough inflation.  Five more years and I can live better than modestly.

My point is that no one cares more about your "golden years" than you do, so take control the minute you can.

David

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

Thanks for the information and advice zdas04 but quite frankly I don't have a clue what you are referring to. The IRA as far as I am aware is the Irish Republican Army but I believe they are no longer fund raising. Investing in CD's (or Compact Disks) is fine but somehow I don't think my CD collection of Max Bygraves top hits from the 1970s will make much money in the future. Can you just explain your acronymns?

My opinion is that contributing to a company pension scheme is more to the benefit of the directors than the rank and file employees. In this article from the Guardian directors are able to build up their pot twice as fast as an employee - "directors' final salary pension pots usually build up twice as fast as those of employees, meaning it takes twice as many years for staff to reach a full pension as it does directors" - http://www.guardian.co.uk/executivepay/story/0,,1649313,00.html
There's something wrong somewhere.

I have heard zdas04's advice before about taking as much of your pension as a lump sum as you can when you retire. Given  the chance of high inflation (above 4%) it's probably good advice. If you're a director though, you're probably not bothered.

corus

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

Defined-benefits pension plans are going the way of the passenger pidgeon here in North America.  Those who still have them tend to introduce themselves to colleagues in meetings talking like people doing hard time in prison, "Hi, I'm so and so from such and such division, and I've got 13 more years to go (before my pension is fully vested)"

Personally, I like the portable retirement savings co-contribution option that has tended to replace the defined-benefits plan in most places.  The only one screwing with your plan is the market.  No worries about whether your organization remains solvent to keep paying out pensions, and no benefit to rotting away in a horrible job merely to collect on it.

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

corus,
Since we share so much of our heritage, it really is a shame that we don't share a language.

IRA is (in government-tax-speak) is Individual Retirement Account and it is a tax-defered account for retirement.  You pay the taxes on the income you remove from the account at retirement, but the money going in and the earnings on that money is tax free.

CD is Certificate of Deposit that pays a fixed return for a set period of time and I'm sure there is a similar financial instrument in the UK.  They generally don't return the same rate as equities, but they carry much less market risk.

The plan that I retired under was a predecessor to the "portable retirement savings" that moltenmetal speaks of--under that plan you could either take a lifetime annuity or a lump sum upon retirement.  The company saw the handwriting on the wall and set the interest rate for the annuity just a touch lower than the interest rate for the lump sum so you have to be pretty dim to opt for the annuity.  The year after I left they changed the plan to eliminate the annuity altogether for new hires.

David

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

(OP)
I must admit I used to find the term IRA amusing when I lived in America.  My American colleagues just didn't get the joke when I asked them why they were investing in a illegal foreign army for their retirement.

Similarly my comments that "401K" was a much more understandable term than the silly British equivalent of "pension".

Anyway, to cut to the chase...

My view is that the company I work for is hoping that hyper-inflation will solve its deficit problem.  We've been told over and over again that the biggest problem is increasing longevity.  And reading between the lines, that means us younger members, not current pensioners.

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

I recently saw an article that said most pension plans are in trouble because they are assuming an average life expectancy after retirement of less than 10 years (retire at 65 and die before 75) and people are retiring sooner and dieing later.  If they have to pay out an annuity for 15 years that is only funded for 8 years then somebody (say a 30 year old) has to either pay more or lose benefits.  The more I learn about this shell game the happier I am that I decided to cash out at 50 and invest it myself until I finally decide to retire.

David

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

the bottom line is: no body knows. Not even the (so called) experts.
If you analyse all the 'advice' given from the financial experts over the past 20~30 years, it all seems to change, in 6~8 year cycles.
Take Endowment Mortgages:  The people who were selling you these 'fantastic' plans that will 'guarantee' a comfortable income all seemed to be chastised in the public eye for doing something wrong. They then started saying, after most average folk had handed over large sums of their hard-earned income, that the predictions are that the guarantees are now not guaranteed and actually may be worthless. You'd better sell them. In fact. you'd better be quick and sell them otherwise you might get nothing. So, the wind has changed direction, Mars is in line with Venus and suddenly our precious investment is worthless.
So why is it the people who sold us these investment plans are the same people 'willing' to take them off our hands for next to nothing?
but hey, what do we know, we're only engineers...

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

can someone please explain to me what the 401k plan is?

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

A 401(k) plan is a retirement savings plan where the tax on your contributions is deferred until you withdraw from the account.  It is named after the section of the (U.S.) tax law which describes it.

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

Quote:

illegal foreign army

That description sounds more appropriate for the occupying forces in Iraq.

The IRA are terrorist scum, just like al Quaeda are terrorist scum. Don't glamourise either of those organisations by comparing them to soldiers.

----------------------------------
  I don't suffer from insanity. I enjoy it...

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

The portable plan I was talking about is simpler than that- no annuity or lump sum on retirement:  the boss simply matches your own payments to your own registered retirement savings plan (RRSP in Canada, 401k in US etc.) in a set proportion to a set maximum % of salary.  When you leave, you take the plan and all its money with you.  You make all the investment choices based on your own goals and risk tolerance.  Nobody messes with the money but you (and the markets of course!)

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

With regards to 401(k) plans, don't forget the vesting part of the deal.  In addition to your employer matching a certain portion of the money you put in, there is also a vestment period on portion of money the employer contributes.  For example, if you leave before 5 years is up, you may only be eligible to take 50% of what your employer contributed.  The rest goes into the company's general 401(k) fund.  That value varies from employer to employer.  In some cases it's more, in others it's 0%.  The vestment periods and rules vary among employers.  

If you're looking for concrete examples, my employer's plan contributes $0.35 for every $1.00 I contribute to the plan, up to 5% of my annual compensation.  Anything I contribute above and beyond the 5% would not be matched.  In my case, it's best to contribute up to the set amount of cash matched by my employer and then contribute the rest that I have available to a Roth IRA (up to what I think is now $4K annually...at least for this youngster).

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

Some of the UK schemes are similar: ours is through a third party and, assuming they remain solvent, the money invested by employees and employer is yours even if you leave. The specific scheme I'm a member of allows us to either leave the investment choice in the hands of an expert, or to make our own fund selections.

Most UK schemes have a two year period during which if the employee leaves they get their contributions returned, less tax, and the employer keeps their contributions.

I'm paying in 12% at present. It's heavy going with a big mortgage, but hopefully will pay off long term.

----------------------------------
  I don't suffer from insanity. I enjoy it...

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

Only a few companies provide a match for the 401(k).  Most are vested immediately, as it is your cash, but if you take the money out of the plan prior to age 59-1/2, you not only get taxed on the amount, you get penalized by the IRS (Internal Revenue Service, the U.S. tax agency).  You are allowed to "roll over" the amount into another plan, or into an individual retirement account (IRA), if you change jobs.

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

The common plan here in Canada is a simple salary percentage-limited matching contribution, with no vesting period and 100% portability.  If you contribute 3%, they contribute 3% (or more) to a preset maximum.  The second the investment is made, it's your money to do with as you please, including transfer to another RRSP plan or even early withdrawl- of course, subject to a witholding tax.  I don't know if this is a company choice or the law of the land, but I've never seen one personally that had a vesting period with a claw-back of company contributions for people who didn't stay longer than a certain period.

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

In the UK there is a simlar system in most companies where your contribution is matched by the company. However, when the pension fund is doing well (as they did in the 80s) then the companies will take a 'pension holiday', as it is referred to. In simple terms they don't contribute at all to the fund. When the pension fund is doing badly, however, the companies merely ask you to work longer, take a lower pension, ask you to contribute more.

There's something wrong somewhere.

corus

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

the problem is, the holiday usually continues long after the fund is doing badley. It takes a long time to achieve a healthy pension fund but only a very short time for it to go pear-shaped.

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

(OP)
I read (or heard?) somewhere recently that UK firms aren't allowed by (tax) law to overfund a pension, so the idea that a pension "holiday" is a cynical company bean-counter thing may not be true.  Can anyone point to a legislative link?

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

yes, SomptinGuy, the pension fund is limited by tax laws, however it is companies that refer to is as a 'pension holiday' and not some cynical comment. The point is that when the fund does well the company stops paying, when the fund is doing badly then it is you that pays in one way or another.

On this site http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/4810030.stm :

Q: Should companies have been allowed to take "pension holidays"? Has this been a factor in this crisis?
Jel, Cardiff


It certainly has. Horror stories have emerged of companies that took complete pension contribution holidays in the 1990s and into this century.

Often that was because their actuaries told them they had a notional surplus which they could afford to run down and the employers seized on this with glee to cut their costs and boost their profits and dividends.

In their defence they claim they were obeying Inland Revenue rules which put a limit on how big these surpluses could get before losing their tax exempt status.

But quite why some of them waited until they had plunged head-long into a deficit of hundreds of millions of pounds or even, in some cases, billions of pounds, I can't answer, other than to say it now looks like an astonishing level of negligence or stupidity somewhere along the line.

Now that deficits have arisen it has given some employers a good excuse to close their schemes to new members and bring in new versions which are much cheaper to run.

corus

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

In the case of our plan, the company is NEVER permitted to take a "holiday", because there IS no company plan.  There's no pension fund, no fund manager, and no company involvement in the program aside from merely making the electronic transfers every month and adjusting your payroll tax deductions accordingly.  The money is contributed monthly by both the employee and the employer automatically, and once it's contributed, it's the employee's money, period.  Of course, if you make bad investments, the market can take it all away in a heartbeat, but that's your problem.

The program is popular with small companies because it wastes little money on overhead.  It's also popular with employees, especially those whose families have been screwed out of pensions earned by themselves or their parents at companies that are now insolvent.

RE: Final Salary Pension Stories

moltenmetal,

That sounds like a remarkably good scheme. Once again I am in envy of the Canadians.

----------------------------------
  I don't suffer from insanity. I enjoy it...

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources