×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Live load for museum floor
2

Live load for museum floor

Live load for museum floor

(OP)
I can not find direct reference for second floor live loading of a photography museum. Does anyone have a reference that they can cite for me?

I am between two values, 50 PSF and 80 PSF. Any thoughts would be appreciated.

Regards,
Lutfi

RE: Live load for museum floor

For museum floors, due to the assembly nature of these, I would use a LL of 100 psf minimum unless stipulated otherwise by the owner.  For storage areas and filing areas, the load could easily be in excess of 100 psf.

$.03(CAN) Dik

RE: Live load for museum floor

(OP)
dik,

Thanks for the quick input.

For the storage area I used 300 PSF because they have a storage compactor.

100 psf sounds good at face value. However, I do not want to over design if not necessary.

Do you have a code reference?


Regards,
Lutfi

RE: Live load for museum floor

Lutfi - I'd agree with dik on this one.  museums many times have "shows" or events and these qualify as a public assembly area.  In addition, sculptures and other museum items can be very heavy so 100 psf isn't excessive.  

For a photography museum...do you have photographic equipment on display?  You might want to find out what the display layout is planned and try to get a handle on true weights.  



RE: Live load for museum floor

2
Lutfi - The museum area that you describe and the reading room of a library would seem to have a lot in common.

ASCE 7-02 gives Library Reading Room live load as
60 PSF (Uniform) and 1000 lb (concentrated)

www.SlideRuleEra.net reading

RE: Live load for museum floor

I think a library reading room is generally described as the area where the tables and chairs are along with minor shelving for "special" displays...i.e. not the stack areas.  I would think a museum would be heavier.

RE: Live load for museum floor

Slide...

Yep - the article also includes this:

In one example, a museum building was to display a fine collection of bone china in glass cabinets that were to be fixed to the walls and floors. Even taking account of the fact that the space between cabinets could easily be crowded with visitors, it was shown that the floor loading was less than half the 4.0 kN/sqm suggested by the British Standard. A somewhat lower value was therefore used and the amount of structural intervention was dramatically reduced, without compromising the safety of the visitors or of the building.

This sounds like the studies I've read where office loading (usually designed at 50 psf) was found to truly range around 10 to 12 psf in actuality.

However, for any floor, we as engineers are judged against the standard of care - what another reasonable engineer would do  -  so most engineers I know are naturally conservative in their designs and would use the code required load or even higher if they suspected different potential uses for the floor - so in a museum, I can certainly envision a large group of people gathering for a party or an exhibition with speakers, etc. - and that sounds a lot like "public assembly" to me (i.e. 100 psf).

RE: Live load for museum floor

Ok... you convinced me, there could certainly be a large group of people, shoulder to shoulder for a tour, and that is 100 PSF (for folks my size anyway)

www.SlideRuleEra.net reading

RE: Live load for museum floor

JAE:
Baker's steel skeleton has reference on actual loading within office space, but conditions may have changed since the original publication.  The results mimic your 10-12 psf... they have a bit of a breakdown based on area...

Dik

RE: Live load for museum floor

I don't have my copy of the NBCC at home, but most assembly areas without fixed seating/tables, etc. are 100 psf...

It's been my experience that the cost for the added loading is a small additional item... the real economy is the selection of the framing system.  Your and JAE's experience might be similar..

Dik

RE: Live load for museum floor

Depending on the type of museum, I believe the Live Loads could be expected to range from as low as 50 psf to well over 100 psf. I would not expect a photography museum to require more than 70 psf, unless a large number of glass plates are anticipated (except for storage areas).

In my experience, Performance is usually the issue. I have not dealt with any fall down floor failures, even when the floors were obviously overloaded. Floors which 'bounce' 'vibrate' or 'just do not feel right' are a common occurance. If the display cabinets rattle when people walk around or when the distracted boy jumps up and down, It could be perceived as a failure.

Very interesting how little specific guidence can be found for what should be a small problem. We are accustomed to having this all laid out in a code or standard. Good discussion.

RE: Live load for museum floor

(OP)
Thanks for the debate and great exchange of ideas. This is what I like about this forum.

I have been in practice for over 23 years and my judgment tells me that 100 psf is the way to go. One will never know what the client may want to hold as a function down the road.

For now, it is a photography venue to display various pictures by the client’s photography students and professionals alike. Even hold regional shows.

I was leaning towards the 50 PSF but I convinced myself to use the 100 psf.

Good night to all.

Regards,
Lutfi

RE: Live load for museum floor

The Australian loading code gives 4 kPa (~80 psf) for museums. However it gives 5kPa (~100 psf) for areas susceptible to overcrowding.

RE: Live load for museum floor

Just an interesting post script. This morning started back to work on my next "E-book" to share with you folks (scanning and making a .pdf out of 372 page "1923 Carnegie Pocket Companion")

Lo, and behold...
There are the (historical) City Building Law Live Load requirements for, you guessed it, "Museums"

1917 New York: 100 PSF
1919 Boston: 100 PSF
1920 Cleveland: 125 PSF
1914 Pittsburg: 200 PSF

www.SlideRuleEra.net reading

RE: Live load for museum floor

(OP)
wow slideRuleEra...... I am impressed man.

Regards,
Lutfi

RE: Live load for museum floor

One more thought on the museum floor loading.  While the exhibits could be large and spread over a good sized area resulting in a relatively low psf loading, the EQUIPMENT used to move it in and out of the "show room" could be pretty heavy -- forklifts etc. with good sized wheel loads.

I vote for the 100 psf.

RE: Live load for museum floor

I wonder why Pittburgh was so nervous.

RE: Live load for museum floor

Slide Rule,

Your graphic makes it appear you are pulling some important reference information from behind and below your waist.  That brings to mind an expression I heard often in collage ...

RE: Live load for museum floor

Dinosaur - Thanks for your interesting (and accurate) observation - time to make a change!

www.SlideRuleEra.net idea

RE: Live load for museum floor

I vote for 100 psf.  Museums often change hands and function - one day photos the next sculptures, etc.  Forklifts are common and not all operators are pros.  I was working in the Guggenheim, NY, when a 36 W 350 was dropped on the spiral ramp during installation of a sculpture.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources