water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
(OP)
why do we pump into a chiller and the opposite for a water heater?
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS Come Join Us!Are you an
Engineering professional? Join Eng-Tips Forums!
*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail. Posting GuidelinesJobs |
water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
|
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
You want your warmest fluid temperature and lowest pressure to be located at the air separator. This is where the air bubbles are most likely to separate from the water.
In the case of heating, the water passes through the heater, then through the air separator, then goes to the pump.
In cooling, the warm return water passes through the separator, then to the pump, then to the chiller.
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
If the pumps are at the inlet,the pressure on the tubes will be 140m.If they are at the outlet,the pressure will be only 100m.This is more critical in the case of boilers because of the high teperature and therfore lower pressure ratings.
Chiller tubes generally have higher pressure rating than boiler tubes(due to the need to withstand the refrigerant pressure).
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
Digression:
The only time this is not really the case is with water towers, where the elevation is used to position a constant pressure head on a hydraulic system. The advantage over straight-through pumping is that the tower has loads of buffering capability to absorb transient pressure and flow spikes, a pump does not.
In the case of the chiller, it represents a pressure-using device, e.g. - it has a significant pressure drop. If a pump is placed on the outlet, the pressure drop may exceed the NPSH rating of the pump and cause cavitation. A good design may limit these effects, but the strategy would still be contrary to the direction of goodness. Another point is that after spending $hundreds of thousands to cool the water, why would you turn around and add pump heat to the outlet?
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
TBP,
Perhaps I've misinterpreted, but no one was talking about air separator location, anyway. Stanlsimon interjected that as a reason for pump location relative to a water heater vs. a chiller.
(Refer to original question for this thread.)
I merely stated that air separators have nothing to do with that issue, and they don't. Systems perform quite well without air separators at all. It is far from conclusive that air separators are even needed. That has nothing to do with the correct placement of a pump in a hydraulic circuit relative to a water heater vs. a chiller.
Again, I apologize if I've misinterpreted your statement.
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
It's all aimed at removing the dissolved air from the water. If you don't deal with the air issue for heating systems, it can collect in heat emitters, and you'll get no-heat complaints. The other main problem is that your system can sound like it full of BBs with the air bubbles zinging around with the water flow, and you'll have noise complaints.
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
boiler or HX, then the expansion tank & air separator (the air sep is in-line, and the expansion tank is usually connected to it with a short section of pipe), then the pump, pumping away from the separator & x-tank. Hydraulically, it doesn't particularly matter, but this sequence really does work best for dissolved air removal. The other bit, is the make-up water line. This should be fed to the short section of pipe connecting the x-tank to the separator.
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
* sigh * No one disagreed that positioning is important. Please let me state it again, more clearly:
A. The question was how to position the pump relative to a water chiller in chilled water circuits vs. positioning the pump in water heater circuits.
B. Stanlsimon stated "It has to do with the air separator."
C. I stated it does not, and then went on to clarify the reasons for the different positions of a pump with a chiller vs. a water heater. I never stated that those positions were not critical - only, that an air separator has nothing to do with it.
An air separator is not a fundamental requirement in hydronic circuits. The position of a pump in a circuit can be critical, and is dependent on the devices it's intended to serve.
I hope that's cleared things up. If not, I give up.
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
It is not needed at all for chilled water.
Here's the original question:
Again, any discussion of an air separator is just "clouding" the issue (sorry for the pun). It is not essential for the hydraulics. It's only nice for the quality and efficiency. It does not dictate the position of the pump - the hydraulics of the circuit does that.
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
In Australia I have not seen an air seperator on either a CHW or HHW system, so the debate has been interesting but not the answering my question.
There is no storage tank associated with the water heater. (In Australia we don't call them boilers. We only call them boiler if they produce steam. It has to do with fire rating requirements of boiler as opposed to water heaters. Another topic altogether).
We have an installation which we are currently undertaking in which the design engineer has shown the pump discharging into the water heater. We have suggested that the position of the pump should be altered and supported this with the arguement of heat exchanger pressure rating - as touched on in a couple of the posts. We don't have air seperators on this system.
The manufacturer of the water heater has indicated that are not concerened with the location of the pump on either side.
I was hoping for an engineering based arguement other than 'that's the way we always do it'.
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
Because the air seperator is located at the warmest, lowest pressure area, and the expansion tank is often located at the air seperator I end up pumping away from boilers and into chillers.
Quick question, why don't you use air seperators in Australia? How do you remove air from the system?
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
Lots less steam flashing, especially with heat exchangers.
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
I do not know why you toss it to your heater(boiler?) vendor to make a call on the pump position.He should be advising you only on the maximum pressure rating for the tubes.It falls on you to calculate the maximum system pressure and then decide whether it is safe to locate the pump before/after the boiler.
The point in favor of having the pump before the boiler is that it is exposed to lower teperatures and may prolong its life.I do agree that the air speration point is weak to argue the case having seen installations working well without it.It might be worthwhile askig the designer the reason for putting it ahead of the boiler.
I have also seen some really high rise buildings where chilled pumps were also positioned after the chillers.
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
I agree with SAC9 - I have seen more chill water plants where the pump is located after the evaporator.
For hot water systems and chilled water systems that I have operated, the pump was located at the coldest point in the system.
The reasoning has been NPSH - you want the coldest fluid at the pump suction.
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
The same is true if we are concerned with a boiler, not a hot "water heater" (with a storage tank). That original statement was confusing. If we are talking a hot water boiler, then you have a tube bundle in a heat exchanger, and the chiller-pump strategy in the paragraph above is just as valid - because of pressure drop.
I am glad that others recognized an air separator has nothing to do with it. If you use one, then you should be concerned about its proper placement in the hydraulic circuit, too - but that is a consequence, not a cause.
The expansion/compression tank should be viewed with the same philosphy - it is an accessory, not a prime component in the circuit.
BTW, ad77, what do you call hot water heaters (with a tank)?
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
Having the coldest water at the pump suction is not normally a factor in closed loop heat system circulators - I've never seen one of these systems where the pressure-temperature conditions would allow the low-head circ pump to cavitate. I HAVE however, seen no end of problems from dissolved air popping out of solution at the pump suction in systems that weren't designed and/or installed correctly.
I'll see your "sigh", and raise you an "eye-roll".
RE: water heater / chiller pumping arrangement
We seem to be talking on two different wavelengths here, anyway, so I'm done.