×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Thermals software suggestions?
3

Thermals software suggestions?

Thermals software suggestions?

(OP)
Can anyone recommend a software for designing heat sinks?

RE: Thermals software suggestions?

Yes.  Call FLUENT, INC.  They sell a program that specifically analyzes heat sinks.

Tunalover

RE: Thermals software suggestions?

(OP)
I've tried the Fluent product.  Does anyone have any alternative suggestions?

RE: Thermals software suggestions?

3
Yes, I just found out about this one www.heatsinkdesigner.com.  It's definitely worth a try.

RE: Thermals software suggestions?

If you're not going to explain why you find a particular software unacceptable, what makes you think you're not going to get more of the same?

TTFN



RE: Thermals software suggestions?

(OP)
mecheng66:  Thanks for the suggestion. I tried Heat Sink Designer and it's very impressive.

IRstuff: I wouldn't call Fluent's product 'unacceptable' but I am looking for something better along these lines:

1. Fast and easy to use.  We are not thermal experts here and only have a need to use the tool occasionally.  Fluent's Qfin isn't bad but Heat Sink Designer is a good example of a much better user interface.

2. Helps find off-the-shelf heat sinks

3. Makes it easy to compare various designs

4. Costs less than Qfin

RE: Thermals software suggestions?

Fluent Software named "IcePack" is particular meant for the thermal designs of the heat sinks. It is provided by inbuilt functions and fan specification from various companies to make the design process easy.

RE: Thermals software suggestions?

thermcool-
It sounds like ICEPAK would be a Ferrari where a Toyota will do.  It is a more general-purpose tool tailor to electronic products.  The learning curve and price would both be too long for finder1.

finder1-
Hopefully you're not planning on putting non-engineers at the wheel. Every analytical tool has a price to pay in the learning curve.  If the tool is too easy to use then I would be leery because it may not provide the flexibility you need.  It may even force you to make assumptions you don't wish to make.

Just my $.02

Tunalover

RE: Thermals software suggestions?

(OP)
That's exactly right, tunalover.  We looked at IcePak and Flotherm - great tools but overkill for what we need, and a major investment in $ and time.

An engineering tool is just that - a tool for engineers. It will be used by EEs with some experience in heat sink selection.

You are also correct about the limitations, though I never met a tool that was "too easy".  HeatSinkDesigner is limited to natural convection and "parallel flow through plate fins" which covers most of our applications, but not all.  They offer a free Flotherm model of any sink their tool can't handle.  I intend to test this claim soon.

RE: Thermals software suggestions?

I've been using Heatsinkdesigner for a couple of weeks now and it's pretty clear what the limits are.  It basically tells you how a heat sink will perform in a wind tunnel, where you spec the tunnel size and the heat source details.  This is useful but you have to understand how to apply it to your application.  You should have a basic understanding of electronics cooling.

I'm very happy with it so far.  The optimizer and catalog search are very slick.  I don't the high-end tools can do this.

RE: Thermals software suggestions?

Optimization capability is not unique to HeatSinkDesigner.  Flotherm, for example, has a very powerful and sophisticated "command center" for setting up a design of experiments and running a series of simulations that can optimize sink design, component layout, vent locations, etc.  

What is unique, I think, about HeatSinkDesigner is the catalog search capability.  

ko  (www.ecooling.biz)

RE: Thermals software suggestions?

I've used Flotherm before and clearly HeatSinkDesigner is not in the same class, but it's not really an either/or question.  HeatSinkDesigner is just a well-designed, cheap, handy little tool. I tend to gravitate to it for quick feasibility checks. I haven't tried it yet for finding suppliers, but it's already paid for itself.

RE: Thermals software suggestions?

Have you tried MacroFlow from Innovative Research?  Program is done by Dr. Suhas Patankars company (CFD expert).  The program looks relatively simple, but not braindead.  It is NOT a Fluent style product.  Here is their blurb:

"MacroFlow is very useful for the thermal design of a variety of electronics systems. Because practical electronics cooling systems can be considered as networks of flow paths through components such as screens, filters, fans, ducts, bends, heat sinks, power supplies, and card arrays, MacroFlow based analysis of such systems is very simple and fast in terms of model definition, computation, and examination of results."

Here is the link: http://www.inres.com/Products/MacroFlow_Electronic/macroflow_electronic.html

RE: Thermals software suggestions?

Finder1 asked for a tool to design heat sinks.  MacroFlow doesn't predict heat sink performance or component temperatures.

I haven't looked into MacroFlow in depth because it's pretty easy to quickly model simple systems on Flotherm CFD (whereas HeatsinkDesigner is faster and does some things that CFD cannot). But for someone who can't afford CFD, the combination of MacroFlow and HeatSinkDesigner might be worth looking into.

RE: Thermals software suggestions?

(OP)
I hadn't heard of MacroFlow before. Is it in the same price range as HeatSinkDesigner?

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources