×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

ASME Flange Bolting Recommendation
4

ASME Flange Bolting Recommendation

ASME Flange Bolting Recommendation

(OP)
Hello,

I'm looking for the recommend torque to put on an ASME flange. I can't seem to find it in ASME B16.5. Is there an industry standard that people go by or is there a chart that I can look up these values in?

Thanks,
Sam

RE: ASME Flange Bolting Recommendation

2
Flange bolting recommendations are provided in ASME PCC-1, Guidelines for Pressure Boundary Flanged Joint Assembly.  

RE: ASME Flange Bolting Recommendation

(OP)
Thank you bvi

I looked up ASME PCC-1 and from the abstract, I get the feeling it is for ring type joints only. Is there also a publication for raised face flanges or does this publication also apply to it?

RE: ASME Flange Bolting Recommendation

It applies to raised face joints.  

RE: ASME Flange Bolting Recommendation

Look at ASME VIII, Appendix S.

You may find it very interesting.

Paul Ostand
www.ostand.com

RE: ASME Flange Bolting Recommendation

my 2cents...

The purpose of flange torque is to compress your gasket within the limits of the bolts and flange.  The last time I needed torque requirements, I contacted the gasket mfg.

RE: ASME Flange Bolting Recommendation

Be very careful with "recommended" torque values, as there is no one torque value for an ASME flange that takes all factors into consideration.
Assembly torque should consider the minimum and maximum stress for the gasket, the yield stress of the bolting (ASME PCC-1 suggests 50% yield for A193-B7 bolting), and finally the yield limits of the flange itself (integral flanges vs loose flanges have very different flexibility and thus allowable bending).

Gasket manufacturers are good at telling you what their gasket's require, yet they typically do not consider the min/max limits for bolting, nor do they consider the flange type.  You need to hook up with a supplier that has the technical competency to help you with these analyses.

RE: ASME Flange Bolting Recommendation

TECHNICAL NOTE:

REVIEW PP25+PVRC+PRESENSTATION BY John Ludman, Randy Wacker, Kevin Kelleher, and Ed Perez May 24, 2005.

Optimizing Torque Values:
Why we did the work
How we did the work
What we learned
what needs to happen

Why optimize?
Existing Corporate Flange Assembly Standard based on single bolt stress value for “sheet” (20 ksi) and spiral wound (45 ksi) gasket
Poor sealing experience
Some flanges damaged (rotated)
Previous PVRC efforts shows need
W.E. Short  - ASME PVP-Vol. 235 1992 - referenced PVRC initiative to study stress limits of 16.5 flanges (FEA)
Rodabaugh/Moore - ORNL-NRC-5 - a) ASME rules don’t adequately analyze ASNI flanges, need for limit analysis
Several sources of conflicting torque tables

Sources of Recommended Pre-load

Gasket Manufactures - consider gasket stress and bolting
PCC-1 - Similar to existing corporate standard, single bolt stress value (50 ksi)
ASME Flange Calculations (Appendix 2) - max allowable pre-loads were conservatively low (Rodabaugh/Moore Study-suggests 40 ksi bolt loads although ASME rules predict excessive stresses)
Pre-load required to achieve “tight” (T3) seal - only considers gasket, not optimal  
Rule of Thumb - 40% of bolt yield strength (Bickford)

Optimal Pre-Load

Maximum pre-load that does not damage fastener, gasket or flange
Flange - consider stress and deflection (output only)
Gasket - consider mechanical properties
Fastener - assume high strength bolting only

“Tightness” is an output not an input

Conditions of Analysis

1) ASME B16.5 Flanges (Lap Joint, Weld Necks)
    2) Design Conditions, pressure rating at 400 degrees F.
    3) Diameters, 1/2” through 24”
    4) Standard Pipe Sizes
    5) Material A105
    6) High Strength Bolting
    7) Spiral Wound and Sheet gaskets (allowable                     compressive stress > 10,000 psi)

General Strategy
1) Established acceptable limits of stress (flange, bolt,         gasket)
    2) Adjusted fastener loadings to achieve flange stress limits
    3) Compared resulting gasket stress to gasket stress requirements (T3 seal, manufacturer’s    recommendations)


Lap Joint Flanges

Method
ASME, Division 1 Appendix 2 equations

Limits and Considerations
     1) Bolt-up case only (pressure increases stress by ~ 12%)
     2) Flange stress limited to 90% of hot yield (at bolt-          up)
     3) “Hub” not included in Appendix 2 calculations
Verification
    1) Axisymetric Finite Element Modeling (considered         hub)
    2) Verified several sizes (proved method used was                conservative)

Weld Neck Flanges

Limits and Considerations
    1) Limit Flange stress to 90% Sy
    2) Limit Hub stress to 1.7 x Sy
    3) Yield (Sy) value at temperature
Verification
    1) Elastic-plastic FEA analysis (for hub stress)
    2) Verified bending stress in hub was “secondary”, use          criteria of <2 Sy


Method
    1) 3D Finite Element Modeling (AxiPRO, Paulin                Research)
    2) Gasket dimensions per ASME B16.20 (spiral              wound) and ASME B16.21 (ring)
    3) Reviewed output (flange stress and deflection)         and adjust bolt load to approach limits

I could not add the rest of the pp.

E.C. Rodabaugh and S.E. Moore published a report “Evaluation of the Bolting and Flanges of ANSI B16.5 Flanged Joints ASME Part A Design Rules” sponsored by US Nuclear Regulatory Commission,  We were referred to this report by Clyde Neeley.  Available through National Technical Information Services (ORNLSUB29133)

This PP is available.

RE: ASME Flange Bolting Recommendation

Key Observations

Recommended pre-load based on single bolt stress value inadequate criteria for all flange combinations
Lap Joint flange design allows limited pre-load, tightness - new tables increase pre-load from 20 ksi
Use of 50 ksi bolt stress pre-load could overstress small size Class 150 (up to 1”) and 300 (up to 3”) weld neck flanges, damage gaskets in small sizes (over 20 ksi gasket stress)
Pre-loads of 60 ksi are recommended for some Class 150 flanges (3” and 8”)
The torque tables consider all elements of the flanged assembly (gasket, bolt, flange)


What’s Next?

Complete analysis for slip-on flanges
Class 300
Complete analysis of SS flanges
Consider additional flanges classes
Field observations
Higher pre-loads established for sheet gaskets
Lower pre-loads recommended for SW’s in small sizes and larger size
Work with PVRC Task Group to study topic across industry



Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources