Thermal Storage Tank
Thermal Storage Tank
(OP)
Can somebody please tell me what is the possible disadvantage of a thermal storage air conditioning system on a large office building?
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS Come Join Us!Are you an
Engineering professional? Join Eng-Tips Forums!
*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail. Posting GuidelinesJobs |
|
RE: Thermal Storage Tank
Lack of space/area/volume for the storage mass.
Best regards
pennpoint
RE: Thermal Storage Tank
It is commonly thought that thermal storage does not save energy, only costs - by virtue of the fact that it saves the demand during peak loads. Conventional wisdom suggests that you have only "time-shifted" the load, since chillers and power usage are needed to charge the tank the night before.
However, charging the thermal storage system can be made on your terms - not the load's So, an operator can pick the ideal point of maximum efficiency from a particualr chiller's capacity/power usage profile, and use that point exclusively to charge the thermal storage.
That will actually result in saved energy, not just saved demand.
RE: Thermal Storage Tank
RE: Thermal Storage Tank
RE: Thermal Storage Tank
The savings can be significant. Most electrical rate structures use demand thresholds that lock-in for an entire billing period. For instance, if your power demands on a hot afternoon exceed your demand contract threshold, then your charges are assessed at a higher level for the entire month, not just that single day - regardless of whether you ever exceed that level again.
These days, most places in the United States have commercial/industrial rate structures that may be considered a "triple tariff" as you have termed it: Real Time Pricing (RTP). That is because RTP is often a third level of rate structure, in addition to demand and usage charges. With an RTP rate structure, utility rates are published on a real-time basis by the hour - similar to stock values in a stock exchange. With that type of billing, RTP prices are extremely high during the peak demand periods. These higher rates are justified in return for the gamble that the rest of the rate structure - off peak - is very low.
The result is an extreme incentive to time-shift the demand to more tolerable periods (night). In those cases, savings can be so great that co-generation becomes attractive. The savings (and investment) can dwarf the dividends reaped by thermal storage, and can actually negate the justification for thermal storage, since you would be generating your own power in any case, regardless of the time schedule.