Shaft fracturing
Shaft fracturing
(OP)
A couple of years ago I worked on a design of a small (approx .5" dia) splined shaft that had a reduced diameter section that was intended to shear in the event that the driven load increased to some unacceptable level. Through some calculation and some experimentation, I arrived on the correct diameter for the shear section. Under static tortion testing, the shafts "twist off" at a torque of approx 350 in-lb. The shaft is driving an automotive air conditioning compressor with a clutch. I set up a test that drove the shaft at the right RPM under the operating load, and cycled the clutch approximately 30K times. (about 2 minutes on, and 5 sec off). All the lab testing indicated that the shaft should perform as designed under normal operating conditions. However, when installed in the field, the shafts began failing with very few hours of operation. The system is installed on an aircraft powered by a 6 cyl piston engine and the shaft is driven by one of the rear spline drives. The shaft is 1144 steel. The splines are induction hardened to 56C. The shear section is adjacent to the spline, but not induction hardened. We have made some design changes tht have eliminated the possibility of shaft/drive missallignment. The lab testing was done with an electric motor, could the piston pulses be causing a vibration that is causing the failures. Or is this a material problem??





RE: Shaft fracturing
Can you upload some pictures on the web site below of the failed spline shaft and the appearance of the fractured end (view of the fracture surface looking straight at it) ? We might be able to help you. The cause of failure could be several possibilities. The key is to evaluate the appearance of the fracture surface to confirm the failure mechanism.
http://flypicture.com/
RE: Shaft fracturing
Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA
RE: Shaft fracturing
The right (flexible) coupling can suck the energy out of the big spikes in the torque/rpm delivery. Conversely an unfortunate coupling stiffness can amplify the variation. I picture your device being a relatively small appendage on a large prime mover, so your device's mass properties are just along for the ride, via your effective couping stiffness. Simply introducing a long thin driveshaft can serve as the spike reducing coupling.
RE: Shaft fracturing
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rtr8kKzf
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rtr8kK3b
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rtr8kK3d
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rtr8kK3f
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rtr8kK3e
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rtr8kK3Q
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rtr8kK7Y
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rtr8kK7b
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rtr8kK7d
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rtr8kK7f
The 10 photos are of two different shafts from various angles. Since I didn't have a tripod, it was very hard to get pics that weren't too blurry.
RE: Shaft fracturing
RE: Shaft fracturing
RE: Shaft fracturing
RE: Shaft fracturing
Here are some side views.
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rt31ka/c
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rt31ka/f
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rt31ka/e
http://flypicture.com/bin/?id=rt31ka/R
RE: Shaft fracturing
RE: Shaft fracturing
Thank you all for your help to date.
RE: Shaft fracturing
RE: Shaft fracturing
Big diameter > neck radius > spline = pretty big stress concentration due to shape. Throw in a few more de-rating factors for surface finish, naturally evil spline re-entry geometry, and if the end of the female spline happens to be the site of crack initiation. It takes a heck of a good material to overcome a pack of designed-in stress concentration factors.
http:/
Gotta think turning down the shaft to a smaller-than-spline-pitch-diameter for a few inches adjacent to the spline, plus some polishing and shot peening would work wonders if you have to make these parts work.
Might be fun to stop the test on a shaft after a few hours to see what's happening.
RE: Shaft fracturing
Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA
RE: Shaft fracturing
So that undercut area must be a very small diameter. I could not access the photos.
I would like to know what the torque requirements are for
the compressor and "various speeds"? What is the instantanious shock torque and full governed speed?
And how long is the shaft? How is it supported?
RE: Shaft fracturing
My two cents.
RE: Shaft fracturing
Now, if you're torsional loads are such that you are getting stresses in the shaft that are between the yield strength and tensile strength of the steel, you will, I suspect, get a torsional fatigue failure in very short order.
I agree with RORSCHACH in that stay away from free machining steels.
Am I correct in that you are looking for a material that has incredible toughness (to resist fatigue crack propagation) yet predictable tensile strength (to give you the shear failure you desire if the load is too high).
RE: Shaft fracturing
I think that your last statement is accurate. I consider the environment, driver, and load to be unchangeable. I need a material that can withstand the various inputs as they exist now. I really think that the engine characteristics must have something to do with the failures. My lab testing with an electric motor driving the system wasn't able to produce any failure resembling what is occuring in the field.
Thanks to all for the input.
RE: Shaft fracturing
Just out of curiosity, having stuff snap into two pieces that is attached to the engine of an airplane while it's flying - isn't that something to be avoided? Could you make something like a clutch coupling that separates under excessive RPM?
RE: Shaft fracturing
- When the compressor locks up, it doesn't take the belt long to burn up and fall off.
- The natural frequency of the belt can be tuned to isolate the compressor from the engine's torsional vibration.
Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA
RE: Shaft fracturing
Agreed -- get rid of the resulferized steel. polish the radius and shot peen. I would try 4340 steel not that it is needed for depth of hardening but readily available and much more fatigue resistant. If this does not answer, use a mararging steel which has about the best fatigue resistance you will find and very predictable properties and easy to achieve processingwise. Maraging steel is expensive but your part is small so should not impact expense appreciably. Machining cost will also increase as a trade-off for increased fatigue resistance but again it is a small part so that machining time cannot be extensive.
RE: Shaft fracturing
RE: Shaft fracturing
Have you considered the effects of accelerating or decelerating your compressor? Because the drive is geared up it makes it more than steady running. Aircraft components are designed with the idea to keep the mass down, more than commercial and automotive components. Even if you do not have the compressor on when the engine is accelerated, it still has to accelerate the clutch. With an electric motor there is a more even acceleration, so that could be why shafts are not failing with electric.
I have seen components with similar design break and it often occurs after an engine speed problem. Usually they didn’t break when it happened, but occurs soon after. I agree that it is probably a torsional failure of a ductile material, because of the smooth surface with helical swirls, which should go in direction of rotation.
There is another item to consider. The engine manufacture lists in the TCDS the allowable torque that a drive can provide. I didn’t look up you particular engine but a similar one allows for max continuous of 90 inch pounds, max static of 600 inch pounds, with a max overhang moment of 65 inch pounds. Using these numbers I guess you could go up to 600 inch pounds, but with a compressor your overhang limit may be exceeded unless you can fit in a bracket.
It could still be a vibration problem, but the only way you will know for sure is if you do an analysis of complete airplane with your compressor. There was a case where one engine manufacture was having problems with the oil pump, with an engine in only one airframe. When they went back and re-evaluated, they found that the prop that was installed in that airframe was causing a resonance and when they changed it to another one, the problem went away.
If you have enough electrical power available, I think the best means to run the compressor would be to use a 24V electric motor. It would give you less headaches than trying to mount on the engine.
RE: Shaft fracturing
Nick
"Speed costs money boys, how fast do you want to go?"
RE: Shaft fracturing