×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

(OP)
I am developing a set or WPS for repairing a wrought iron bridge circa 1880; these procedures must be submitted for approval.  I am very concerned about the potential liability and will include a comment, such as below on each WPS. I am looking from comments and guidance from this esteem group.

Base metals are what they are. Wrought Iron circa 1880.

The bridge will be painted so I am not concerned with galvanic corrosion as is typically the case with wrought iron repairs.


Wrought iron is a ductile, tough, fibrous, ferrous material composed of relatively pure iron and silicates, Iron Silicates (Fayalite), Magnesium Silicates (Fosterite) and Iron-Magnesium Silicates (Olivine).  These silicates, commonly referred to as slag, are distributed throughout the pure iron in the form of threads or fibers that extend in the rolling direction.  The quality of the wrought iron varies because of the range of carbon, manganese, phosphorus, sulfur and silicon that constitutes each individual member. (Sulfur tends to develop hot shortness at elevated temperatures, causing problems during weld repairs. Phosphorous leads to cold shortness, a brittle characteristic at room temperatures or lower).  The wrought iron used in the original construction of this bridge has several shortcomings that are a result of a high percentage of phosphorus and sulfur and the directionality of the slag deposition.   The slag content may vary and be in excess of 6% by weight. During welding the silicates will start to melt at approximately 1200ºC, this is below the liquidus temperature of the E7018 electrode of approximately 1600ºC. At high slag concentration, the slag may inundate the weld interface surface, resulting in poor fusion, porosity and inclusions. During the welding process the welder shall examine the weld puddle for any signs of excessive slag contamination such as bubbling. If excessive slag contamination is noticed the weld shall be removed my grinding and rewelded.

Ipso facto any repairs by welding shall only be considered as cosmetic, sans any increase in strength, or toughness and with a significant decrease in ductility and possibly a decrease in strength and toughness.

Only full penetration welds are allowed. Fillet and surface type welds typically will peal off wrought iron taking a thin layer of wrought iron at a slag–iron interface.



Comments?

Vita sine litteris mors est.

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

So, why allow the welding?  Find an alternative repair to the welding.  I was always under the impression (and by your note, you must be too) that welding of wrought iron is not advisable.

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

(OP)
Many pieces are being replaced with ASTM A572 Gr 50 Steel.  These weld procecedures are for items such as 50mm x 50mm x 6mm (2x2x0.25) angles that have a bent leg that is cracked along the slag thread.

Vita sine litteris mors est.

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

I assume that someone in his/her ignorance has specified/proposed welding repair in lieu of mechanical repair methods. You should even more forcefully persuade the Owner/Engineer of his folly. I would futher my caveat and state that the Owner/Engineer will bear all responsibility for any liability due to failure of repairs in service and that your company will not warrant the repair; stating that the repair is made under duress. I would check it with Legal for their input prior to issuing the abvove to the Owner/Engineer before contemplating and proceeding with the repair.

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

NDT of the repair welds as final acceptance by the Owner - using Liquid PT or WFMT.

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

You can't be too cautious.  Often WI failures are due to inclusions.  Trying to weld repair these is like trying to repair stress cracking, it is a loosing propsition.
Mechanical repair is better.  Add reinforcement, bracing or backing and join by bolts or rivets.
We repaired some overhead steel work in an old plant.  After a few trys welding we gave up and did it all mechanical.

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Corrosion, every where, all the time.
Manage it or it will manage you.
http://www.trent-tube.com/contact/Tech_Assist.cfm

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

The last sentence of your first paragraph should say " 'by' grinding and rewelded.", not "my".  I don't know if you just typed that in the window or copied and pasted.  Spell check won't find it.

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

(OP)
Thanks

Vita sine litteris mors est.

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

Well, I looked a little closer:

REFERENCE:  Kidder Parker Architects' and Builders' Handbook
            Edited by Frank E. Kidder and Harry Parker
            18th Edition, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1936

Page 412:
"Welds:  Wrought iron is more easily welded than steel because the work may be accomplished through a wider range of temperature than with steel.  A weld may develop the full strength of the bar, but tests on hand-forged welds on rough tie-bars reported by Kirkaldy gave average values of about 60% of the strength of the bar."

So, while wrought iron may be easy to weld, there seems to be a significant drop in the strength.  I would think alternative repairs would give better and safer results.

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

I think the reference in  Kidder Parker Architects' and Builders' Handbook concerns forge welding - fusion welding is a much different proposition.

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

Also, in the final sentence - "peal" is what a bell does, "peel" makes more sense there to me.

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding


Rich2001,

Please refer to this thread thread 181-27567

Thanks,

teb1

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

(OP)
thread181-25767 ?

Vita sine litteris mors est.

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

It has the name of a company and a procedure that might be of benefit to you in this cast iron repair project.

Teb1

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

(OP)
What is the title of thread181-27567 ?

The 181 designenates the "CSI (construction) Code Issues Forum."

Vita sine litteris mors est.

RE: Wrought Iron Bridge Repair by Welding

Sorry 'bout that.  Try the thread listed below with regard to a cast iron turbine case repair.

thread725-116788

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources