more on engineer degrees
more on engineer degrees
(OP)
I work with a guy that constantly refers to his degree as a “bachelor of science in civil engineering”. I see this guy’s framed certificate on the wall and it actually reads “Bachelor of Engineering Technology”. I have never heard him refer to himself as an engineer. But here’s the thing, no one here considers the guy an “engineer”. He is a low level CMT technician, has been for 10 years, and will likely continue to be one for the next 20.
1) Is it a matter of poor ethical judgment for him to refer to his degree in the manner in which he does?
2) Should I just MYOB?
1) Is it a matter of poor ethical judgment for him to refer to his degree in the manner in which he does?
2) Should I just MYOB?





RE: more on engineer degrees
RE: more on engineer degrees
Wes C.
------------------------------
When they broke open molecules, they found they were only stuffed with atoms. But when they broke open atoms, they found them stuffed with explosions...
RE: more on engineer degrees
RE: more on engineer degrees
I graduated from Ryerson Polytechnical in Toronto with a three year diploma, making me an engineering technologist. Ryerson has since become a university, granting Bachelor of Engineering degrees. At one time, I think it was a Bachelor of Applied Science. The graduates are now qualified to be professional engineers.
Does his certificate really say "Degree"? "Engineering Technology" sounds like something I was taught.
JHG
RE: more on engineer degrees
I know that in Canada, various universities grant degrees in engineering under various names. For example:
Bachelor's of Engineering
Bachelor's of Applied Science
I personally have a Bachelor's of Applied Science Chemical Engineering (as distict and different from Bachelor's of Applied Science I suppose).
Here is another thought. I also have a diploma in computer science, obtained through my local college. When I worked as a software developer, I hung that up on my office cubicle divider. Although I have a PE, and a engineering degree, I wasn't using it, so I kept it at home. In conversations with collegues, it would have come up that I have an "engineering degree", even though a diploma was in my cubbie. People may also have interpreted that I was misleading them with regards to my degree and licensing - although I wasn't.
In any case, he is not representing himself as a PE (not relevant to your degree). I would just let it go.
RE: more on engineer degrees
RE: more on engineer degrees
Great. So the only person who cares is YOU. get over it.
Cheers
Greg Locock
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.
RE: more on engineer degrees
ABET, Inc., is the recognized U.S. accreditor of college and university programs in applied science, computing, engineering, and technology.
RE: more on engineer degrees
John
RE: more on engineer degrees
ZCP
www.phoenix-engineer.com
RE: more on engineer degrees
Usually see it in someone's office but seldom see a BSc at the work place, Masters and PhD's sometimes but not always either for those that have them.
Rick Kitson MBA P.Eng
Construction Project Management
From conception to completion
www.kitsonengineering.com
RE: more on engineer degrees
It can also be culture. The new person coming into the office notices all the licenses, certificates and degrees on other people's walls, will most likely bring his/hers in also.
It's their wall, and unless there is a rule against hanging things on it...
RE: more on engineer degrees
Hg
Eng-Tips policies: FAQ731-376
RE: more on engineer degrees
ABET accredits engineering technology programs also. Better than wallpaper, but not the same as an ABET accredited engineering program.
RE: more on engineer degrees
In Case of Emergency, Break Glass
Wes C.
------------------------------
When they broke open molecules, they found they were only stuffed with atoms. But when they broke open atoms, they found them stuffed with explosions...
RE: more on engineer degrees
Sounds like much ado about nada.
--------------------
Bring back the HP-15
www.hp15c.org
--------------------
RE: more on engineer degrees
RE: more on engineer degrees
Hg
Eng-Tips policies: FAQ731-376
RE: more on engineer degrees
It isn't that I'm not proud of the work I did to get it, more that I prefer useful or interesting things on my walls.
It reads Bachelor of Applied Science in Engineering. No distinction that I took mechanical engineering. That information resides at the association and is checked when you take a job.
RE: more on engineer degrees
Cheers
Greg Locock
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.
RE: more on engineer degrees
RE: more on engineer degrees
RE: more on engineer degrees
RE: more on engineer degrees
Wes C.
------------------------------
When they broke open molecules, they found they were only stuffed with atoms. But when they broke open atoms, they found them stuffed with explosions...
RE: more on engineer degrees
RE: more on engineer degrees
Most of these degrees are 4 yr degrees but taught on an atypical schedule of all year long. They just don't go into the depth a real engineering curriculum would.
Its too bad some of your colleges did not put what discipline on your degrees. Seems like a major oversight on their behalf.
If someone wants to hang their degree, let them. I have no problem with it. Mine is not hanging anywhere but each to his own.
If the guy thinks he is an engineer, then his supervisor should politely correct him, if indeed he is not an engineer at this particular company. He may be an engineer their but without the typical education. Then again, maybe he is just a technician. I don't remember reading where you stated what his title actually is.
I have worked at a place where they called people electrical engineers to their customers. These people did not even know ohms law. Unfortunatley, they actually believed they had some engineering ability, very, very scary. The manager(supposedly) was an engineer but he never made a qualm about it. I believe he wanted their customers to think they actually employed several engineers. The place was a real joke. Project managers were people who did not even go to college and had no clue on how to design a product or the steps involved. Their equipment was very dangerous, in my opinion, and I exited out of there in a hurry. So the guy may just not have a clue that he is really not an engineer, especially if he has engineer in his title.
RE: more on engineer degrees
Every course longer than about three days gets you a “Certificate of Military Achievement” which is a nice certificate suitable for framing. (Some of these are real courses with stringent pass requirements and some are simply attend only touchy feely ones with little enduring merit.)
Add to that military commission scrolls, university diplomas, licenses and the usual parting gifts from each posting and assignment and sooner or later every individual has a vast collection of stuff, some meaningful: the result of some hard work and a lot of it only of significance to that individual.
If someone puts it all on a wall then it is called an “I love me.” wall.
Rick Kitson MBA P.Eng
Construction Project Management
From conception to completion
www.kitsonengineering.com
RE: more on engineer degrees
If you don't create a new working, profitable design annually and/or haven't solved a differential equation in 1 year, you must relinquish your degrees until doing so... and then subsequently be re-deemed as a utile engineer.
...Kind of like renewing your drivers license.
RE: more on engineer degrees
If I ever work in a real office with real walls that reach the ceiling, I will put them up... Until then, they share wall-space with some rather embarassing baby photos.
RE: more on engineer degrees
My major: Mechanical Engineering Technology
ABET accredited University
Do I consider myself an engineer - yes
Can I sit for the FE/PE - yes
RE: more on engineer degrees
Anyone can be an engineer in my estimation if they fit the criterial. Orville and Wilber Wright, the 1st and arguable the best aeronautical engineers ever, had no formal engineering training. In fact, Orville didn't even graduate from high school, let alone ABET.
Thomas Alvia Edison. The father of the electrical age, the greatest inventer ever, no formalized engineering training, in fact his mother home schooled him. He never set foot on a college campus.
I could go on forever.
With the great achivements of these men (women) and men (women) like them, only a fool would dare challenge their credentials. These were some of the best engineers the world has yet seen.
Guiness recognizes guiness. Don't look at the title, certificates, or no. of degrees, respect the skills. Real engineers want to be engineers because they love the field. They do things that people say can't be done, or don't want to do. They are a special breed. Real engineers want to feel like engineers. If someone needs to design rockets thats fine. If someone needs to feel like he can solve a differential equation, good enough. If someone needs to know all the asoteric clause of the National Electrical code, good too. If someone needs to come up with a patentable idea, well enough. Regardless, we always recognize our own, the advertisement of a degree makes it obvious, but its not required.
Just so no one says, "he's saying that because he's not an engineer", I have a Bachelors and Masters Degree from an ABET accredited school, I've been practicing for 6 years, and I'm sitting for my PE in April. Yet I still aspire to feel like an engineer.
RE: more on engineer degrees
"Congratulations. You now have a piece of paper that entitles you to go out a learn how to be an engineer."
-Dr. Baldwin, CSM ChemEng Dept.
Even though I didn't stay in the design side of engineering, I still tell people "I'm an engineer" when they ask what I do. More accurately, I don't "do" engineering. It's more of what I "am". This distinction is lost on most non-engineers...
RE: more on engineer degrees
“Congratulations you now have a license to learn how to fly.”
Too bad I didn’t have enough spare money.
Formal education is only the starting point of engineering. A degree is more about teaching you how to think like an engineer (or any other profession). You may get some specifically useful knowledge but in most fields even that will become obsolete in a few years. That’s why continuing education is such a hot topic in all professions.
However an adequate foundation in formal education is essential to gain the maximum benefit from the experience.
That is why all professional bodies have experience requirements for full membership, because it is simply impossible to teach the profession in an academic setting.
Rick Kitson MBA P.Eng
Construction Project Management
From conception to completion
www.kitsonengineering.com
RE: more on engineer degrees
RE: more on engineer degrees
RE: more on engineer degrees
Rick Kitson MBA P.Eng
Construction Project Management
From conception to completion
www.kitsonengineering.com
RE: more on engineer degrees
I worked for Project Engineer at an aerospace company who's degree was in biochemestry (we were in a structural *design* group). He however, continued to take engineering courses, in areas where *He* felt he was lacking. He also took courses to stay UP in the field. We actually took a couple of graduate courses together. One in Vibrations another in matlab.
I know he was quite active in the SAE, and he continually took courses in the *technology* that was rapidly changind (CATIA coursework).
BUT---- He has NO Engineering degree.... So he says, he's an engineer... he works as an engineer... (now for all of those who will say that he isn't liscensed - in CA aero is an exempt industry, so that is out of the discussion)...
now I thought he was a very competent engineer... except he spelled better than engineers... what do you think?
Wes C.
------------------------------
When they broke open molecules, they found they were only stuffed with atoms. But when they broke open atoms, they found them stuffed with explosions...
RE: more on engineer degrees
In those jurisdictions where there are laws/acts/legistlation/other legal requirements to calling yourself an engineer, then, you need to meet those requirements before you can "legally" call yourself an engineer. For example, Canada.
In those jurisidiction where there are not, then you can call yourself an engineer, as there is no "legality" involved. For example, I don't have one, so can someone help me out here.
I specifically want to avoid any moral, ethical, etc, reasons as that is covered elsewhere.
RE: more on engineer degrees
Call your dog an engineer in the US if you want, cannot do that in Canada because there is right to title and to use it, with limited exceptions, you MUST be a member of at least one provincial association.
In wes616’s example it appears that the individual does have the necessary academic background to benefit from the experience in an engineering field.
You could not take someone out of high school, sit them down and teach them how to crank out some sort of design and expect them to gain anything near professional experience out of doing them.
You could however take s graduate of a science, math or engineering program and do the same thing and then have them actually get some professional experience doing the same thing.
The difference is that the high schooler would only be doing things in a mechanical fashion with no understanding of why he was doing them and the graduate would have some knowledge of where the equations he was using came from.
I was using the example of needing suitable academic qualification not in terms of only ABET accredited programs but in the more general sense of having some suitable academic background.
Rick Kitson MBA P.Eng
Construction Project Management
From conception to completion
www.kitsonengineering.com
RE: more on engineer degrees
I am licensed in 10 states. In about 1/2 of them, anyone can refer to themselves as an engineer. But in the other half, only PEs can call themselves engineers. I've read the rules that each state has on this, so I am quite sure of what I'm talking about and its not my particular interpretation of the law. New Jersey is one of the states where only PEs are engineers. The only exception to this is for the employees of manufacturing firms and even then its only within the confines of their office. So the moment that these folks have any communication with anyone outside the office, they are NOT engineers of any kind.
Ashereng,
What state do you work in? I'll be happy to look up the regulations regarding whether your state allows you to call yourself an engineer.
RE: more on engineer degrees
I have worked in the State of Illinois (The Prairie State).
My lack of knowledge was in which states can anyone refer to themselves as an engineer (without a PE).
RE: more on engineer degrees
New York is a state that does allow non-PEs to refer to themselves as engineers. It is not unique in this position, as others allow it also.
Regards.
RE: more on engineer degrees
RE: more on engineer degrees
I didn't know that. New York eh? Thanks.