×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Relay test equipment

Relay test equipment

Relay test equipment

(OP)
Our company is in the process of looking for a new relay test set. Does anyone have any suggestions? We are reviewing the
Megger MPRT, KoCos ARTES 440 II, Omicron and Doble 6100. We have experience with the Doble 2200 series of test sets but would like to move away from them.

Any suggestions would be helpful.

RE: Relay test equipment

Why are you looking to move away from the Doble 2200 series?

RE: Relay test equipment

(OP)
The biggest reason we are moving from the 2200 series is size and weight. You have to setup 3 of them to test any new relay.

The newer test sets source as many as 4 voltages and 6 currents at the same time. (in one convenient package). For field testing portability is a major concern. The newer test sets are also lighter (helps reduce the potential for injury while carrying the equipment).

RE: Relay test equipment

(OP)
Thanks for the information and replies. Does anyone have experience with Omicron? If so does it handle older electromechanical relays well?

RE: Relay test equipment

Use to be a place in KC called Slaughter that made specialized relay test equipment, don't know if they're still around or not.

RE: Relay test equipment

I haved used Omicron and there should be no problem with electromechanicals. You can't really automate the testing. The old electromechanicals typically only have one protective function so there is no reason or ability to talk to the relay. You simply dial in the parameters on the current and voltage supply and energize. You can time the contact changeovers as well.
I have not used many testers except Manta, Omicron, and Doble. For relay testing, Omicron beats all of the above hands down.
FYI - there is some software that recently came out that can be used with a bunch of testers. This allows one software package to be used for multiple testers. This is something worthwhile if your company uses different test sets but only wants to use one software package to reduce the number of test sequences needing programmed into different test sets. Write one test program for any test set.

RE: Relay test equipment

(OP)
What makes the Omicron the better test set? I have used the Manta and did not like it.

Does anyone have experience with the new Megger MPRT?

RE: Relay test equipment

I currently Use the doble 6150 relay test set and I love it! It is light weight, it can support 6 voltages and 6 currents (lower VA of course) and it comes with software that has a good range of Macros (to help automate tests...very good for Ohmic Reach circles)

We also have an Omicron Relay Test set and Personally I don't really like it. It seems harder to set up and the tests arn't as easy to automate like with the doble. They do put out a much better looking report though.

My vote is definatley for the Doble 6150! After I got good with this test set I could easily test up to 4 involved SEL relays in 10 hours (351s and the like).

RE: Relay test equipment

(OP)
Has anyone had any experience with the new MANTA MTS-5000?
Seems like a pretty good unit. It has enough VA to do a KD-10 set at 0.3 ohms reach. No problem.

Does anyone really use 6 currents for relay testing? If so how often?

RE: Relay test equipment

Testing a three-phase diff relay would use 6 currents.

RE: Relay test equipment

(OP)
More often than not I find myself paralleling the 6 currents into a more useful 3 current arrangement. I agree with davidbeach's comment but it is not mandatory.

RE: Relay test equipment

You can get away with using three currents and series connecting (NOT parallel) the two sides of the diff relay only for a machine diff relay or a transformer diff set for 1:1 voltage ratio and wye-wye or delta-delta configurations.  Any other configuration of a transformer diff that produces non-equal currents under non-fault conditions would require all 6 currents to test it for three phase operation.  It may also be possible to test the relay phase at a time and only need two current inputs.

RE: Relay test equipment

(OP)
From your experience is it faster to use 6 currents or just test single phase?

RE: Relay test equipment

With single phase relays the most currents you would need would be two (to test a current differential). However, most of the microprocessor relays are three phase in one box. Also, not all manufactuers publish a method for testing three phase relays single phase. To further complicate things, three phase relays perform angle compensation inside the box instead of relying on a simple rewire of the CT's to shift the currents to match the opposite current. The compensating current that is used in three phase relays will be a phase to phase current which makes single phase testing a real intresting propositon. And finally, because three phase relays use phase to phase angle compensation, the relay also has to know the phase sequence or the compensation will be wrong.

Remember when you actually calibrated relays, slaving over a hot load box. Ahh, those were the days. By the way, hi David Beach, its Mike Young, how's life in the big city.

RE: Relay test equipment

(OP)
Valid points indeed. What type of test set do you use?

RE: Relay test equipment

Hi Mike, welcome to the forum.  You will probably also have lots of fun in forum238, the Power Engineering Forum.

RE: Relay test equipment

Its been over 10 years since I was testing on a regular basis, its mostly been demonstration of relays to customers. I don't have the current hands on to help you pick a model from experience.

Once you have it boiled down to 2 or 3 vendors ask them to send an application engineer (not a sales rep) to demo the unit, and ask them if you can keep it for a few weeks to try it out. Most of the companies have demos for just such things.


RE: Relay test equipment

(OP)
Thanks for all the response. We have settled on the Manta MTS-5000.

Just as mikey70 suggested we invited application engineers to demo their units. The litmus test was a Beckwith 3420 generator relay and a KD-10 with a reach of 0.31 ohms. The Manta unit handled everything wonderfully.

The Manta unit proved to cover all the bases we need.

I would like to thank everyone for the input.

RE: Relay test equipment

Is there anyone wo is looking to sell any used doble relay equipment ie. 2200 series test sets with pro test?

RE: Relay test equipment

There was a set on ebay for 25K. Kinda spendy don't ya think? I've been looking for test equipment for the last couple of months and its really hit and miss. Its not a commodity so if no one else happens to be looking at it you may get it real cheap, especially if its something the seller doesn't know anything about. If 2 or 3 get on there that know what test equipment costs then in can cost just as much as going through a dealer who has checked it out and repaired it. I will try to find the link to the dobles and post it here. I am looking for something older, SR 51, SR 76, SSR-78, manta 1710, etc.

RE: Relay test equipment

Mikey70,

keep your eye here for SR51 or 76.  http://www.govliquidation.com/index.html

Bought one about 1 year ago and it cost more to ship from CA than I paid for it.  When I it arrived the original leads (and orignal rubberbands I believe) were in it.

Just like Ebay, hit and miss, but not as much bid competition.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources