×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Compression strength of concrete cube
3

Compression strength of concrete cube

Compression strength of concrete cube

(OP)
We want to tilt a 100 ton vertical generator rotor to horizontal position by placing it on 40 inch x 40 inch x 40 inch rebarred concrete cube.

The rotor will be hung from a crane at the top and it will be turned on its coupling flange till it is horizontal.

Will this concrete cube hold the 100 ton weight ?

What I am worried about is the pressure at the point of contact of the coupling flange with the concrete block. The whole weight, at least for some time, will be concentrated at this line contact.

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

Having the line of contact being directly on the concrete cube is not a good idea. However, if you have a suitably sized steel base plate installed on top of the cube, and have the line of contact on top of this steel plate, it should work. Best to get your civil/structural engineer involved to design the base plate and to ensure that whatever the cube sits on is adequate for the load.

www.SlideRuleEra.net

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

(OP)
Thx SlideRuleEra.

If I place a 10 inch x 10 inch dry, solid wood along the axis of tilt, will it distribute the load over the block ?

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

If you had the load distributed evenly across the cube face, your contact stress is only 125 psi.  Depending on the dimensions of the flange, the actual contact stress could remain low or be very high.

Assuming your 10x10 piece of wood is 10x10x40, you would have a contact stress of 500 psi, still relatively small.

If your contact face of the wood is 10x10, then your stress goes to 2000 psi, still not enough to locally fail the concrete in compression; however, you are skirting with overstressing the wood!

Since the cube is reinforced, shear would not be a big deal as your shear area is large and the rebar will help.

We load test concrete piles to 100 tons routinely.  They typically range in butt size from 10x10 to 24x24 or are 12 to 20 inches in diameter.  About the only time we fail the concrete is when there is an anomaly in the concrete, usually near the top of the pile.

In short, use SlideRuleEra's suggestion of a steel plate for load distribution and you'll likely be OK.  Even a 1/4" thick steel plate will help you considerably.

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

(OP)
Thx Ron.

I will use a 1/2" steel plate on top of the block and then on top of this plate, a 10" x 10" x 40" solid wood.

Hopefully this would distribute the load.

Will let you know how this works.

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

it seems like the steel will distribute the load, you don't need wood also

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

i think the wood is probably to protect his machinery. could be worng though

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

10" x 10" wood will help protect the machinery, but 40 inches thick as stated above is overkill.  I would suggest a steel base plate with a 2" x 10" or 4" x 10" wood member on top

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

(OP)
Thx cvg & TFL

Yes, the wood is to protect the shaft and it is 10" x 10" which is 40" long to suit the top surface of concrete block.

Sometime today, I should have a picture of this arrangement and will post it here.

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

(OP)
The framework for holding the steel plate (20 mm thick) and the wooden block is getting ready. It should be done by tomorrow.

What do you think is the best wood for this application (high compression)?

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

#1 Teak
#2 Oak

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

(OP)
Thx itsmoked. I see that you are curious about this.

Now that you are here (???), I wanted to ask you how got those pictures directly (not through links) into your posts.

I should be ready with the pictures of my arrangement soon and I realised that despite my brave words, I didn't know how to post them here.

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

Hi edison123!

We have to stop meeting in here... People will talk.

I wrote the following faq just for posting stuff.
FAQ238-1161

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

(OP)
Thx once again itsmoked (you used to be an electrician ???).

Point 8 of your faq was good. I always goof up on my posts.

One more star for you and what a place to pick it up.

I should have the jig (and the jpg) ready in another 4 hours.

Don't wait up too long.

cheers.

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

(OP)
You can see the pictures directly in

thread238-140877

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

(OP)
Now I learnt the tricks, you can see the pictures here also.

The 1st one shows the concrete block in white. On top of it is the the 20 mm steel plate and the newly made angled brace to retain the 10" wooden sleepers.





The 2nd one below shows the wooden sleepers in place with the groove in front where the coupling rim will sit during tilting.




Will this work ? The crane operator is very good.

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

(OP)
Thx to all MVP's here, the job was done today.

Here is the sequence (I have RF'ed by previous pictures) to reduce the thread download time).






















But for the damned wood crushing, it would have been "picture perfect" ending.

Thank you all once again for your valuable tips and advice.

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

edison123 thanks for the hassle of putting in the pics. There great!

That is one big muther!!

I would expect and personally desire some crushed wood.  It totally limits sliding and helps reduce rolling.

Hey where did you say your job site is?

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

(OP)
Yeah, it is a 100 ton monstress (???) and I get to 'do her' three times in next one year. It is in Malaysia.

You could put a +ve spin (half glass full) on the crushed wood, I guess. That wood is a goner anyway.

I am now having a coupla' beers for having got thru' the day without killing anyone.

RE: Compression strength of concrete cube

HA! CHEERS.cheers

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources