×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Strange forces on restraints

Strange forces on restraints

Strange forces on restraints

(OP)
Hi all,

I am using CaesarII software to analyze stress on a steam piping system.

I am astonished because the results show forces on nodes where I am not putting restraints, and it also show displacements at this same nodes (and I'm not using gaps).

This is the first time I see something like this.

I have to say that I'm using some kind of template file prepared by a ex-colleague for this project.

Does anyone know what can be going on? I'm thinking in a special parameter of the program configuration file, but reading the documentation I don't see anything like this.

Advanced thanks

RE: Strange forces on restraints

sounds like C-nodes
which are placed in the pipework to emulate an pipe/pipe anchor.

C-nodes are coded on the restraints panel

RE: Strange forces on restraints

(OP)
Superpiper,

I am not using C-nodes at the moment, so the answer has to go by other way.

The reactions are lower than the real one, but thet exist. For example, in a node restrained in X-Y appear the 3 reactions (X, Y and Z), but the Z component is much lower than the X one (10% of the other more or less).

RE: Strange forces on restraints

Give your Coade dealer a ring or contact coade directly.
they will spot the problem very quickly and for free.

RE: Strange forces on restraints

scalabres,

"the results show forces on nodes where I am not putting restraints" - The local and global elelment forces reports will have the internal forces between elements.  The restraint report will show forces at only the nodes with restraints or displacement reactions.

"it also show displacements at this same nodes (and I'm not using gaps)" - Each node in a piping system will have deflection or movement due to gravity or thermal effects, unless it is restrained at that node against those effects by a support or anchor.  Are the movements inputted as the displacements of anchor nodes, corresponding to the thermal movements of equipment connections?
  
If the node with X-Y restraint also has a reaction in Z axis, could it be result from friction at the restraint?

RE: Strange forces on restraints

(OP)
ApC2Kp,

> The restraint report will show forces at only the nodes with restraints or displacement reactions.

This is not what appear in my line as I have forces on not restrained directions. But I think you are right and this is a question of friction. In fact, I'm introducing a 0.3 frictional coefficient, but I understood that the friction forces only appear when I have a gap and the pipe can move in the direction specified. Now, I've read the documentation of the program regarding friction forces:

Ideally, if there is motion at the node in question, the friction force is equal to (Mu * Normal force). However, since we have a non-rigid stiffness at that location to resist the initial motion, the node can experience displacements. The force at the node will be the product of the displacement and the stiffness. If this resultant force is less than the maximum friction force (Mu * Normal force), the node is assumed to be "not sliding," even though we see displacements in the output report.

More interesting still:

For dry friction, the friction force magnitude is a step function of displacement. This discontinuity determines the problem as intrinsically nonlinear and eliminates the possibility of using the superposition principle.

I think this is the reason of the reactions in directions not restricted.

> Are the movements inputted as the displacements of anchor nodes, corresponding to the thermal movements of equipment connections?

No, I am not using displacements nor C-nodes.

Thank you for your answer, you gave me the way

RE: Strange forces on restraints

Have you done a input graphics plot to see what is shown that looks unusual. I like the ALT+F12 to get the two line plot, the volume of the hoops graphics sometimes hides the info inside the pipe. Check all of the buttons for Forces, Springs, Displacements and Restraints. Make sure the shift is on so the nodes are displayed for the activated items.

Also, check the input file individual reports. Supports for a node can be called out on ANY suceeding node.

Good Luck,

NozzleTwister
Houston, Texas

RE: Strange forces on restraints

On the above post I meant SHIFT+F12 for the two line plot.

NozzleTwister
Houston, Texas

RE: Strange forces on restraints

Scalabres,

For the benifit of other who might encounter this same problem in the future, could you post this thread on COADE Caesar forum? This issue is more suited in that forum. Thanks.

Phil

RE: Strange forces on restraints

scalabres,

Did you ever find out what the problem was? Please give us an update.

NozzleTwister
Houston, Texas

RE: Strange forces on restraints

(OP)
The point was that if you consider a friction coefficient (0.3 in my case), frictional forces arise in both horizontal axes (X and Z) independent of the restraints you consider.

So, if I have a non restrained direction, i.g. X, I get as result a displacement and a reaction. The force at the node will be the product of the displacement and the stiffness. If this resultant force is less than the maximum friction force (Mu * Normal force), the node is assumed to be "not sliding," even though we see displacements in the output report. But it appear a force in that direction.

I hope this can help.

How can I post the whole thread in other group?

RE: Strange forces on restraints

(OP)
Thank you, PhilEduard. Do you think that there is another answer to my problem?

I made this question to COADE staff few days ago and they replied me in this way of friction forces.

Anyway, I didn't know there were forums at COADE site, I have just now get registered so in the future I will also post my problems there.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources