×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Stamping EIT's structural work
4

Stamping EIT's structural work

Stamping EIT's structural work

(OP)
What is the consensus regarding stamping the work of junior engineers at the firm.  I have been asked to start stamping all the structural work in the office.  It is good work and meets all the definitions of "responsible charge" so its no ethical dilemma there.

My problem is more philosophical in that I am simply an employee with no ownership in the firm. At other (larger) firms I was employed at, typically only the business owners/principals were asked to stamp others' work; you stamped your own work, but not others' work, as an employee.

My mental hangup with this new request by the boss is that I don't mind "hanging my license out" for others but I do mind others "hanging my license out" for others. Two others is one too many in my current mindset.

I have had my license for nine years now and it STILL tightens my schincter somewhat to stamp my own work that I engineered from top to bottom. I will have to come to grips with this new request and I will basically be repeating a large percentage of this EIT's engineering in my check of the drawings before I will be OK stamping it.  Lincoln freed the slaves and and structural engineering jobs are plentiful and I know where the office front door is located; this is only a problem as long as I want it to be a problem I guess.

Are many of you licensed guys being asked to stamp the work of others under your responsible charge as a simple employee?    

RE: Stamping EIT's structural work

Make sure you understand your personal liablity, and are aware of the insurance your company provides.  I'd recommend having a detailed dicussion of the corporate and personal liabilities.  I'm like you, I don't really like stamping others work unless I have thoroughly reviewed it.  It's a lot of responsiblity.  Unfortunately a lot of engineers take it lightly.  Some even stamp without even really reviewing the drawings and calculations, which should never be done.  

Also, make sure you ask for compensation in pay for your new responsiblity.  You are taking on quite a responsiblity when you stamp others work, and sticking your reputation on the line for others.  It is a big deal and you should treat it as such.  No matter how much time you say you'll devote to reviewing the work, you'll usually be pressed for time.

RE: Stamping EIT's structural work

Just a couple of things that you might want to consider:

Do you feel that you are adequately being compensated for this new responsiblity?

Are you being given adequate time to review this work before you stamp it?

Are you the EIT's supervisor? If not why doesn't his supervisor stamp the work?

Do you actively oversee the EIT's work while he is doing it or are you reviewing it after the fact?

Is your name included on the company's E&O insurance policy?

Are their others at your firm who stamp drawings? What is their feelings on this?


RE: Stamping EIT's structural work

I feel that if you are stamping drawings, you should be compensated at the level of upper management. This is precisely why I don't stamp even my own work where I am employed, athough I'm a PE.

RE: Stamping EIT's structural work

in most states, a firm must have a certificate of authorization to practice engineering.  The state board of registration keeps a list of PE's who will be sealing and signing drawings for the firm.  Your name must be on that list or you could be in violation of your state's licensing laws.

RE: Stamping EIT's structural work

(OP)
Thanks for the advice guys.  Pay is commensurate with responsibility; stamping my own engineering is scary; stamping others' engineering gives me the shakes.

I already have a verbal agreement with the boss about liability insurance and will get it in writing for the statute of repose (7 years Colorado, 10 years New Mexico).  I long ago signed all my valuable possessions (house, land, cars) to my wife for liability reasons to keep some lawyer from crawling from underneath his rock and going after that stuff.

I had not thought about the certificate of authorization stuff, but that is something to consider.

RE: Stamping EIT's structural work

I'm an employee and seal the work of someone under my supervision.  And did it at a previous job- but there the people in question were basically drafters, not EIT engineers.  I do go through and check the drawings very carefully.

One issue is whether you actually supervise these people, and you seem satisfied on that end.  One is whether you trust them enough to know whether you need to check every last dimension and number, or just know they did a good job and stamp it.

If they actually do have an EIT, by all means encourage them to get their PE.

Make sure you have an understanding with your boss as to the extent for which they would hold you responsible for errors.  If they expect you to check every last detail, then they need to allow you time for that.  And if not, they need to be aware that errors are the EIT's, not your own.

It would make a difference as well how complicated and how critical your work is- whether you're building suspension bridges or outhouses.

RE: Stamping EIT's structural work

Isn't it the idea of the EIT to have him work under a licensed professional engineer who mentors him - and, thereby, checks and reviews his work?  As such, the design is done under your supervision and, seemingly, you can stamp the work as such.  If he was an EIT that wasn't working directly under you on the particular project, then you couldn't sign the work even if you wanted to.  If the EIT can't do work that is able to be put out, then what good is it to have an EIT on staff and would thus negate the whole concept of such.

RE: Stamping EIT's structural work

sundale...I don't see why you are fretting so much.  This is common in most larger firms and the premise that BigH talks about is a necessary part of the mentoring/licensing process.

Make sure you are considered a Senior person having supervisory responsibility over those individual for whom you will REVIEW and sign (technical supervisory responsibility might be different than administrative supervisory responsibility, depending on your firm's structure).  Since you are taking the responsibility for the design you must adequately review that design for concurrence.

RE: Stamping EIT's structural work

I have spent many years stamping drawings of those who worked under me. Later they went on to get PE's and stamp their own drawings. As thier supervisor, I reviewed them just as closely. The trick is to be involved from the beginning on the project. In most cases the firm indemnifies the engineeer, although in a case of gross negligence, you may have exposure. The firms insurance should cover not only the liability but the cost of defense. So generally there really is not a lot of exposure for the employee. At least where I am, thats how it is. However, the firm should be licensed as a design corperastion and does not hurt to have a coperate engineeering stamp on the documents also, although I rarely see that.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources