×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

need feedback mcquay chiller
3

need feedback mcquay chiller

need feedback mcquay chiller

(OP)
my client asking for mcquay because of its lowest price.
Does anybody had experience with McQuay screw WSC 079 - 087 and/or centrif AGS 400. I need opinion about them; How reliable?, is it good or bad.

RE: need feedback mcquay chiller

I can't comment on the specific chiller you mention.  However, I can tell you that with chillers, you get what you pay for.

The lowest priced chiller will probably suffer with a greater number of breakdowns.  The noise level may be higher, and the chiller COP will almost certainly be lower.

My advice, is to calculate the operating cost (based on the chiller COP over the expected chiller life) and add this to the initial purchase price.  This is a much better indication of true chiller cost.

Hope this helps,

Cooky

RE: need feedback mcquay chiller

I wouldn't touch a mcquay screw chiller with a 10' pole

RE: need feedback mcquay chiller

"Cookie" has very good advice.  Without naming names, I have seen multiple oil pump failures (during factory witness testing) and chillers flash-flooded with rain midway up their shells on the truck dock awaiting shipment.

As for air-cooled recips and screws, I've seen shells fracture because of inadequate freeze protection (internal to the chiller), multiple compressor failures within the first 2-3 years, and plastic condenser fan blades separate and slice through the coil bundle on their way to impaling the building structure.

"Cme" also has an interesting comment.  I wonder why he limited it with the word "screw"?  Perhaps that was just becuase of the specificity requested with this thread.

RE: need feedback mcquay chiller

P.S. Just to be clear, I have no actual experience with the specific model chillers you mention.  Yet, the experiences I relate are true.  Whether they are anomalies or a general trend, is something you should decide on your own.

For many property owners, a chiller is the most expensive and  most complicated piece of equipment they will ever own.  Cost cutting and a possible sacrifice in quality results in diminishing returns - very quickly.

Even with the experiences I related, the decisions were based on supposed added capability, not lower cost.  It was thought that the price was an added benefit.  However, even the "added capability" was not enough to make up for the eventual problems.

RE: need feedback mcquay chiller

(OP)
Thank you guys for all the comment.

Yes, previous centrif mcquay had a sound pitch as loud as jet engine. But new design implementing 'liquid injecton' method in order to reduce pitchy sound. The compressor discharge area is injected with liquid (refrigerant) droplet from condenser. The idea is to absorb compressor' sound energy while droplet evaporate and reduce discharge superheat.... nice thought!   

But what struk me the most is the size of centrif impeler 6" diameter only and rotating more than 20.000 /minute. High rotation does mean lower component lifetime. McQuay also implementing extra oil lubricant reservoir + piston + compressed spring in case power outage. Does this employ with other centrifugal chiller as well? What I see is McQuay has different design compare to others... Well, I guess that unique design really make the price differ...  

RE: need feedback mcquay chiller

The primary difference in centrifugal chiller design is the choice of motor drive: open vs. semi-hermetic, and refrigerant: low pressure vs. high-pressure.  Both decisions impact lubrication issues, noise, efficiencies, and reliability.

The 6" diameter and 20,000 rpm impeller is no cause for concern itself.  Rather, it is a measure of the ratio between volume and pressure dictated by the refrigerant (higher pressure).  The McQuay centrifugal compressor design is essentially the same Westinghouse design invented 50+ years ago.  Even so, there is no inherent advantage/disadvantage with the compressor that outweighs all others.  There are preferences.

As for the oil pump/reservoir system changes, or other issues ... well - you saw my previous comments.

The attributes of that chiller design compared with Carrier's newer R-134a designs, Trane's low-pressure R-123 designs, or York's open-drives are too numerous and complicated to discuss on a forum format.

RE: need feedback mcquay chiller

Higher speed does not necessarily mean higher wear and tear or problems.  It all depends on how the product and the component is designed.  Aircraft engines run at very high speeds - are we scared to fly ???

The best way forward would be to do a cost-benefit analysis including a life cycle cost calculation and arrive at the right product for you.  Don't forget to ensure that you have local service back-ups by whichever manufacturer you choose.

Good luck

HVAC68

RE: need feedback mcquay chiller

The WSC079/087 are a very sound centrifugaldesign. Its design has been around for years and a very popular model for McQuay. Every chiller manufacturer has sweet spots for both efficiency and price so saying that the least expensive(which the majority of the time is NOT McQuay)is not a good reason to buy just doesnt make good business sense.

The biggest thing to look for is local service capabilities and knowledge of their respective equipment which McQuay is limited in certain areas of the world.

The AGS is a top of the line air cooled screw chiller which
is very reliable. It will freeze up as any flooded chiller will do if proper installation instructions are not followed. The same cannot be said for the model ALS in its early years (up to 2001). It was way too touchy for most customers in the "run it to it breaks" mode

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources