? ASTM A105 vs ASME SA105 ?
2

Question

? ASTM A105 vs ASME SA105 ?

Nukie (Nuclear)

(OP)

17 Nov 01 11:44

What is the difference between ASTM A105 and ASME SA105 ???

Thanks for you time

gunnarhole (Mechanical) · Answer 1 · 2001-11-17 14:46:09

SA-105 and A-105 are the same material. ASME adds a "S" prefix to the ASTM materials they include in Section II.

Regards

Gunnar

jmagee (Mechanical) · Answer 2 · 2001-11-18 15:15:53

RE: ? ASTM A105 vs ASME SA105 ?

jmagee (Mechanical) 18 Nov 01 15:15

gunnarhole is 100% correct.

MJCronin (Mechanical) · Answer 3 · 2001-11-20 12:00:11

Nukie,

Everything above is correct, however what is missing is the reason for the distinction.

ASME "SA" materials are permitted for use as components for ASME pressure vessels...... for example, one would expect to see SA105 carbon steel components on a vessel drawing.

ASTM "A" materials are permited for use in a Power or chemical process plant piping system designed to ASME B31.1 or B31.3.

Material Records must be maintained by the vessel fabicator for all "SA" materials......... the piping system fabricator must only supply evidence, in the form of a certificate of compliance, that the materials meet the "A" requirements.

Hope that this helps..............

MJC

lalaith (Petroleum) · Answer 4 · 2001-11-20 15:39:13

MJCronin,

This is very interesting. I would like to know where this information is referenced. This could prove very useful in my job.

Lala

Member Login

Come Join Us!

Posting Guidelines

Link To This Forum!

? ASTM A105 vs ASME SA105 ?
2