×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost
5

Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

(OP)
About 3 years ago there was a thread ( thread71-19102 ) about the life of hybrid vehicle batteries. Does anyone have any recent information along that line? Also, any idea what it the parts and labor would cost to replace the batteries?

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

If memory serves, almost the cost of the entire car to replace the batteries ;)  And if I remember correctly on lifetime, too, expect about 5 before they need replacement.  Suddenly that "deal" doesn't sound so good after all, eh?

Dan
Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

These hybrid cars seem to suffer from very low resale value for that exact reason.

Even if you spend many thousands on a new battery, it does not then become a brand new car. There will still be all the usual wear and tear on the engine, drivetrain and brakes, just as with any other car.

If you take into account depreciation as part of the total daily running cost, I suspect the total running costs of these hybrids may not look so attractive.

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

I've found the following information by sifting through toyota documents available on the internet.

The following Toyota warranty statements reflect how far they are going to go out on a limb.

Toyota's Prius warranty is 8 years / 100,000 miles on the hybrid system components e.g. inverter, electric motor, generator, and nickel metal hydride battery.

Their documentation states the expected life of the nickel metal hydride batteries is 150,000 miles "based on laboratory bench testing". The remainder of the vehicle is the typical 3 years/36,000 miles.  

Anidotial comments from my local Toyota service manager, (whom I've known for about 25 years and has shared freely what he knows on a number of technical questions) indicated they alway have some number of Prius that have crossed the 200,000 mile point on the original batteries.

Also, the service procedure does allow for replacing one or some of the (total 28 7.2v) batteries on their third generation design if there were to be an isolated early life failure. I believe the 2005 production was the first year of the third generation design.

Also I've read the batteries are typically only charged to about the 60% point as apparently this is the sweet spot for maximizing nickel metal hydride battery life at the expense of trading off additional battery reserve. This also leaves headroom for regenerative braking.

The other key difference in the nickel metal hydride batteries (developed by Panasonic for Toyota) are references in some of the literature to a "prismortal (sp?) design" that allow for very high inrush and outgo currents.. Haven't found any technical info on this..

That's all I've been able to find out so far..

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

My neighbor is a Ford dealer and they recently sent two of their master technicians to a Ford training school for their new Escape Hybrid.  One of the techs asked the instructor about battery life and they were told that there has not yet been one confirmed full failure of a battery pack (Toyota builds the Synergy Hybrid system for Ford) and that the failure of several cells will not cause a full pack failure.  Panasonic's control system has the capability of monitoring the battery packs health and make charging and discharging adjustments as needed.
He went as far as to say that given the full history of the battery pack service, that there have been relatively few failures and most Ford dealers will not stock a replacement battery pack for warranty and in-service replacement.

Franz

eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

2
Strictly anecdotal...As I've mentioned before, I'm not a great fan of these over priced hybrids, not cost effective in the overall picture, IMO.  However, my tax accountant has had two of the Toyota Prius since they first came out.  He is positively rabid about them.  One car is his wife's and has considerably less than 100,000 miles and her only complaint was that the engine kept stalling every time she came to a stop (oh well)...the other (purchased used) is now something over 200,000 miles and he has only had it in for a fix of some sensor that made it hard to start when it was cold.  Nothing more...pretty good quality as I see it but, they are still cheap, plastic, uncomfortable little POS (I would feel more comfortable in the new Lexus hybrid if it cost less than 60g's).  On that same note, as I see it, the Prius will amortize out at something like "junk yard" time if you can stand to live with it that long, I certainly could not...maybe at HALF that MSRP...Naaaaawwww---I'd still rather get standard car of equal cost should I ever entertain the idea.

Rod

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

CNNFN.com had a story about the Prius and the savings. Turns out gas has to be $9.20 a gallon for the life of the car to make you come out ahead. $5.60 a gallon for the Escape Hybrid.

Myself, by driving sanely and using cruise control on the highway, I always beat the EPA mileage by 20% or better, considering the average most people get is 15% below EPA.

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

I'm confused..

What is it about a little $21,500 car (yes my dealer is selling them at list and no more) that requires $9.20 gallon gas to justify?

That's pretty cheap as cars goes these days (and the sticker price of a Prius I've driven a couple of times).

What does it take to justify a Merecedes, BMW or $45,000 Excursion or Yukon?

Is it pounds of steel you get per dollar?  feet per dollar? bling per dollar?

Help me understand.  

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Easy, Dan.  If it wasn't for all the 'hybrid' stuff, the car would sell for $12,000 dollars and still get 35mpg.
Let's not forget, those 60mpg figures are mostly a figment of some marketing type's imagination. Robert gets about 45 and his wife gets a bit better.  I have a 1959 Nash Metropolitan that gets 39mpg on a regular basis! I made a trip from Los Angeles to the east and back in a 1960 Austin-Healy Sprite and AVERAGED 39 mpg  holding 65 mph wherever possible!!!

Rod

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Some of those older model cars are ideal candidates for being petrol misers. Often they are smaller and lighter, and are not weighed down with power steering, airconditioning, sound deadening and all the other luxuries that modern small cars usually have standard these days.

A light weight vehicle, with high compression engine, low exhaust back pressure, decent valve timing, and a really well tuned carby and ignition, can have surprising fuel economy if sensibly driven and maintained.

The depreciation will probably have fallen to about zero. It may well actually increase in value as a unique collectible vehicle.  

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Funny... the last time I bought a comparably equipped Toyota for anywhere near $12,000 was 1988.. We still have it and it's getting 30mpg with 242,000 miles on it....will probably junk it or give it away at 300,000 miles.

I guess the 54mpg I got in local driving in a rented Prius was a figment of my imagination..

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Sooo.  If your Toyota gets 30 mpg averaged over 100,000 miles... fuel cost at $3/gal. yields about 10g's.
100,000 miles at 54mpg is about $5500...
Using 15,000 miles per year you save about $56 a month.
Different strokes for different folks.
If your happy in a Prius, great.  It's not for me. With my wife spending more than $20 a week at Starbucks , it's gonna take a lot more than 56 bucks to get me all lathered up over 'hybrid technology'. Sorry!

Rod

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Oh well... some folks like the old stuff and others like to tinker with new ideas...  

I got my fill of austin healy sprite and MG midget engines many years ago.. you are a brave man to run a sprite at 65mph..

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Few of us that commute daily to work will see much running at 65Mph these days, with radar and cops everywhere it is just no longer advisable.

The only really serious disadvantage of driving an old model car that I can see is physical safety. If you get crunched under a SUV, your chances may be somewhat less than in something more recent.

But in sheer miles driven per dollar, a well maintained older car will always beat the latest new model, even if it drinks a lot more fuel.  

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Quote:

Oh well... some folks like the old stuff and others like to tinker with new ideas...

That's my point, Dan.---If you really love to tinker with modern technology (?) that's great.  Just don't try to disguise it as cost effective reality.  A used car in good shape is a much better deal if you really want to save.  
From my end, I've been riding bikes since 1949...not because they got great mileage...because they are really great fun.  I bought my last Gold Wing because it was really comfortable and trouble free---53 mpg did not turn me off, though! Motorcycles are NOT cost effective when it comes to overall cost in the long haul yet sales are up because folks want to 'save on gas'!!!
My old cars? I mostly just 'tinker' with them. I like my AC on a 100f day like today.

As to 65 in a Sprite?  I guess you really would flip if you saw me at California Speedway last September clocked at 121+mph off  turn 2 in a 1963 Austin Cooper !

Rod

 

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Quote:

Just don't try to disguise it as cost effective reality.

Never did... you dreamed that up. If your memory span is that short, go read all my posts again.

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Yep, I'll admit to memory glitches...on occasion I've started toward my shop, some 100 or so feet, reached the half way point, stopped and tried to figure WHY  I was going out to my shop!
  
I intended no offense, Dan. IMO, hybrids (at least the current offerings) are just a 'feel good' measure to assure the 'unwashed' that technology is 'fixing' our gas crises and all is well..."keep buying our stuff".

Rod

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

DanEE

Just a word of advice, go look up Rod's profile (just click on the name at the top of the post).

It should indicate that his advice is always worth consideration, and a cheap shot is not advised. Come to think of it, cheap shots are against forum rules.

I read your posts, and came to similar conclusions to Rod.

Regards

eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Yes, the hybrids are a feel good measure. The small amount of gas saved is eaten up in the extra cost of buying and maintaining all the hybrid technology. Hydrogen cars are the same as there is a net energy loss in creating the hydrogen from fossil fuels or water. And it leaks from almost everything because the molecules are the smallest of all.

The long term solution is methane as motor fuel. It burns in existing cars with little modification. The taxis in Vancouver and many other places have been using it for years. For now, it comes from natural gas but it can be generated in anaerobic reactors with genetically modified bacteria from any kind of organic waste in essentially unlimited amounts. Yes, it puts carbon in the atmosphere but if we generate it from biomass, growing the biomass takes the same amount out of the atmosphere at the same time.

But one of the biggest advantages of methane is that the distribution infrastructure is mainly in place right now. All we need is the last 3 meters to the car in most places.

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Guys,
Let me add my 2-cents to your posts.  The promise of Hybrid technology is real.  Today, you can modify your Prius to get about 100 miles per gallon (look up PHUV) on Google.  The point of the current generation hybrid is prove that it is a viable technology.  Ford does use the Toyota configuration, but be careful on suggesting that it should match Toyota's specs.  Ford to did not buy the rights to software and uses their own logic motor controls.  As far as the $12,000.00 car goes, Honda's Hybrid Civic only costs about $3,000 more than the gas engine model.  The Hybrid Civic is a more advanced design than the Prius Technology.  It is suffice to say that Toyota's Atkinson-Miller engine does not fair well when matched against Honda's IMA design.  Finally, although hydrogen cars are on the road today (Honda Civic Hydrogen)  a 2005 conference in Alaska of industry leaders from all aspects of automotive technology beleive that a biodiesel powered hybrid will be the most likely configuration for the next 30 years.

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

I just checked the honda website $22,150 for hybrid and
$15,560 for dx.  5 speed is $1000 less
$17,510 for ex.  5 speed is $1000 less
$19,260 for lx.  5 speed is $1000 less

If you want to compare apples to apples, you would have to use the lx auto model. The difference in price is $2890 and at $3.12 a gallon that would equate to 108,100 miles to break even on the money you spent on the hybrid.  Then comes the possible cost of batteries.  Not to mention the 30 less HP lost by getting the hybrid. I can only afford the ex 5-speed.  People buying civics are usually  people that don't have a lot of money.  So i cant see people spending $22,150 on a small car.

For that kind of $$$ you can get a LX Special Edition Accord.

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

I think that similar arguments were probably leveled against the automobile when it was in its infancy. Maybe it is still a bit early to judge.


In any case, there are other advantages of this vehicle beyond mileage:


Roughly speaking, in any congested area, half the cars oin the road are simply idling at an intersection. This causes lots of pollution right where people's noses are. Because hybrids often shut off when not moving, they reduce this problem - making hybrids better "city cars".

Currently a debate is raging in a stinking, polluted area of Indonesia, where owners of antiquated and heavily-polluting motorized rickshaws are resisting the forced introduction of clean and modern engines. Many of their arguments sound a lot like anti-hybrid arguments. See:

http://www.climateark.org/shared/reader/welcome.aspx?linkid=61063

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Excellent point woodbot.

Though I am in Rods camp on this issue, I am thankfull we have the opportunity to disagree, for if we didnt, it would mean technology has stalled.

So, until a Gvt. agency decides to crush Rod's car, or decides we all should drive a Prius for the cause, perhaps we could all enjoy the technology we love.

Personally, I still am looking for a nice, small 4 cyl common rail diesel to stuff into my 1995 K2500 extended cab.

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

I am all for a diverse fleet!

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Basically all I am saying its a waste of money when you look at it from cost savings point of view.  Its not a waste if you look at it from a "feel good" (green peace, democrat)point of view.

RE: Hybrid Battery Life and replacement Cost

Here is the deal with buying a hybrid in this relatively young industry.  Will you save money in the long run?  Probably, if you drive it more than 5-6 years.  Is it efficient and green? Yes.  But the real difference you make right now is supporting a growing industry that will only thrive on consumer demand.  As consumers, we can only drive efficent, environmentally concioius vehicles if we tell the car makers that they will make money by producing them.  End of story.

Those who purchase these cars now are doing us all a favor.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources