are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
(OP)
I am presently sticking glass( of 4 mm thickness ) using polyester resin onto fibre glass of around 2mm thickness . However the problem I have is that many of the pieces seem to break after some days .
My feeling is that there is an incompatibility in the coeffecient of expansions of the two materials namely glass and resin leading to this cracking during shipment by air .
I would like to know if someone has had a similar experience and the possible solution for this problem .
Thanks in advance
My feeling is that there is an incompatibility in the coeffecient of expansions of the two materials namely glass and resin leading to this cracking during shipment by air .
I would like to know if someone has had a similar experience and the possible solution for this problem .
Thanks in advance





RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
I am sure you can find each by a google search.
I am surprised that the stress build up is enough to break the glass rather than break the bond, and or stretch the polyester.
Some shrinkage of the polyester will occur on curing, creating some preload, which will be increased stress at lower temperatures.
Regards
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
Regards,
Cory
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
Actually Cory I am doing two things here -firstly I am creating the fibre glass using the resin as you described at the same time I am laying it in conatct with a glass sheet of thickness of 4mm .So the polyester resin which is reinforced with the fibre is also simultaneoulsy adhering to the glass sheet . The silane can promote the adhesion with the glass but can it avoid the stress development between the glass and the resin ?
Is there some resin which would be more compatible . Epoxy resin has a much higher expansion too .But can it be amde compatible in some way .
Regards,
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
Some mineral filler might reduce the difference to an extent that avoids breakage.
Regards
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
If you are stuck using polyesters, here is something you may consider. Add 10~15% by weight one part uncured polyurethane elastomer such as Sikaflex or equivalent, to the polyester resin and mix for a few minutes until it is completely dissolved. The result is a more flexible material than regular polyester, and should be more forgiving against the glass.
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
Pat is right that fillers generally have thermal expansion coefficients about 1/10 that of polymers. That means adding the glass fiber helps in that regard, bringing the CTE of the filled resin closer to that of the glass sheet. As Pat said, adding a mineral filler (an isotropic one like CaCO3) would help reduce the CTE further.
The second factor is the shrinkage on cure. A friend of mine did a study on how that affects bonding (J. Lange, KTH Stockholm). Anyway, what he showed is that the curing during shrinkage builds a stress at the coating / substrate interface and that tries to delaminate the joint. At the start of cure the shrinkage is there but the resin is liquid so there is no force built up. As cure proceeds the total force at the interface builds. Think of it as a spring, the force is the shrinkage x the modulus of the resin at that point in the cure. Here the glass fibers hurt you a lot because they increase the modulus of the material by 100% or even more. They only do that in the direction they are aligned too so it's important to align them evenly in all directions. Or can you remove the glass fibres? What do they give to the final product? Consider mica instead.
Regarding silanes they can help adhesion a lot, especially if water gets in to the bond area. The idea of adding something soft was also a nice one (e.g. PU) but if you can afford to lower the modulus by adding a soft component then I would suggest it's cheaper and better to just leave out or reduce the glass fiber amount.
Hope that helps.
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
But please also let me know what would be the approximate percentage of filler to be added to the polyester resin in order to have good adhesion properties and also in order to be able to lower the shrinkage during the cure .I think I will try the suggestions regarding the alignment of the fibres and about the use of the PU elastomer and see the changes in the final product .
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
Thanks for the stars. You asked about adding filler to decrease shrinkage and that may work but as I mentioned it's a balance because the glass fiber as well as reducing shrinkage, will actually hurt adhesion because it increases the modulus and therefore increases the force at the interface that tries to delaminate the bond.
Can you specify what overall properties you want? Does the polymer layer have to be transparent / translucent? What do you want from the polymer layer mechanically? Can you accept another material instead of polyester?
As a first guess I would suggest adding the soft component as you planned and perhaps replacing some percentage of the glass fiber with glass beads. The glass beads help reduce shrinake but without increasing the modulus nearly as much. (Potters is one supplier of glass beads)
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
Can you not just stick it on with silicon rubber adhesive?
This will give a flexible joint...
Rgds
Harry
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
The colour and appearance of the coating is not important in any way .I am ready to try out other material other than polyester but feel that this is the cheaper option compared to epoxy resin .
Demon3 can you please explain about the increase in the modulus in simpler terms ,I fail to follow you on that matter .
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
Sure, I can explain. There is a force at the interface of the resin and the glass. The force is caused by the shrinkage of the resin as it cures. The resin contracts and the glass doesn't and that builds a force that is trying to rip the resin off the glass. Can you picture that? The magnitude of that force depends on the amount the resin shrank by and the modulus of the resin. Imagine a spring, the force in a spring is the modulus (stiffness) of the spring multiplied by how much I compress the spring by. The interface is the same. That means there are three answers to your delamination problem.
1. Make the interfacial bonding so good that the delamination force I described is not enough to rip the resin off the glass (e.g. certain silanes could help)
2. Make the resin shrink less (e.g. fillers or choose a resin that does not shrink on cure like some cyclic monomers that ring open on cure)
3. Make the resin softer (e.g. add less filler, add a soft component or change from polyester to a soft resin like silicone)
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
Glad to have helped! It's actually even slightly more complicated that what I explained because the actual force at the interface is an integral. It's the modulus at a given time multiplied by the shrinkage, then as cure proceeds the modulus goes up and the shrinkage does too so you have to add that new modulus x shrinkage to the previous one and so on until cure is complete.
Regarding cyclic monomers they are available but not that common as far as I know. I have seen an aliphatic cylclic epoxy (yes I know epoxy groups themselves are cyclic before someone points it out). The cylcic monomers tend to expand on cure whereas most monomers give shrinkage. If you blend them correctly you can get a material that gives neither shrinkage nor expansion. I know some work has been done to make such materials for dental fillings.
I am pretty sure that using a softer adhesive for example will be a better solution for you than exotic adhesives with cyclic monomers.
Good luck on your quest and tell us how you do.
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
Regular glass sheet is a rigid material and very prone to cracking if overflexed.
For reasons unknown to us you need one side of the glass untouched but it is OK to clad the other side with just about anything cost effective that will help prevent the glass from over flexing.
The current method is an insitu lay up of a 2mm thick polyester fiberglass laminate to the glass sheet. However, due to high resin shrinkage, the bond creates bending stress causing the glass sheet to bend slightly towards the fiberglass. You can easily verify this. This pre-loading between the laminate of glass and fiberglass is causing an unacceptable number of breakages during subsequent handling.
To overcome the problem, a simple, effective solution would be to pre-cast or even buy in flat sheets of 2mm thick fibreglass and simply bond them directly to the glass sheet.
RE: are glass and polyester resin incompatible?
I posted two other messaged today and thought of updating you on the progress obtained as as result of the suggestions I got on this thread . By adding filler in the resin,by placing the fibres bidirectionally and by leaving some gaps in between the fibre groups I was able to solve the above said problem of the big sheet of glass bending and cracking.
A big thanks to all of you for all the suggestions you offered .