×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool
3

What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

(OP)
Hi,

I read in European papers about this guy Frank. The papers know that a combination of wool and synthetic fibers charged Frank "to the brink of self-ignition". Frank also produced sparks that could be seen outside the building and left marks in the carpet. Frank did not notice what was going on until he found a piece of burnt plastic in his car and wondered from where it came!

Is there anything in this story that is true? Or anywhere near the truth? All the normal ingredients were there - including a professor at a technical university and a fire brigade captain that measured 40 kV in Frank's jacket.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

Funny story, but I'm not sold on it's authenticity.

Quote:

Clewer, who after leaving the building discovered he had scorched a piece of plastic on the floor of his car, returned to seek help from the firefighters.

"We tested his clothes with a static electricity field metre and measured a current of 40,000 volts, which is one step shy of spontaneous combustion, where his clothes would have self-ignited," Barton said.

What would a "static electricity field metre" be, and why would a fire department have one? Some stories say 30kV, others say 40kV, and most say "shy of spontaneous combustion". What the heck does that mean? Combustion of what? I can cause combustion of some kinds of clothing with far less than 30kV! If by chance it is real, it appears to have been written by amateurs at best. I checked for it on Urban Legends and they have nothing yet, but time will tell. I submitted it to them for investigation.

By the way Gunnar, does this have any relation to your nickname?
http://urbanlegends.about.com/od/accidentsmishaps/a/skogsra.htm

"Our virtues and our failings are inseparable, like force and matter. When they separate, man is no more." Nikola Tesla
Read the Eng-Tips Site Policies at FAQ731-376  
Member, P3

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

(OP)
Half right,

The Skogs part is the same. It means Forest. Gurra is short the old viking name Gunnar. It all comes from me being the one that lives in the forest. The two other Gurra in our little department lived in the city. The were nicknamed N-Gurra and P-Gurra. What was left for me? 0-Gurra or I-Gurra. (We were working with power semiconductors and the PIN diodes were popular at that time.

The RA (RÅ, if you have the correct key-board) is a man's dream. She was mostly seen by lonely men watching their carbon piles in the deep forests. They did this for weeks and couldn't leave the pile. So they were thinking about women a lot. Working in the fumes from the carbon piles and never having enough sleep made them hallucinate. First thing they saw was what they wanted to see - a young and attractive woman (which I - I can assure you - am not).

We keep the tradition alive. Our little village community have just started a little carbon pile and there are two or three men from the village keeping watch over it. Day and night. Sometimes, the young women in the village dress like skogsra and visit the men.

This link (the fourth picture) http://www.karlskoga.se/granbergsdal/v%C3%A5ra_evenemang.html  shows a carbon pile (kolmila) in action. The second picture shows "cow bingo". We all have bet on which square the cow will leave her droppings. This year, she didn't.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

Wow..skogsgurra...  Most illuminating. [eye's wide open - head shaking]

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

2
Static electricity field meters are found in pretty much every single electronics lab where electronic components and boards are handled.  The field meters are used in conjunction with wrist straps and other measures to ensure that parts are not damaged by ESD

TTFN



RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

(OP)
Well, all that is good and interesting - but what happened to Frank? Any Aussie that did see this?

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

I agree with IRstuff.

Furthermore the author of the article quoted above doesn't know the difference between voltage and current and therefore qualifies as technically illiterate. The level of static present doesn’t tell you much about the energy present since the energy depends on the voltage (squared)and the capacitance.

Typically static on clothing would have plenty of ability to destroy small semiconducting devices but not to ignite the clothing!

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

What stikes as typical urban legend is the "synthetic clothing emergency protocol" cited in the Register version:
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/09/16/static_jacket/

The other hallmark of a hoax is the citation of a "scientist."  No one in a scientific field would self-identify as "scientist," since that removes any hint of possible qualification or authority for making any statements of fact or theory.

Finally, 30kV static discharge is hardly unusual; it's unusual for the average person, since it sounds like a large number, but 30 kV is quite typical for ESD protection test levels.

The bit about the clothing continuing to generate "voltage" is also quite amusing.  Has someone found a perpetual source?  Static charge generation requires movement of objects against each other.  For a pile of clothes to continue to generate charge is not possible.

This reference is quite long, but makes no mention of the mysterous "scientist."  Likewise, there's no mention of the perpetual charge generation.
http://the.standard.net.au/articles/2005/09/16/1126750111141.html

TTFN



RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

Sarah Scopelianos appears to be the original author of the original article.  She's apparently around 22-23, so may be somewhat forgiven for overdramatization.

Dennington is about 1 mi outside of Warrnambool, according to GoogleEarth.  Ms. Scopelianos is a reporter for the Warrnambool Standard.

What's really fascinating is that it's only 2 days after the original byline and the story has made it into:
http://www.aboutjobinterviews.com/

Of course, that freshness of the article suggests that it'll be a while before it gets debunked

TTFN



RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

(OP)
Mighty fine research, IR!

The link to "The Standard" leads to an amusing article. The last sentence: "He said Mr Clewer's clothes were at no stage dangerous because they were low in amps which could be deadly" is the jewel in the crown.

Why is it that good electric engineers are not consulted in cases like this? Are we that hard to find? MarkE; do you have any first-hand information? Yes, I know, NZ is a bit away, but you may be the nearest reliable (and sane) person down there.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

The Reuters article gives some more detail that was added to the original story:
http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20050916/od_nm/australia_electricity_dc

The bit about self-ignition is quite fascinating.

Gosden is apparently a real person at U of Sydney:
http://www.ee.usyd.edu.au/staff_eie.php?id=34

But note that his quote from the Reuters article is cleverly embellished in this article:
http://www.smh.com.au/news/national/a-cracker-of-a-day--but-whats-that-smell/2005/09/16/1126750129173.html?oneclick=true

Apparently, the news community is unaware of easy it is to generate 40 kV, unlike:
http://www.physics.udel.edu/~watson/phys208/vandegraf.html

TTFN



RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

Ok, I'm better than that.  here's the image from the last link:

TTFN



RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

(OP)
Sorry IR - you already got my PLS!

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

Can you tell that it's a slow news day for me as well?

TTFN



RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

Sounds like some Aussie illywhacker (Aussie term approximating to B***s****er) taking advantage of a passing tourist.  Much any local anywhere likes to do with passing tourists, I suppose!

Warnambool is a nice place, but it's a bit far out of town (let's start a war! ).

There are plenty designs out there on the internet for making a van der Graaf generator using old pantyhose and an aluminium can.  Not exactly rocket science.  Or take off your jumper on a dark night and watch the light show.

Bung
Life is non-linear...

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

Quote:

"We tested his clothes with a static electricity field metre and measured a current of 40,000 volts, which is one step shy of spontaneous combustion, where his clothes would have self-ignited," Barton said.

I dont know, what do you think a "Current of 40,000 VOLTS. what are you thinking.
This is so much BS. Please stop it now... I beg you.

pennpoint

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

I think that pales in comparison to the second part of the quote, e.g., "one step shy of spontaneous combustion."

Be afraid...

TTFN



RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

"Within about five minutes, the carpet started to erupt."

OK, what does "erupt" mean in this context, especially considering it took the carpet five minutes to do it?



"There were several scorch marks in the carpet, and we could hear a cracking noise -- a bit like a whip -- both inside and outside the building,"

They heard the noise OUTSIDE of the building?  What, were there sonic booms happening fro this "electricity"?!

Dan
Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

(OP)
Yes - it is a mystery.

I talked to one of the journalists that wrote about Frank and his jacket. She says that she got the story from Reuter's and since that is a big news agency, she thought that the story was true.

I think that it is about time to start SFPEDTP (Society For Prevention of Electric Disinformation to the Public). Every daily paper should have an EE attached who can guide the journalists. It will be a much better world where we do not have to read about 10 000 volt currents, energy savings equal to 10 terrawatts (find two faults) and be assured that it is essential to be well grounded when working with electric equipment.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

We have recently had 2 underground electrical substation explodions here in the San Francisco Bay Area. I have marveled at the variety of misinformation spewing from the TV journalists. The best one last night was that "the electrical surge blew a manhole cover up into the bottom of a car driving over it!" Another station reported that the surge caused the manhole to fly 30ft in the air and land on TOP of the car. They couldn't even get the trajectory of the manhole cover correct, so I wasn't going to waste my time correcting the electrical issue.

The other one was trajic in that a passing pedestiran was severely burned when a transformer vault under the sidewalk blew up, but they repeatedly reported that she was electrcuted, when in fact she was burned by the exploding oil.

"Our virtues and our failings are inseparable, like force and matter. When they separate, man is no more." Nikola Tesla
Read the Eng-Tips Site Policies at FAQ731-376  
Member, P3

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

Journalists are not necessarily at fault, since they obviously didn't spend 4 yrs in college engineering.  The so-called "experts" that they interview are the ones that are truly scary.  

Can you rely on a fire official that thinks 40 kV will cause spontaneous combustion?

TTFN



RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

(OP)
I think that it is possible to be fairly conversational in basic physics (to which elementary electricity belongs) without ever attending engineering school. Journalists also go to schools. Don't they?

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

Oh sure, but they take "Physics for Poets" in sophomore yr or thereabouts and that's a maybe.  Most liberal arts majors are not required to take any math or science.  Seems a bit unfair, since we engineers were required to take one class of liberal arts every quarter.

Given that a sizable number of Americans don't even know that New Mexico is part of the US, it's not at all surprising that a non-science reporter would have trouble separating the wheat from the chaff

TTFN



RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

(OP)
Yes, IR. You are probably right there. I think that we still have some physics (or "nature" as it is called) squeezed into the schools over here. My grandchildren show some kind of understanding for physics and mathematics and that makes me glad.

And, yes again, I think that engineers know more about non-engineering stuff than so-called classic educated people know about just anything. At least we seem to have a much better judgement when it comes to urban legends and other myths (I refrain from mentioning ID and what have you).

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

I don't begrudge reporters from not knowing everything about every subject, but for sure they should know who to ask! To ASS-U-Me that a fire chief is an electrical expert is ludicrous. All they need to know about electricity is "How do I turn it off before I open the hoses?"

When a reporter sees something that is an obvious electrical issue (or any other engineering discipline for that matter), they should go to a credentialled engineering source, such as a public university professor or City Engineer, for relevant comments. What they do instead is find the nearest crackpot with a ready opinion because that makes for a more sensational story, regardless of relevance or accuracy. Such is the sorry state of our "infotainment" industry.

"Our virtues and our failings are inseparable, like force and matter. When they separate, man is no more." Nikola Tesla
Read the Eng-Tips Site Policies at FAQ731-376  
Member, P3

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

Ah, but some other reporter did, and got that wonderful quote "It was unusual for static electricity to reach 40,000 volts.", although, it's not obvious who was the author.  That particular interviewee is a bonafide senior lecturer in EE.

TTFN



RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

skogs,

"...find two faults..."

No one else has bothered and I'm having a slack day:

1) Terrawatts - should be terawatts

2) Why is a unit of power being used to quantify energy savings? Should be joules or maybe terajoules.

There, I made myself happy!

----------------------------------

One day my ship will come in.
But with my luck, I'll be at the airport!

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

Scotty...

you missed the "10,000 volt currents"

TTFN



RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

(OP)
You read my intention correctly Scotty, the two faults were in the "energy savings equal to 10 terrawatts" part.

Of course, you are also right, IR. But that was part of the package and too obvious to be mentioned. Anyhow, I give you both a PLS. I hate seeing people being sorry.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org

RE: What happened to Frank Clewer in Warrnambool

Misspelled words in this type of forum is pretty common, so I ignored that.  Even in a print article, it's unclear who actually makes the mistake.

TTFN



Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources