×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Bearing oil sightglass venting question
7

Bearing oil sightglass venting question

Bearing oil sightglass venting question

(OP)
This is an indoor 4kv vertical motor manufactured by Westinghouse with oil-lubricated upper and lower bearings (picture below)
http://home.houston.rr.com/electricpete/VertMotor1.jpg

The lower bearing housing has a pipe that extends outward to the bottom of a sightglass chamber.  The sightglass chamber has a fill plug on top and a drain plug near the bottom (at the same elevation as the pipe to the bearing housing).   

The motor is identified with a static fill level.  

The sightglass chamber is not vented.  After adding oil when we screw the fill plug back in, we have noticed that the indicated oil level decreases, as if the screwing of the plug creates a positive pressure in the sightglass chamber which pushes down on the oil in the sightglass chamber and displaces into the bearing.

Questions:
Would you consider this behavior normal?
Is it safe to assume that the bearing itself breathes to atmosphere (even though the sightglass design obviously doesn’t).
Would it be a problem to drill a hole in the vent plug to eliminate this phenomenon?  If not, should we shoot to have the level at the static mark before or after screwing in the fill plug.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

(OP)
Another concern with the existing setup is that the bearing oil level in the sightglass may not represent bearing oil level in the bearing under conditions of heatup or cooldown or other changes which can create a slight pressure or vacuum in the air volume trapped above the oil in the sightglass.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

3
Hi electricpete.

I would think that is abnormal.  I have not heard of a sight glass EVER being vented.  BUT! I have always seen the tank that the sight glass depicts vented.   Partly this is to prevent exploding sight glasses and the loss of everything in the tank out the failed sight glass. (this is bad)  Picture a ruptured sight glass on an engine room fuel tank. (evil)

I would certainly believe the sight glass is not properly depicting the reservoir in your case.

Now your case is strange in that you have a single sight glass connection.  It MUST be vented in this case or you have a barrometer/thermometer NOT a level guage.

If this thing isn't a complete bungle, another words you can remove the cap while the unit is running and not have it void everything due to pressure/horrible-design aspects then I would certainly drill out a small hole in the cap.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

pete,

You can drill a hole on the plug to vent the air. I suggest a fine-size metal filter over the vent hole to prevent ambient dust/debris getting inside the oil.

How did you the upload this picture ?

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

(OP)
"I have not heard of a sight glass EVER being vented"

I always see one of two setups:
A - The sightglass is vented to atmosphere at the top.
B - The sightglass top is vented back to the bearing cavity at the top.

B is a little better since vacuum or positive pressure at the bearing doesn't affect level indiction.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

I meant directly vented... I don't consider hooking back into the tank "vented".

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

You did not state what size the plug is, but someone out there makes a pipe plug with a sintered metal core that 'breathes' which would allow your barometric leg in order to indicate true level.

Short of that, you should put a goose neck on top of the gage to prevent dust, etc. from entering the sight glass.

It may have been the mfg'r's intention that the resorvoir would be filled using the open sight glass, and then checked periodically by removing the plug.  That is to say that the sight glass is only for verifying the initial charge of the oil, not continual monitering.

Many oil resorvoirs have only a pipe plug that has to be removed to check the level, as you know.

rmw

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

(OP)
rmw - for electric motor bearing oil reservoirs I have always seen a live level indication (an exception may be motor/pump supplied by large 100+gallon sump with oil pumps - but that has oil pressure alarms).

edison - you can get a free website to post your pictures etc (up to 25MB) at www.tripod.com

It is surprisingly easy.  You can upload files through your internet explorer using ftp.  I just put the file here in about 30 seconds:
http://electricpete1.tripod.com/VertMotor1.jpg

If you give it a try and have any difficulties - let me know - I'd be glad to help.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

(OP)
Hmmm.  It looks like tripod has some restrictions on hot-linking (directly to files).

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

Thx pete. I will try it out, I had always wanted to post some pics on eng-tips.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

(OP)
Ok, it takes a little more work on tripod. You need to create an html file to link your picture so they can get their advertising in to pay for the free service.

Using notepad or word (with word save as type txt or html), create a file  VertMotor1.html with the following contents
<html>

<head>
<title>kumar's link page</title>
</head>

<body>
<p><a href="VertMotor1.jpg">VertMotor1.jpg</a></p>
</body>

</html>

Save that file as VertMotor1.html (text or html format).
Then upload that file to tripod as well.  The result is here:
http://electricpete1.tripod.com/VertMotor1.htm

The website I originally used is provided by my internet service provider which is roadrunner.  They give a free website which doesn't have these restrictions like tripod.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

(OP)
Tripod probably has some tools that make it a little easier to create the html page but I haven't tried them.

A discussion of free websites is here
http://www.freewebspace.net/forums/showthread.php?t=26552

I would avoid the ones identified with an asterisk (*) since they don't have ftp.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

electricpete, edison123;


There is NO easier site for picture hosting then:

http://www.tinypic.com/

No registering, no passwords, no pages to work thru, nada!  Not even a home page!  Just hit the url above. Hit browse. Select your picture. You are done.  It then spits out all possible routes and hot links.  Pick the one you want. Paste into here.

Done.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

(OP)
Let's see if we can get the motor....
http://tinypic.com/dlm03o.jpg

How long does it stay there?

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

(OP)
It worked.  I guess I'll check back in a week to see if it's still there.  Most things I post are only of interest for a week or so.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

electricpete; I presume at least a month probably a year.

That graph in thread248-133430 is on "tinypic".

Don't make the mistake of tinypic"s"

Demo: Bad day at the office...




RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

Thx itsmoked. tinypic was easy and simple.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

I don't find any reason to think that screwing the plug creates the positive pressure and pushing the oil level down. The depth of the plug can't create that pressur to push down the oil level. Further, breathers(or vents) are provided to push out hot vapor. One possibility may be that entrapped air slowly coming up.

What is another level indicator shown on top?

Most of the fill caps come with an annular empty space to breath out the air and vapors. Is there any chance that the original plug was replaced?

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

I apologize for the long winded answer and the repeating of your original questions but felt it was the best way to respond and not forcing everybody to have to scroll up and down.

“This is an indoor 4kv vertical motor manufactured by Westinghouse with oil-lubricated upper and lower bearings “

yes, it looks like one of their 5000, 5800 or 6800 frame size drip proof machines. Is it a 4 pole?
Have you been having any problems with oil leaks [the reason for the questions will be seen later in this post]

“The motor is identified with a static fill level.”

It should also have a scribe line for running level. They would put is mark on the glass when the motor was tested. Perhaps with such an old machine, someone has been working on it and replaced some parts.

“The sightglass chamber is not vented.”

Well, this is proof that the original parts on this machine have been replaced with non-Westinghouse parts. I assure you that when that motor shipped from the Westinghouse factory in Buffalo NY, it had a vented plug in the top of the sight gage.

“After adding oil when we screw the fill plug back in, we have noticed that the indicated oil level decreases, as if the screwing of the plug creates a positive pressure in the sightglass chamber which pushes down on the oil in the sightglass chamber and displaces into the bearing.”

Are you adding oil while the motor is running or static? The photo shows what looks like is the proper oil level [in both top and bottom gages BTW] for static conditions. Proper static level is near the bottom of the gage.

“Questions:
Would you consider this behavior normal?
Is it safe to assume that the bearing itself breathes to atmosphere (even though the sightglass design obviously doesn’t).”

The sightglass should be vented to atmosphere just like the pressure above the oil level is atmosphere inside the oil pot. The bearing itself will breathes atmosphere via the shaft seal clearance.

“Would it be a problem to drill a hole in the vent plug to eliminate this phenomenon? If not, should we shoot to have the level at the static mark before or after screwing in the fill plug. “

This whole design will not work properly without ALL the parts being original with a vented top plug and the bottom of the sight glass should be attached to the bottom-side of the oil pot via a hose. This arrangement means that the level shown in the glass is the oil level on the side of the oil pot, not the level of the oil inside the bearing when the motor is running.
So yes, drill two holes at right angles to each other in the cap. The size of the hole depends on the size of the machine but would be either 1/8 or 1/16 inches in diameter.
Then there should be a “metering plate” resting inside the oil pot just below the bearing. Also, there should be a flinger attached to the shaft just above the inboard seal.

You might want to contact service@tecowestinghouse.com for more assistance.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

(OP)
Thanks motorman

”yes, it looks like one of their 5000, 5800 or 6800 frame size drip proof machines. Is it a 4 pole?”

Yes, it is a 5800 series frame (5810-P39).  Lifeline D, Type “LAC”, Model VSW6, 2-pole,  Westinghouse Outline Drawing 8976D94, nuclear safety-related.   Westinghouse shop order 76F52942,3,4.  There is also a designation on some paperwork  “G.O. LA18823-L7”  

”Have you been having any problems with oil leaks”
No.

”It should also have a scribe line for running level. They would put is mark on the glass when the motor was tested. Perhaps with such an old machine, someone has been working on it and replaced some parts.”
There is a metal plate permanently affixed to the motor to identify static level. Nothing to identify running level. We have discussed running level with Westinghouse before and they told us there is no identification of running level but it should be within approx ¼” of static level mark.

“[The sightglass chamber is not vented.] - Well, this is proof that the original parts on this machine have been replaced with non-Westinghouse parts. I assure you that when that motor shipped from the Westinghouse factory in Buffalo NY, it had a vented plug in the top of the sight gage.”

I don’t know where it was manufactured.   Do you know if all Westinghouse does it the same.

”Are you adding oil while the motor is running or static?”
Static.

I will try to keep an open mind to investigate the possibility that this motor may be different than it’s sisters or different than the original OEM configuration, but it doesn’t look that way to me at this point in time.  Also have not got any clarifcation from the vendor yet.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

(OP)
After motorman's post I took a close look and did see 2 of the other units have vent ports in the plug.  Based on discussion with W we will ensure that all have vent ports drilled in the plug.

Now another question - there is another group of motors also Westinghouse Lifeline D verticals slightly smaller (frame 5000 series).

One has high directional vibration up to 0.6 ips at top of the motor which we have attributed to resonance at running speed (confirmed by bump test).  The condition has existed for several years (the motor operates only standby/intermittent use).  Recently we have seen some oil droplets spread around below the motor (coupling area).   We don't see this on any of the other motors. What could be the cause of this?

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

Conjecture:

- Clogged/blocked sightglass vent and clogged/blocked bearing chamber vent.

- Aging/ stiff/ seal lip no longer compensating for normal shaft runout.

- Aging/ worn seal lip no longer maintaining normal contact with shaft.

- Incipient seal failure associated with in-progress bearing failure.  Droplets in combination with the vibration are somewhat suggestive of a bearing that's been chewing on its separator for a long time.  

I'd tear it down and replace the bearings and seals just for fun.

 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

The Westinghouse 5000, 5800 and 6800 frame series vertical motors used non-contact, labyrinth shaft seals. So there is no seal lip to wear out and no chamber vent to get clogged.

If you only notice the drips after the machine has just been shut down from a run but not when the machine has been idle then I would concentrate only looking for sources that are above the static oil level. While running, the bearings whip up quite an oil mist in the oil pot [sump]. This then can cause nuisance dripping because the mist will seep around the o-ring where the shaft seal is bolted on or it can and does seep around the bolt heads that hold the seal on. Check the o-ring gasket and make sure that a sealant such as Duxseal has been used under the heads of the seal bolts.

If the drips occur independent of the machine running then concentrate on areas that are below the static oil level. Such as a hole in the rubber hose going to the sight glass; leaking around the fittings. The oil pot [or sump] on those machines are a casting. Hairline cracks could be developing especially where the standpipe is press-fit into the cast oil pot.

A neat way to trace oil leaks is to darken the area as much as practical and look around using a fluorescent trouble light except with a black light tube. The oil path will really show up. Or, if you prefer periodic checks, spray some developer [I think that’s what it is called] like the white colored stuff that is used for dye penetrate testing welds, all around the most likely joints and surfaces. The oil will turn this white into a blood red.

RE: Bearing oil sightglass venting question

Thanks, motorman, for the education about the seals.

I'm still suspicious of the bearings.

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources