×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Research or industry job ?

Research or industry job ?

Research or industry job ?

(OP)
Hi all,
       I am basically mech engineer. At present am bit confusion for choosing my permanent job. Here are my exp's. I finished my bachelor in eng 99' after that i had worked as a cnc programmer for one yr. After that i had 1.5 yrs exp as a CAD programmer in well known firm. Then next 2.5 yrs studied Masters. At the same 2.5 yrs(part-time) i worked as a student worker in mech engg. so far 5 yrs over after my bachelor. After that i am working as a research assistant in mech engg since 1 yr. But i am very much interesting to work in industries rather research. I really confused myself whether to continue this research in another 3 yrs or start to search job in industry. Presently i am 29 yrs old.
I hope some of u can suggest me, the better ideas or alternate way to make better in my career.

thanks and regards,
lm

PS. I did several stress analysis in mechanical transmission elements and also had couple of yrs exp's in mech appl. programming.

RE: Research or industry job ?

If you want to work in industry, look now.  Doing an additional 3 year stint in research will solidify someones initial impression of you as a research oriented individual.  The Master's degree also serves as a pointer (from a first impression) that you are more of a research oriented individual.  Hence the need to jump now if able.

Regards,

RE: Research or industry job ?

"Hence the need to jump now if able".... what's the problem with research? If you really like to use your intellectual capabilities to the max throughout your career, stay in research.
If you like oil stains in your shirt, operators massacring your beautiful design, sales guys putting you under impossible time prssure, unreasonable customers and unreliable suppliers, move to the industry.

It's all a matter of taste and you have to decide for yourself what you like.

RE: Research or industry job ?

(OP)
Entering in real industry job at the age of 29 with masters or 32 with Phd which will be better ?. Bcs now a days industry looks staff <30 am i right ?.

RE: Research or industry job ?

PhD in industry is often worthless at best, sometimes even a handicap

RE: Research or industry job ?

epoisses,

A little condescending attitude towards industry?  I have worked in several different areas within engineering, including design, maintenance and long range planning.  I find the time contraints/pressures and the "on your feet" decision making necessary in O&M very intellectually challenging.  In my opinion, the best engineering designs come from those that understand the challenges with construction and maintenance.  I have seen some pretty horrible designs come out of people that thought they were intellectually superior to us in the field.

RE: Research or industry job ?

I have had the fortune of working with some Ph.D.'s who were darn useful people to have around.  These were/are people with depp knowledge of their fields of study and the desire and ability to put that knowledge to good and profitable use.

There is definitely a place for Ph.D.'s in industry.  The greatest difficulty to overcome might be your academic overqualification.  When interviewing, you have to make it very clear that you desire a certain career path.  Otherwise, expectations of what others think you should be doing could cloud the issue.

If there's a place you want to be, pick the path that gets you there.

I could be the world's greatest underachiever, if I could just learn to apply myself.
http://www.EsoxRepublic.com-SolidWorks API VB programming help

RE: Research or industry job ?

The research and industry are two different environment. In research world, you are free and flexible in time and do the job whenever you like. In industry, you need to work on-time and at least 8 hr per day. Even you earn your PhD at 32, it is still young enough. I always think after you have been working for many years, you don't want to go back school. Try learn and be stuff when you are young.

RE: Research or industry job ?

Quote:


In research world, you are free and flexible in time and do the job whenever you like

I think I choosed the wrong path, no headache, no stress, no bosses, no pay-check to worry about, or am I missing something?...

RE: Research or industry job ?

toiap,
Not at all, I work in the industry myself, but I thought it would be good to defend research a bit, for a change.

RE: Research or industry job ?

Thank you TheTick. That is one of the most sensible sentiments I have heard in a long time.

I would add that the specialist knowledge gained in doing a PhD is not what will make you more employable. Rather it is the fact that, by definition, you are an analyst and a problem solver who knows how to learn in self-directed manner. The PhD is a badge which says that "I am a professional resarcher" in much the same way that a PE/CEng says "I am a professional engineer". It does not just mean that "I am an expert in Sound and Vibration in Aircraft Structures Using Statistical Energy Analysis" (in my case).

As for the accusation that PhDs have their heads in the clouds and no knowledge of real-world engineering, well that may be true for some, but equally, as there are bad engineers with PhDs, there are also plenty of bad engineers without PhDs too.

PhDs are people too! Don't judge them by a title.

Remember also that there are engineering research jobs available outisde academia (I know, because I'm looking for one at the age of 32 and after 3 years as a student researcher and 7 years as a professional researcher). In fact there are more and more what you might call "Engineering research consultants" appearing, certainly in the UK. The decline of engineering in the UK in recent decades has coincided with the rise of the management consultant (I'll leave you to judge if the relationship is a causal one). Engineering company R&D departments were the first to fall under the management consultants' axes ("Tarquin, what is this division here? R&D? What's that? They seem to take awful lot of money and have generated next to no cash in the last year. Let's cut them loose first.")

This short-termist short-sightedness means that the those companies that have survived have suddenly realised that they needed an R&D department after all to compete in the global market but they don't have the capital available to create one. As a result they must instead pay a premium for the R&D consultants to do it on their behalf.

M

--
Dr Michael F Platten

RE: Research or industry job ?

When money is tight and the axe must fall, the Research Division is usuallly one of the first that they put on the chopping block. As far as the company is concerned, Research is simply overhead that can be eliminated when times are tough. I have seen this happen at my present company, and it was ugly.


Maui

Constants aren't; variables won't.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources