×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

stating salary requirements
2

stating salary requirements

stating salary requirements

(OP)
Today’s classified ads feature a listing for an engineer (unspecified with 3 years experience in manufacturing).  The bottom of the ad reads “Resumes without salary requirements will not be considered.”

What do you make of that?

RE: stating salary requirements

Looks like that company got a budget set a side for a certain salary scale and will see which engineer fits there parameters and discard the rest.

RE: stating salary requirements

I know what they'll end up with. On the other hand, it would have saved me a fair few hours a few years back. There was no way the company involved was prepared to pay me what I'd expected, so I wouldn't have bothered with the interviewing process.

Cheers

Greg Locock

Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.

RE: stating salary requirements

LOL...

Been there...Interviewed with IBM and they offered me a job, but didn't show what the salary offer was, so I called them up.  

Even then, they still wouldn't tell me, but asked what my other offers were.  "oh...," they said, "well, we weren't going to offer you anywhere near THAT much."

TTFN



RE: stating salary requirements

Another one like this is "send salary history."  It's a sign that the salary is going to be on the low side and the company knows it.  They don't want to waste time with people who want too much money.

Regards,
-Mike

RE: stating salary requirements

I was once once in the interview process for a job that had the salary for the position posted in the classified ad that I responded to. Once they were interested in me they started asking for salary history and I refused. They couldn't believe that I wouldn't tell them what I was making at the time. I told them thanks but no thanks and moved along. In hindsight, it was the best decision I could have made at the time.

RE: stating salary requirements

I would have no concern telling a prospective employer either what I make or what I want.  You cannot expect to get what you want unless you tell them.  If you tell them what you make be truthfull.  They may want to make an offer based upon what you make.  You will accept the offer based upon what you want or perhaps what you need.

John

RE: stating salary requirements

I agree with Roadbridge that the company is trying to filter out the candidates wanting salaries outside its range.  Good people can be "missed" using this technique.

Companies usually have a set budget and a range of salaries for each open positions.  More often than not, revealing the current salary can limit the salary negotiation process for the candidate.  In many cases, companies will offer salary beyond a few raise cycles from your current rate, and it WORKS!

RE: stating salary requirements

I've been working for a very low salary, based on hopes of better times, and a promise of deferred compensation, sealed by a handshake.  

(The IRS makes it very disadvantageous to have an actual contract.)

Better times came, but not better enough, I guess.  The job evaporated, and so did the promise and the deferred money.

If I tell 'em what I was making, they'll try to match that pitiful sum.  If I tell 'em the boss reneged on a promise, they'll think I've got a bad attitude.

I detest this whole salary negotiation game.

 
  



Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: stating salary requirements

Asking for salary history is equivalent to forcing you to make the first offer in the negotiation, and an involuntary offer, at that.

TTFN



RE: stating salary requirements

I would answer the ad, and give a very liberal range.  That will get you in the door.

The original post stated "salary requirements", not "salary history".

I would not provide a salary history during negotiations, and can't ever remember being asked.

I have always been asked what my salary requirements are, and I can't imagine not answering any direct, legal question in a job interview.

Its just like asking a current employer for a raise...the first question is always, and has to be, "how much do you want?"  I can't imagine refusing to answer, but I can well imagine where the negotiations would end up if I didn't have an answer.

Remember: The Chinese ideogram for “crisis” is comprised of the characters for “danger” and “opportunity.”
-Steve

RE: stating salary requirements

Asking for salary requirements in the initial contact for a job is simply a way for a company to filter out applicants they don't want.  The salary history request is a little more subtle but serves the same purpose.  Some companies don't pay the going rate, but that's just the way things are.  My point is that the "salary requirements" or "salary history" thing is a sign the position being advertised will most often pay on the low side, but this is just my opinion.  

-Mike

RE: stating salary requirements

It's to your advantage to make them give the first number.  If you give the first number (whether it's your current salary or your desired salary) you can short change yourself.  If they ask your salary requirements simply say that you expect they will make you an offer commensurate with your experience and accoring to the local market - make them do the research.  But you should have a desired salary range in mind and if they make an offer in this range, then you should accept.  

RE: stating salary requirements

I don't see how my salary history has any bearing on my salary negotiations with a prospective employer. Let's say that I'm a really really great engineer (which I am - I'm also not too modest either - haha). But let's say that due to some circumstances, I had to take an engineering job that paid below what I felt my level of experience should be paid. I then interview for another job and they want to know what I'm making now. No way am I telling them. I have no problem giving them a number that I think I should be paid, but not until they throw one out first. So they can do one of two things - either don't offer the job or offer the job with a salary that they feel is inline with my experience. Then I can do one of three things if they offer the job. Decline, Accept, or Present a Counteroffer. If at any point I feel that I'm getting jerked around, I will end the interview/negotiation right then and there.

RE: stating salary requirements

So what is the answer when you're sitting in front of the interviewer, and he says "what is your compensation at your current position?"  -"We'll discuss salary if I'm offered the position" only defers the point in time when you answer.

RE: stating salary requirements

Well, if you've gotten to the point where you don't really give a damn if they offer a job or not, the correct answer is,

"That's relevant only if you're proposing to pay me to do that other job, the one that I used to do.  

What we're discussing here and now is what you'll pay me to do the job that _you_ need done.  

Since you already budgeted the money for it, just put the highest amount you anticipated in an offer letter, and I'll get back to you."

;---

If you do give them a number, use the real one.  If you were accepting a low salary because your kids were in school, or the climate was nice, etc., so state.

;---

Okay, I've already tried every possible tactic except flat out lying.  My experience says that an outfit you'd want to work for won't screw you over ... and conversely.

My experience also says that the outfits you'd want to work for are rarely hiring.


Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: stating salary requirements

Last interview I told them that I preferred not to disclose it at that time and that I was confident they would make a reasonable offer based on my experience and the job location.  I got an offer on the high end of my desired range, so I accepted with no further negotiation required.  

If you don't like their offer and you want to negotiate, then you can bring up what your current salary is if it helps your cause.  

RE: stating salary requirements

When it comes the to question, "what are you being paid now?" I've replied with:

I'm making $XX,XXX. Now, I read the salary surveys in the engineering trade journals, so I know that I'm in the high/average/low/whatever range."

The next question usually is "what are you looking for?"

Answer: "I'm looking for at least a $10,000 increase."

Note: this is being honest. If they're going to hire you away from a good job -one that you like- they're going to have to pay more. Plus, you've just let the interviewer know what you think you're worth.

Also, if you are desparately looking for a job, that's the time to use the old "I'll discuss salary when the time is right" line. But when you're in a position and the other company "wants you" you're in the driver's seat. Go ahead, tell 'em what you make and tell 'em what you want!

RE: stating salary requirements

vooter,

What if before they interviewed you they set a budget for the position that was $15k to $25k higher than $XX,XXX?  You've just screwed yourself out of some money they were prepared to pay.  And maybe you've just let the interviewer know that you don't think you're worth much.

RE: stating salary requirements

I found it advantageous to not reveal the current salary nor the desired salary.  Allow the firm to determine a price based on the resume (which they obviously approved) and the interview.  This drives them nuts.

I've been on both sides of the desk and use it to my advantage as much as possible.  Important thing is, never short-change a good candidate because when they find out, they are out the door.

RE: stating salary requirements

(OP)
What I do not understand is what is so relevant about my current salary?  Obviously the prospective employer is looking for a baseline from which to begin negotiations.  Well I wouldn’t be considering changing employers if my current employer rewarded my talents to my satisfaction.  I mean who changes employers to do the same work for the same pay?  As Mr. Halloran pointed out, my current salary is relevant only if the prospective employer is proposing to pay me to do my current job.  If the prospective employer needs a baseline from which to begin salary negotiations let him look at the market, his budget, his work load, and my resume and go from there.  

Am I way off base with this thought process?

RE: stating salary requirements

I think the way companies set salary levels is less scientific than most people think.  They want to know what you make and then offer you that and a percentage more, the percentages depending on factors like the economy, demand, and so on.  The job candidate and the company are seldom thinking of the same number to start with so it is probably best if salaries are discussed later rather than sooner, when it's established that a good match between the candidate and position is possible.

Getting back to the original post, an advertised position that asks for your current salary is letting you know that the salary offer will be low regardless of experience or qualifications.  There won't be much negotiating of salaries involved.

RE: stating salary requirements

(OP)
This company posts its salary ranges on its web site.  I don't think I have ever seen this on any other web site.  Interesting.

http://www.gallet.com/salary.htm

RE: stating salary requirements

Salary is NOT the noly measure of job satisfaction.  

What if your commute suddenly increased by 30 minutes or your spouse's job changed and now you have to do something different?  What if you got reassigned to a toad?

TTFN



RE: stating salary requirements

djv: "What if before they interviewed you they set a budget for the position that was $15k to $25k higher than $XX,XXX?  You've just screwed yourself out of some money they were prepared to pay.  And maybe you've just let the interviewer know that you don't think you're worth much."

Good point. But...

If you're doing an in-person interview, you're already somewhat in the door. AND, if the position is similar to your current job, then you know what they'll pay. If the position is an obvious promotion, do the research and ask for what the salary surveys say is the right money for that job. If you really are what the company wants, they'll pay.

For example, if you're a senior civil at firm A, how much more is firm B going to pay for the same job? Sure, there may be different perqs, different location, different type projects, etc., but it's still the "same" thing you're doing now. Why go through the headache of changing jobs for the same money?

Another example. You're a senior civil with 15 years' experience in design. Time to move into design management (and, yep, "business development"). That's a lot more responsibility. The salary survey says you should be making $110k. Right now you're making $85k. The interviewer asks what you want. Tell 'em "at least $25k more." If they say they are only prepared to give you $20k more, you've won the negotiation because they've let you see their hand. If they say that's too much, consider yourself in negotiations and go with it.

Considering that companies pay recruiters a lot of money just to find people, they're certainly going to pay a premium for your services - if you are what they think they want.

RE: stating salary requirements

vooter,

Of course you need to do the research and know what you are worth and what you want and you can probably expect that if they do their research their numbers will fall in line with yours, but I still say make them give the first number - you may end up pleasantly suprised.  

You say you've won the negotiation when you've seen their hand, but guess what?  It was after you'd shown them yours.  Maybe their standard is to drop 5k off your request and see if you bite.

Also, what if you say "I want 25k more" and the interviewer says "ok, no problem" without batting an eye.  Won't you wonder if you could've got $30k more?  

Anyway, we could give a bunch of scenarios.  As long as you're happy with the salary in the end, that's what matters.

RE: stating salary requirements

This reminds of a trip to Cabo I took once.  We went to the beach and there were these vendors selling blankets.  I asked how much and one replied, "$20," and I returned with "$10," and closed the deal.  

My friend laughed and said, "You're a crappy negotiator and could have gotten a much better price."

So, he accosts another vendor and enters into negotiations.  20 minutes later, he returned with a $10 blanket.

If you're willing to work for what they offer, then all is good.  Anything else is buyer's remorse and whining.

TTFN



RE: stating salary requirements

A lot also depends on who's more desperate - you to get the job or they to get somebody like you on board.

HVAC68

RE: stating salary requirements

On job applications, I almost always write in N/A for salary history, especially if prior to an interview.  I had one company call me on it, asking me why I did not fill it in. I told them I didn't think my salary history should have any bearing on the upcoming interview.  They told me they considered salary history to  be a good gauge of employee worth, and that they assume my current company was fair and equitable with salaries and salary increases.  I told them such assumptions were off.  Still today, I leave my salary history off the applications, unless of course I already received an offer.  It's an indication to me that they are not willing to take a much of a chance on a new hire, that they are not willing to do their own personnel screening based on resumes and experience, and that they will be penny pinching me every year I work there, despite the company size.

ChemE, M.E. EIT
"The only constant in life is change." -Bruce Lee

RE: stating salary requirements

Like many other negotiations, the best way of getting what you want is knowing what the other side can offer you.  Going into interviews I always know what the statistics are for similar jobs in the area.  If they ask my what I want, I give them the figure for the upper decile.  My position is that they want someone in the top ten percent of their peers, so they should be prepared to pay for that.  If they can’t afford that, then tell me that and give me an offer, which I will consider relative to the other factors that affect my job satisfaction.  

As for salary history, I have rarely been asked for it, but when I have, I provided it.  The interesting part of it was that I took a pay cut (relatively large) at one point because I liked the other factors affecting job choice.  This has created some good conversation during interviews.

Dave

RE: stating salary requirements

I had a boss who told me, just before he left (which I didn't know at the time), that I was worth whatever I thought I was worth.  Obviously, some people have ridiculous expectations, but if you have realistic expectations, especially in certain markets, you can do very well.  I am now considering a few different jobs, all of which offer a significant raise.  My former boss, as well as others, have offered (informally) salaries well in excess of my current salary.  I didn't even have to ask.  If you do your job well, i.e. show up and just work, you will do very well in the current climate (at least where I am).  We all have to work to live, but good workers can write their own ticket (within reason).  I'm not worried about a couple thousand a year here or there, the people you work with and their attitudes are vastly more important.  You spend 40 (really 50) hours of your life at work.  The people are the most important factor, because markets always find an equiliibrium and you will get a similar offer everywhere.  If you are unhappy at your job, at least in civil, it's your fault.  Everyone naturally thinks they're worth more than they're getting paid, which may or may not be true, but who cares.  They pay me to go out to job sites and say Yup or Nope.  No worries, holler at contractors, kiss their @$$e$, the job gets done and I get to go home and drink.  This is a great time for an engineer to be alive.  I hear horror stories about the early 80's and just thank god I'm living now, where I have ten jobs I can get and will excel at all of them by showing up, working when I'm there, and being honest.  Not a bad gig.

RE: stating salary requirements

My mother's going through a job search right now, and for some jobs the only way to apply is online, and there's the mandatory form with all the basic info, including salary range.  It's an awful thing--she's flexible, so she's afraid of pricing herself out of consideration for certain jobs by picking a higher range, or screwing herself out of money (or indicating that she's not of an appropriate level for the higher-paid jobs) by picking a lower range.

I think the whole thing is crap.  Decide you want to hire the person, make them an offer, and if it's too low either there will be a negotiation or they'll decline.  Forcing the applicant to play the game of guessing what you had in mind is just plain cruel and unnecessary.

Hg

Eng-Tips guidelines:  FAQ731-376

RE: stating salary requirements

Remember people value something based on what they pay for it.

I doubled my fees and quickly doubled my billable hours for a 400% increase in income.

A friend of mine tried running a computer repair business from his home. His fees were 30% of the downtown firms (one of which hired him after he gave up his own business). I tried to get him to charge the going rate in town but he never had enough confidence in himself to ask that much and went out of business. The downtown firm where he ended up had no problem hiring him out at the going rate, sometimes to clients who passed over him at the 30% rate.


Initially ask in the high end of the going rate, negotiate downwards only if offered something in return, OK $2,000 less but I get a company car.

This works best if you have a job you like and could stay in for a while.

In any negotiation always know your and the oppositions best alternative to a negotiated solution. Yours is continuing as you are in your present position (or lack of a position if unemployed) theirs is the other candidate. Think through the implications for both sides.

Rick Kitson MBA P.Eng

Construction Project Management
From conception to completion
www.kitsonengineering.com

RE: stating salary requirements

The original post stated -"Resumes without salary requirements will not be considered". If you are interested in the job, the best bet is to send your Resume WITH SALARY REQUIREMENT.

It does not strike me as a problem. Whenever I've changed jobs there has been a modest increase in salary which has suited me. Most companies advertising a position have an idea of the salary they will pay. If you are seeking a similar job it stands to reason that the salary will also be similar. If you are looking to step up then you would expect a significant increase in salary but would also be best positioned by identifying that you know it is a step up.

When I've been in the position of interviewing candidates, I always look for genuine (or at least plausible) reasons why they want the job. Having the matter of salary already covered, or at least sidelined, should allow the employer to concentrate on your qualities as a person and engineer!

RE: stating salary requirements

I guess it's quite reasonable for a company to ask a salary history, after all they need to know whether they can probably offer you what they want or not.

It is.... let's say... intelligent for a company to ask for salary REQUIREMENTS. They force you to make the first move, which is disadvantageous. (That's also why antique and high-end jewelry and clothes are never price tagged in the shopping window).

Black on white or in a mandatory on-line form you just don't have much choice. You then have two options: either find an alternative way to apply for the job, or make sure you are not bound by your requirement initially stated by making sure it is a large range OR stating that it is conditional, depending on exact job content or whatever else you think it depends on.

Just think aloud about what would really determine if you'd be happy with a salary proposal of XXk$, and just mention those very same reasons to the interviewer. No need to make it more complicated then that.

The number that you finally land on depends on your negotiation skills. This is a mixture of talent and experience. The fundamental thing to know is that you need a good argument for wanting a higher number. When I got this job I had given them my salary history but during the negotiations I mentioned I was supposed to get an X% raise the next year in my previous job (which was true). We landed on 1/2X% higher. Always keep such things in your pocket to use them at the right moment.
 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources