×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

How's this for respect?
7

How's this for respect?

How's this for respect?

(OP)
I've read many of the posts about respect, image, etc of the enginering profession. I've just heard a couple of ads that touch on this.

There's a LASIK surgeon in the SF Bay Area who advertises on the radio. They start in his qualifications, "Harvard MD and degreed electrical engineer"

Wow, a doctor considers it a marketing plus to point out he's got an EE degree as an undergrad. Perhaps it's not so dismal as some people think.

--------------------
Bring back the HP-15
www.hp15c.org
--------------------

RE: How's this for respect?

Quote:

Advertising
Be cautious about "slick" advertising and/or deals that sound "too good to be true." Remember, they usually are. There is a lot of competition resulting in a great deal of advertising and bidding for your business. Do your homework.

If you want to know more about advertising ethics, do's and don'ts, or want to report on false advertising, explore the following websites:

    * http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/menu-ads.htm
    * http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/menu-health.htm
This was from the LASIK laser eye surgery page of:
http://www.fda.gov/cdrh/LASIK/risks.htm

Now I have to say that this guy needs professional help with his marketing. To me it speaks a bit of desperation. If he wants me to let him use a laser on my eyes he'd better have and equivalent level of expertise in electrical engineering. As joe public that means a PhD to go with the MD. Degree means student. Students think they know everything but don't.

Besides, why does he need to be a "degreed electrical engineer"; is there something that can go wrong with these lasers? am I going to be stuck their on the couch like James Bond (Connery version) while he fumbles around trying to switch it off? ("No Mr Bond, I expect you to die.")

Of course, for engineers to hear engineering mentioned in the same breath as MD might seem like a good idea but ask yourselves, which profession attracts the more malpractise suits?

JMW
www.ViscoAnalyser.com

RE: How's this for respect?

Where's all the "OMG he can't call himself an Engineer without a PE!!!!!" crowd

RE: How's this for respect?

Whats the persons name? I'll be happy to report him/her for publically refering to themself as an engineer.

Sorry GT startup, unless you have a PE I have no way of knowing what you are. You could be the smartest person in the world or the biggest con artist. But there's no way that you can con the state into granting you a license. Exactly why engineering licensure exists.

RE: How's this for respect?

...and that attitude is exactly why it isn't growing.

Cheers

Greg Locock

Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.

RE: How's this for respect?

Eddyc, if you feel the need to report every person who refers to himself as an engineer without a PE I can at least point you in the right direction.  There's this body existing that has the gall to call itself an "institute" of "engineers" and guess what, some of the members are not licensed. I think they go by the acronym IEEE. When you are done with that group, try the Corps of Engineers.  

Beggar, do Eddyc a favor and name the doctor to which you refer. Apparently he would be happy to waste his time and report him. Fortunately he is a Lasik surgeon and maybe they can work out a compromise that would improve his short sightedness.

RE: How's this for respect?

Frankly, I think an MD with an engineering degree is damned awesome. It makes a lot of sense, too. I had a pal in undergrad who was a mechanical but had his eyes set on being an MD who made the perfect prostheses.

If the person is practicing as a medical doctor, let him be. He's not advertising engineering services nor is he calling himself an engineer.

RE: How's this for respect?

If I am not mistaken, here in Nashville, over at Vandy, they have a dual degree w/ a masters in ME and a MD.  They work in the bio eng field w/ replacement hearts joints etc.
John

RE: How's this for respect?

More info

The Department of Biomedical Engineering is in the School of Engineering. In addition to the M.Eng., M.S. and Ph.D. degrees, the faculty supervises an ABET (Accreditation Board for Engineering and Technology) accredited B.E. degree program in biomedical engineering for undergraduate students. The department also participates in the M.S./Ph.D. and the M.D./Ph.D. program with the School of Medicine.

John

RE: How's this for respect?

If he's in the SF bay area he is most likely trying real in some of those EE from the Silicon Valley....stricking a similarity is my guess

RE: How's this for respect?

"Frankly, I think an MD with an engineering degree is damned awesome" ...

as McCoy said, "damn it jim, i'm not a mechanic"

RE: How's this for respect?

The question is, is he offering engineering services to the public? If so he needs a PE. If he is just telling people he is a degreed electical engineer and is not offering engineering services to the public I think he is ok..Nothing wrong with telling folks what your degrees are.

So is offering lasik surgery a form of engineering service? If so he needs a PE.

-The future's so bright I gotta wear shades!

RE: How's this for respect?

In numerous states, probably including California, it is against that law for anyone to refer to themselves as an engineer unless they have a PE. You are not an engineer because you have a college degree, you are an engineer when the state licenses you. I'm sorry that this offends people, but its the law. If you feel that a college degree is sufficient to classify one as an engineer, then change the law to reflect this.

RE: How's this for respect?

2
EddyC-

I agree with you.  However, it is not against the law to say you are a degreed engineer if that is what you are.  Beggar said, "Harvard MD and degreed electrical engineer".  Nothing wrong there, that is what he is.  Do you propose that anyone with a degree and not a liscense take the fifth amendment when asked their credentials?  In no way is performing lasik surgery a form of engineering service.  Sure its a gimmik, but its a stupid ad.  He is just letting everyone know he is a smart cookie, I think this was Beggar's orginal point.  Kinda like being able to fly the plane AND design it.

RE: How's this for respect?

I have been told that if a person is an officially licensed professional engineer (PE) and something goes wrong with one of his designs, he may be held personally responsible for any damages which might be awarded in a legal proceeding.

On the other hand, if he is merely a guy with an engineering degree, the corporation he works for assumes all legal responsibility for any mishaps.

Is there anyone with both a JD and an engineering degree who can confirm or deny the accuracy of what I was told?

Perhaps the engineers who refuse to get a PE have a reason for their inaction. Who wants to volunteer to be sued in today's toxic legal environment?

RE: How's this for respect?

BitTwiddler

I think you are correct in most cases but a PE can/ should buy professional liability insurance for such cases.

But yes a PE means that you take responsibility for your actions and thus are rewarded with the title "professional engineer".

RE: How's this for respect?

But, there are a lot of PE's, myself included who never stamp anything, and unless the design is stamped and signed then there is no more liability for the individual than for anyone else with an engineering degree.

-The future's so bright I gotta wear shades!

RE: How's this for respect?

Exactly what is the incentive for an engineer to become a licensed PE?

It seems to me that the arguments for and against getting a license are:

Pro:

1) If you are an independent contractor, you might be legally required to have a license to bid for some jobs.

2) It sounds impressive and looks good on a resume.

Con:

1) It takes time and money and a bit of hassle to get the license.

2a) If you do anything which only a PE can do, then you can be sued and lose everything you own unless ...
2b) ... you buy professional insurance.

3) Most "engineering" jobs don't require a license.

If you don't have a specific reason to get it, a PE license seems like a waste of time and money (including insurance money).

I recently read that marriage rates in the US have dropped by 50% since 1970 because of fear of the costs of divorce. This seems to be another case of people shying away from making a commitment because the legal risks are huge and the practical benefits are minimal.

RE: How's this for respect?

Are we looking at this backwards?
Shouldn't we ask how many engineers went on to become MDs?
Come on guys and gals, what's more important?

JMW
www.ViscoAnalyser.com

RE: How's this for respect?

BitTwiddler,
I hope you aren't discouraging engineers from going for their PE. In structural engineering (building design), anyone without a PE or SE is at huge disadvantage in the job market.

RE: How's this for respect?

Huge disadvantage means being in the "junior engineer" classification regardless of number of years of experience, though there are exceptions.

I know of a few who started out as manual drafters who were motivated enough to learn to perform structural calculations.  They have obvious limitations as an engineer without formal engineering education from universities; however, within certain bounds, they outperform and even mentor new graduates.

I agree with SacreBleu that licensure is essentially mandatory for a "normal" structural engineering career.

RE: How's this for respect?

Working in the manufacturing end of the industry, I would never consider a PE. I do believe that it is an unnecessary personal risk, and well, as Groucho said,

"I wouldn't join any group that would have me as a memeber."

Professional lisensure, while I recognise it as a necessity for many subspecialties (like building industry) is not, or should not be the distinction of an engineer. Engineering is a verb not a noun!

I know a few Professional Engineers (my dad being one) that couldn't engineer their way out of a paper sack... and Quite a few (ie... the romans) that never had lisenses yet were able to build structures that have held up thousands and thousands of years...

RE: How's this for respect?

Engineering may be a verb but I don't know anyone who took a test to become an engineering.  I do know people who took a test be become an engineer (noun).  


  

RE: How's this for respect?

"Quite a few (ie... the romans) that never had lisenses yet were able to build structures that have held up thousands and thousands of years..."

Yeah, but the legal penalties were harsh enough back then to make overdesign the right way to go.

RE: How's this for respect?

Quote:

I do know people who took a test be become an engineer (noun).

Last night my wife and I were watching television. Animal Planet had a program about a monkey who scored a 1550 on the SAT.

Just because you can pass a test doesn't mean you can do the work(v.) we do.

Vooter, maybe we should instead of bringing lawsuits against Engineers and Architects that design buildings that fall down, we should Hang them in the streets or at the very least run them out of town... tarred and feathered... on a rail.

RE: How's this for respect?

Engineering is the direction of the manipulation of physical sciences to a useful purpose. Anyone can be an engineer, license or not, degree or not. It is absolutley untrue that one have a license to be an engineer. Most full professors who have provided the methods by which we engineer today were not and are not licensed, yet it would be wrong to say they are not engineers while use what they have taught us to carry out or designs. Some of the best engineers from whom I have learned are welders, carpenters, crane operaters and superintendents.

If one practices engineering commercially, ie provides design services for a fee, then either they or asupervisor in the firm must be licensed. This insures the buyer that the desin was perfomed or supervised by a reasonably competent engineer.

Finally, if the Doc is a degreed engineer and proud of it, I say great and so much the better for all of us. No one has suffered and the engineering community has gained.

RE: How's this for respect?

", maybe we should instead of bringing lawsuits against Engineers and Architects that design buildings that fall down, we should Hang them in the streets or at the very least run them out of town... tarred and feathered... on a rail."

I'm for it.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources