×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

(OP)
Dear Colleguages,

One of our daily office tasks is designing members in wood framed buildings for gravity forces. This is a labor-intensive and time consuming job. For steel buildings, we use Ram-steel to analyze and design the gravity framing quickly and efficiently. If anyone knows of software for gravity design of wood frame structures please let us know.

Chung-Soo
cdoo@sdesf.com

RE: Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

I haven't checked it out yet but check out WoodWorks at:

www.woodworks-software.com

they also advertise here:  www.awc.org

RE: Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

I have tried WoodWorks, and did not like it.  HOWEVER, I only tried it a few times.  It seems like a quality program, except I felt the learning curve was quite high.

I don't think WoodWorks does complete framing systems.  For quick beam or joist sizes (even columns), try TJ Beam.  Trus Joist also makes a program called TJ Expert which will do complete gravity systems, however, I don't think Trus Joist makes the TJ Expert program readily available.  Couldnt hurt to ask, though.

RE: Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

RISA 3D also performs wood design to US practice and is smart for modeling.

RE: Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

Try STRUCALC.com It does a lot for a small cost

RE: Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

pylko - We've been thinking about WoodWorks for some time, waiting for the right project to come along before investing in it.  The literature we've gotten appears to indicate that it does do framing systems (as opposed to single beams or joists).  Was it a real deep program with lots of issues to remember? Was it black box?

Most of our wood design is either by in-house spreadsheets or by RISA 3D (per ishvaaag).  RISA is just now developing area load generation similar to RAM.

baueng - does STRUCALC do framing systems or just single member design?

RE: Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

JAE
I see your comment
"Most of our wood design is either by in-house spreadsheets".
All of my work is wood design in CA.
I looked at woodworks and feel the interface is too...
I've written Some VB apps and would like to exchange and/or see what your spreadsheets have to offer.
Please eMail me some of your wood spreadsheets.
WoodGuy@builderspost.com

RE: Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

JAE - It was quite an in-depth program that had all the bells and whistles associated with wood design.  The few times I tried the program was to size a few beams and headers with various sloping uniform and point loads.  It took me about 20 minutes to get the results for one beam, where as the TJ beam program sizes me a beam in a minute.

I'm not saying Woodworks is a terrible program, just that it'll probably take you a while to learn it and get used to it, while TJ Beam was almost childs play.  (And TJ beam will do solid sawn for you, also!)

One other thing - You can only install Woodworks on one computer.  If you have one guy in your office doing wood design, your OK.  If you have 10 guys, forget about it.
TJ Beam can be on any/all computers.

Do I sound like a TJ Beam salesman or what?!  Sorry for the biased post!

RE: Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

pylko - thanks....Yes, you sound like Smiling Sam, the TJ software salesman.  Just don't stick you foot in my door.

Does TJ have a website?

RE: Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

ctruax-
Not trying to be stingy, but our in-house stuff is the company's property and I can't since they aren't my own to share.  Sorry.

RE: Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

JAE - Now that I'm ashamed to admit it; Yes, Trus Joist does have a web site.   www.tjm.com

Honestly, I'm not a TJ sales rep!
I prefer steel, not wood!

RE: Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

One other thing - The TJ-Xpert program is only available for retailers and distributers of TJ products.

RE: Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

For wood structures, as an alternative to Woodworks, you  could contact KeyMark Enterprises, Boulder CO. They do have a system that will lay out structural members and (I believe) size the beams. www.keymark.com

RE: Software for Wood Frame Analysis/Design

As a follow on to the above items on wood design software I would like to suggest WINWOOD from Archon Engineering. This program is excellent value for money and is quite versatile. Trusses and beams are included along with connection design. The timber design modules in ENERCALC are also quite good if you desire a quick beam, column design check. Diaphragms and shear walls are also included.
The following links apply.

www.enercalc.com

www.archoneng.com

Regards

Mike  

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources