×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

(OP)
We ae fabricating a vessel where in the shell and the head material is to be SA 516 Gr 70 N 1/2" thk. The heads are to be hot formed . The head manufacturer does not have SA 516 Gr 70 plate in Normalized condition. What he proposes is thta if the heads are hot formed in the normalizing range that should suffice.

We are having same problem with the vendor from where we are buying the shell. He is proposing to normalize the plate before forming and carrying out the mechanical test.

Is this acceptable as per code

Merzi

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

Per the ASME SA-516 Specification, plates under 1.5" in thickness can be supplied in the hot rolled or hot worked condition. For plates 1.5" and over, the plates must be supplied in the normalized condition unless specified by the Purchaser. So, your supplier would not have normalized plates at 1/2" thickness.

If the plates are ordered with notch toughness testing requirements, then the plates shall be normalized. This would apply to your 1/2" thick plates, as well.

If your application requires notch toughness testing, the plates need to be re-heat treated after forming to be in the normalized condition per the Specification unless you specify otherwise. Plates that are hot worked and air cooled after hot working are not considered to be normalized. This is a separate heat treatment step.

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

One minor correction to my post above is that plates 1.5" AND under can be supplied in the hot rolled or hot worked condition. Plates over 1.5" must be supplied in the normalized condition after hot working.

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

However, I think metengr will agree that it's perfectly acceptable for the head manufacturer to normalize the heads and state so on the documentation he supplies you.  These days it's becoming more the norm to purchase 'green' plate and heve it normalized by a sub processor due to the extreme shortage of materials and backlogs at the mill furnaces.  We have a situation right now where we're buying 3" SA 516-70 as rolled and having it normalized by a local heat treater for just that reason.

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

weldtek;
Yes, I totally agree with you.

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

We've had the same question crop up in Australia.

Due to compressed schedules on one job, the head pressing subcontractor proposed to hot form at normalizing temperature. I was doubtful that it complied and doubtful about the control of temperature.

But, they were able to demonstrate enough temperature control and accuracy and the right soak time to satisfy the requirements. We also took a coupon from where the nozzle was going to be installed and had full mechs done to prove that the plate had normalised properties.

One issue with re-heat treating already pressed heads/rolled plate is distortion. On another job we experienced some significant warpage and the heads were barely salvagable... luckily we had a fair bit of green trim length to allow us to deal with the warping.

Thinking a bit more outside the box, could you weld up a vessel with the as rolled/pressed steel and then heat treat the whole vessel at normalising temperature??

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

robsalv,
One thing that comes to mind is that normalizing temperatures are usually above the upper transformation temps, so that would be an essential variable for the WPS/PQR in ASME IX.  Perhaps a materials guru could comment further.

Steve Braune
Tank Industry Consultants
www.tankindustry.com

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

Two answers to the above posts;
1. Normalizing is a separate operation to assure uniform mechanical properties. If hot working is performed, and the piece is held immediately placed back in the furnace after hot working in the normalizing temperature range (without cool down that typically occurs during hot working) this would be appropriate. The concern that I have is that during hot working, the temperature may dip below that for a proper normalization heat treatment, and as such, one might not get the desired mechanical properties (including impact testing).

2. The problem with welding the vessel on as-hot worked material is that someone has to assume responsibility that the shell and head components were supplied in accordance with the appropriate ASME material specification for heat treatment. If the fab shop that supplies the material components and fabs the vessel has ASME qualified welding procedures (including those that would be qualified with a normalization heat treatment), this could work within code requirements. However, I see no reason why anyone would want to fabricate a vessel out of as-rolled material and risk significant distortion during a normalization heat treatment to meet the ASME material specification requirements.

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

Merzi,
I don't think anyone addressed your question about the shell being fomed with plate that has already been normalized.  Since shell rolling (in the range of 1/2 inch)is usually done cold, I see no Code issue involved.  It is acceptable to roll and weld such a shell w/o further heat treatment.

Steve Braune
Tank Industry Consultants
www.tankindustry.com

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

As per ASME code,what is the time of normalising per inch thickness of plates.

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

The Code does not specifically get into that kind of process detail. For most applications, 1 hour per inch of material thickness, with 15 minutes as the minimum for conventional heating methods. Material heat treatments like normalizing or annealing tend to follow the same time/material thickness as with PWHT requirements in the Code.

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

I believe normalizing falls into the ASTM specification,
so if it is not listed in Sec II-A SA516 and SA20, you have to find mats spec in ASTM
When the head mfr normalizes the mat to form it and if certifies with statement: per UCS___
"the material has been normalized" you are okay.
I will follow up with Code par.

ER

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

GenB;
Most ASTM/ASME ferrous material specifications do not specify a normalization time at temperature, only a minimum normalization temperature.

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

GenB... it's UCS-79

Steve Braune
Tank Industry Consultants
www.tankindustry.com

RE: Normalizing of Sa 516 Gr 70 plates

If you need documentation from the head manufacturer that the heads were normalized, as part of, or subsequent to the forming operation, reference to UCS 79 is not sufficient.
The head manufacturer must describe any heat treatments the material undergoes.  Typically their documentation includes a statement detailing the applicable heat treatment.  

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources