×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

High temperature application material
3

High temperature application material

High temperature application material

(OP)
We have a high temperature heat exchanger application and would like your comments on material selection. The mean metal temperatures is about 1540°F. We are trying inconel as a material and find we get very thick tube sheets. If anyone used materials around these temperatures please give your comments.
Thanks in advance.

RE: High temperature application material

Inconel is a trade name for a family of Ni based alloys.

What kind of corrosion issues are you facing?
Traditional solid solution strengthened alloys like X or 625 simply do not have much strength above 1400F.
If you really need more strength then you need to use an age hardened aircraft alloy.

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Corrosion never sleeps, but it can be managed.
http://www.trenttube.com/Trent/tech_form.htm

RE: High temperature application material

(OP)
EdStainless:

 The main reason for using the inconel is because of the temperature. The fluids used are high temperature exhaust gases from methane combustion with some chloride gases like HCl.

 What is an age hardened aircraft alloy?

Thanks.

RE: High temperature application material

Can you provide more information as to the process involved with this heat exchanger design?  Material selection is based on various service conditions besides operating temperature.

In general, I would recommend only using ASME B&PV Code, Section II material. Does this heat exchanger fall under ASME B&PV Code, Section VIII, Div 1 requirements? At your stated mean metal temperature, your material selection for a tubesheet will probably be limited to materials with a maximum design service temperature of 1650 deg F. I believe ASME SA-564 Ni-alloy forging specification would be your best option for tubesheet material.

Under SA-564, the maximum design temperature for UNS 06230 and UNS 08810 is 1650 deg F. Again, I want to stress that you need to review all potential high temperature corrosion mechanisms that would influence final selection of material for the tubesheet.

RE: High temperature application material

The ASME Specification is SB not SA, a typo on my part.

RE: High temperature application material

(OP)
Metengr:
 The process fluids are flue gases from burning exhaust gases with natural gas. It is a mixture of various gases, CO2, CO, N2, H2O, HCl, CH4, etc. The gases on the shell side operate between 1600-1400°F, the tube side gases are between 100-800°F. the objective of the heat exchanger is to heat the tube side gases up to 800°F. We calculated the mean metal temperatures to be ~1500°F on both shell and tube.
  Our material selection is to be for both the corrosive environment because of chlorides and the high temperature. The unit will be under ASME code.
  We are considering materials like SB166, SB 167, SB 564,  as there are different forms required for us - plates, tubes and pipes. But the stress values are less at these temperatures and gives unusual thick tubesheets.
Thanks.
  
    

RE: High temperature application material

We have a similar situation on a nitric acid plant on what is called the turbine gas heater.  
The tubesheet temperature is kept within reason by 12" thick cast monolithic insulation on the hot side (shell side) of the tubesheet.  The tubes are shielded at the hot gas inlet by a corrugated skin over the tubes.  The tube bundle shell is a boiler.

I'll try to get the exact MOC tomorrow.  

They have a name for this type tube bundle and I have seen pictures of this type on the web.  
 

RE: High temperature application material

asv80;
I would agree with unclesyd that some type of shell side refractory may be your best bet to reduce exposure to gas side temperatures so than your mean metal temperature of the tubesheet is kept as low as possible.

RE: High temperature application material

(OP)
unclesyd:
  It would be great if you can give more information on the insulated tube sheets. Thanks

RE: High temperature application material

I have seen high temp heat recovery units, it is a delicate balance between strength and corrosion resistance.
Insulating the TS is a good idea.
Do you know what sulfur levels you will be dealing with?  I presume you will have some excess air, so the application will be oxidizing?
What diameter tubes are you looking at using?

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Corrosion never sleeps, but it can be managed.
http://www.trenttube.com/Trent/tech_form.htm

RE: High temperature application material

Heat Treating magazine publishes a list of High Temperature alloy suppliers

We usually start with High Performance Alloys 800 472-5569  Try Scott of Jerry Pyle.  

Thomas J. Walz
Carbide Processors, Inc.
www.carbideprocessor.com

RE: High temperature application material

(OP)
EdStainless:
  Sulfur levels are not known (may not be present, main corrosive gases being chlorinated compounds). The tube size is 1".

tomwalz:
   We will contact and see they can suggest materials for our application.

Thanks

RE: High temperature application material

You may wish to explore using Inconel Alloy 617 for this service. Contact Special Metals for particulars.

RE: High temperature application material

I have been promised the materials list tomorrow.

This particular bundle had a internal floating head. The cold gas comes in through the a pipe that straddles the tube bundle centerline and traverses  the bundle to the internal head and is returned through the tubes and into the external head and then sent to the HP side of the unit.  The exit conditions are 250 psig @ 1250?F.  The external head is also jacketed and is part of the boiler.  The tubesheet is about 24" in front of the entrance of hot gases from the burner chamber which allows the insulation to be effective in keep the hot gases of the tubesheet.

The tubesheet as stated before is insulated by standing the bundle vertically and a 12 wide band is tacked to the tubesheet to serve as a mold.   Several injection nozzles are arranged around the periphery and one of the following materials is pumped in or poured in from the top.

Fiberfax QF-180 and LDS and GPS Moldable and Pumpable.

http://www.unifrax.com/web/UnifraxHome2.nsf/AllDocuments/9398CB1B895D1C6C85256C71004C76F2?OpenDocument

Dale Johnson @ Plibrico (863) 519-5044 has handled all the insulation jobs.   

RE: High temperature application material

(OP)
unclesyd:
   thanks for the description. would you have any sketches of the unit that will make better understanding and other sources of reference.

RE: High temperature application material

I got some pictures (3) and try to find a place to park them where you can see them.

The tubes are Inconel 800 and the tubesheet is 800HT 3.75" Thick

The original tubesheet was 321 SS and didn't last very long.   

We can try this
Go to
www.winkflah.com    The albums name is tubesheet and the password is “insulation”

RE: High temperature application material

Hello out there!

Did this link and sharing thing work?

unclesyd

RE: High temperature application material

unclesyd;
It did not work for me. For some reason, this link had re-directed me to a free-print-share-photos.com web page with Kodak advertising and software. I could not find your file.

RE: High temperature application material

metengr,
All the trouble I had getting the pictures I've got to show them to somebody.

The website is: www.winkflash.com  
The album is name is "tubesheet" and the password is "insulation".
 

I typed it instead of copying it, bad.

Its a digital photo storage and print type place that my granddaughter uses for us to see and print her kids pictures, of course at our expense.

RE: High temperature application material

(OP)
unclesyd:
  How do I find the album. Is it the username and password? Thanks for the trouble to find the pictures. You can email me the pictures also.
Thanks.

RE: High temperature application material

asv80,

I think you have to sign on (free) then you can get access to the shared album. The album is named "tubesheet" and the password is "insulation"
I'm trying to find out if that is the correct way.

RE: High temperature application material

(OP)
unclesyd:
   I got a username and password. There is a tab to view friend's shared with friend's username and password. I tried tubesheet/insulation but does not work.
Thanks

RE: High temperature application material

The album is under unclesyd38  password et2005

RE: High temperature application material

(OP)
unclesyd:
thank you very much. I was able to look at the pictures.

RE: High temperature application material

This bundle is a later model where the insulation at the tubesheet is boxed in and not open to the process.  The bundle is a tight fit in the shell.  When it is inserted if needed there is a layer 2600°F ceramic wool wrapped around the insulation box close to the tubesheet and tied with Inconel or 310 wire.  There is still some hot gas circulation in this area as the whole shell is boiler. This is done to keep the temperature gradient within bounds on the shell and flange.  

The shinny insulation covering is used to help keep the exit process gas in the tubes from getting too hot.  The gas entering the tube bundle at the perforated plate is in the range of 1500°F - 1750°F.  The isulation doesn't cover the entire bundle. The boiler generates 650 psig steam @ 750°F

RE: High temperature application material

(OP)
unclesyd:
 thanks for the added information.

RE: High temperature application material

One added piece of information this is one of the bundles made in our Fab shop.   This bundle has just been refurbished at a local shop under our supervision.  

The inlet gas nozzle coming through the visible tubesheet exits at the inside tubesheet.  All the expansion is taken up by an bellows seal at the inside tubesheet.    

RE: High temperature application material

There is an article in this month's Advanced Materials and Processes magazine on high temp alloys written by Richard Frank of CarTech covering their Pyromet and Waspalloy age hardened series of alloys. just perusing the tables shows the following as possibles from a retained strength point of view, corrosion will be another issue and you might want to consult with Cartech for particulars:
 Pyromet 80A  41 ksi at 1600 F
 Waspalloy B  75 ksi at 1600 F
 Waspalloy A  76 ksi at 1600 F
 Pyromet 41   78 ksi at 1600 F
 Pyromet 720 109 ksi at 1600 F


Mind you these alloys are not cheap by any stretch of the imagination and they may not be available in tubing. Your milage may vary.

RE: High temperature application material

(OP)
rorscharch:
  Is it possible to get the article?
Thanks

RE: High temperature application material

(OP)
unclesyd:
  thanks for your insights but unfortunately the is project dead from our end. But, now I know a starting point to look in the future. Also, can you let me know who constructed the unit.
thanks for your efforts.

RE: High temperature application material

You need to contact Dr. Jack Sparks at the following company.  They are quite familiar with the construction of insulated tubesheet exchangers.    

http://www.serfinc.com/index.htm

RE: High temperature application material

(OP)
Thanks unclesyd.

RE: High temperature application material

If you want a copy, I'm sure CarTech would be happy to give you a reprint. If you are an ASM member, you can download the article from ASM's website in PDF format.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources