×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)
2

4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

(OP)
I am trying to source two items:

  -  250 HP, 4160V, 3 ph, Ex-prf motor (D1Cl2, F&G), and
 
  -  Soft starter for above (does not have to be Ex-prf).

For motors, I have found US Motors, Reliance, GE and Continental.

For Soft Starters, GE, A-B, ABB and Saftronics.

Anyone know of any others out there?

BK

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

Benshaw, in Glenshaw (Pittsburgh) PA is a large supplier of MV Soft Starters.

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

why should i use a softstarter in motors if using a frequency converter can have the same results
(how economical and why) one more new engineer or pretend to be one.

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

(OP)
We asked exactly the same Q when we rec'd the RFQ, but have not as of yet rec'd an answer.  

Indeed, for the application involved (a conveyor) we see every reason to make it a frequency converter, and have tried to communicate that point.  

As you likely know, eng-types are too often outnumbered by bureaucrats, and there are indeed consequences.  (We are neither the customer or the project engineer.)  We are including a letter with our bid that states that a freq drive might be a better choice, from both a control eng / functional and economic viewpoint.  I just hope someone both reads it, and can analyze and act upon it.  They might just award it to whomever is lowest bidder, or offers brand names that they are comfortable with.  C'est la vie.

BK

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

been finding out in some books and all i can come up with is either soft starters be used where we neen to start a motor(big)and after that no did to var the speed cos they work with a const load for a long period of time,

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

but how is that economical? (maybe only the capital of instaling the drive?)

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

(OP)
By reducing the speed of the conveyor, both less waste and spillage of the conveyed product (coal) and fewer starts and stops would result.  The difference in cost (or savings) either way, are miniscule compared to the long term benefits.  

All of which is a moot point if the analysis is done from a short-term budgetary standpoint.

BK

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

Bk mine is a Q also,am having the same problem let the engineers or cosumers help

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

MV Soft starter suggestion: If you have a good relationship with GE, ABB, Siemens, Toshiba, Saftronics, or Schneider, they all have MVRVSS starters. The "guts" (electronics) of all of them are made by Motortronics, who also sell under their own name as well.

As to VFD vs RVSS, the main reasons are economic to be sure, but not just in the initial 10:1 capital cost ratio (yes it is that much different). If you will NOT be varying the speed, the VFD will cost more to operate as well. Losses on the VFD often offset energy savings when running at speeds over 90%, especially on constant torque loads such as conveyors. If it does not need to vary, gear reduction and soft starting is much more economical and reliable.

The only times a VFD should be considered are when constantly varying speeds will improve the production or efficiency rate of a system, or where starting power is so severely limited that it must be kept at 200% FLA or lower (depending upon loading).

"Venditori de oleum-vipera non vigere excordis populi"


RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

Check-out Benshaw at www.Benshaw.com MV starter from 2300VAC to 15 KVAC

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

(OP)
Thanks, I took DickDV's suggestion, and we are in contact with the Benshaw people.

BK

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

Would like to suggest another brand of MV soft starter upto 15kV - called LaserV -mfg by company in Houston called OEM.  Uses different technology versus some other other brand in the market.

http://www.oilfieldelectricmarine.com/laserv.html

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

Just a small correction, AB/Rockwell soft-starters do not have motortronic "guts", we have our own.

Generally for conveyor applications tach feedback is recommended.  However soft-starting a conveyor has greater risk as it is harder to ensure consistent starting condition. You may request a motor starting study from a MV soft-starter or motor vendor to determine the worst case situation of trying to reduce voltage start a motor with a fully loaded belt (which affects the inertia and load torque profile).  

The benefit of using a VFD is that becomes a none issue and you have inherent speed control during production.

Check out www.ab.com/mvb for MV soft-starters and VFD.

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

In conveyor applications the starts are frequent and can reduce the life of motors / switchgear. If the intent is to minimise the same, use of fluid coupling that can delink the motor and brake the conveyor when ever there is a trip command to the conveyor is ideally suited.

Coneveyors are high inertia loads and VFDs are not particularly suited for the application.

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

MVRockwell,

"Just a small correction, AB/Rockwell soft-starters do not have motortronic "guts", we have our own."

Read the post more carefully, I never said they did. I do however appologize for leaving you off the list.

Short education on MV soft starters for everyne else.
There are really only 5 true "manufacturers" of MV soft starters available in North America. Motortronics, Allen-Bradley, Cutler Hammer, Benshaw and Solcon (from Israel). All others (including the one from OEM in Texas who uses Benshaw), are using the electronics from one of those 4, mostly Motortronics. Cutler Hammer used to brand label the Benshaw, but has since switched to their own design, leaving TECO as the only other supplier branding their design. Nobody that I know of brand labels the A-B unit, Solcon is brand labeled by Magnetek and several european names. Aucom in New Zealand supposedly has a design, but has yet to sell one.

Many of the brand label arrrangements offer good value to the end users because they can be easilly incorporated into lineups of new or existing MV switchgear and/or sold as part of a motor/controller/switchgear package where system responsibility can be beneficial. I only brought this up to point out to the OP that there is more to the picture than a single source.

"Venditori de oleum-vipera non vigere excordis populi"


RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

since rraghunath mentioned fluid couplings, I would also mention magnetic couplings for a cushioned start and fixed speed, or adjustable speed drives for cusioned start and  speed control.  These components are price competitive in this horse power range at 4160V.

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

jraef

Small correction about OEM in Texas - checking with OEM, was told that electronics from from Altrom - not Benshaw.
Agree with all you other comments

RE: 4160 softstarters and motors (ex-prf)

Huh, learned something new today...
They used to use the Benshaw starter inside of the GE Limitamp structure. looks like they went their own way too.
I assume you meant Alstom?

"Venditori de oleum-vipera non vigere excordis populi"


Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources