Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
(OP)
Just taking a poll of everyone on what to do for a swimming pool bathhouse. This is a stand-alone building with masonry load-bearing walls on conventional footings and an interior slab-on-grade.
The issue is that in the winter, the building is not used and is open to the weather - unheated. It has a roof over everything, but no insulation.
We are concerned that the slab-on-grade will possibly heave and have wrestled with using a flowable fill under the slab for some depth, or using a uniformly graded granular fill for some depth to minimize heave.
Is this a valid concern and what options could be used?
The issue is that in the winter, the building is not used and is open to the weather - unheated. It has a roof over everything, but no insulation.
We are concerned that the slab-on-grade will possibly heave and have wrestled with using a flowable fill under the slab for some depth, or using a uniformly graded granular fill for some depth to minimize heave.
Is this a valid concern and what options could be used?






RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
I also like using 4'-0" of non-frost susceptible fill. I would also isolate the fill from the surrounding soil with a geotextile to keep it from becoming contaminated. This does not mean it won't freeze, in fact I have read that it freezes quicker than other soils. The thing is that it is designed not to heave.
I assume that there are toilets and this is why any amount of heave is not acceptable because it can easily break pipes or crack fixtures. I also would not want floor mounted urinals/water closets as they would be more susceptible to cracking then wall mounted.
I hope this helps!
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
In extremal cause is possible to use thermal insulation of soil surface (for instance styrofoam for geotechnical application).
jb66
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
jike: I guess I wonder about using insulation - there isn't any head except from the ground below; I've seen it done for heated structures, where you have a close, direct, source of heat.
jb66: When you say "ribs" do you mean thickened slab strips, say about 12" deep and 12" wide or so? Please elaborate.
joemarch: You are right - a structural slab is way too expensive for this application.
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
I assume this is a small stand alone bathhouse and it does not contain a swimming pool as jb66 mentioned.
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
Here is some info I sent to someone else that asked me about this before, maybe it will be of some assistance.
http
http
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
I thought thickened slab strips, sorry for my english. These strips could be in spacing cca 8´x 8´, 12´´ deep
and 6´´ wide. If the slab would be reinforced with mat near of upper surface and the "ribs" as well (it is enough one strip of the mat vertical in the middle ), so I suppose that this may be solution.
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
Example of a recommendation for this is as follows:
"Expansive soils require special foundations. The old standard slab-on-grade won't do. Instead, pier and beam foundations are the new standard in Colorado. Basically, concrete pillars are set down onto bedrock. Then concrete beams are placed atop the piers. A thick cardboard spacer can be placed under the beams so that if the soil heaves, the spacer will be crushed but the floor won't move. The walls, especially in finished basements, are separated by 2-4 inches from the concrete slab with small spikes for the same reason."
If money is the main issue (when is it not) and you cannot sell a floor like this to the client, then I would put a disclaimer on your work that covers your butt.
I have not read this Tech Manual, but you may get some useful info that can be applied to your scenario.
http://ww
I would maybe reach out to a Geotechnical professional in the area, as they know the soils and specify specific slabs and pavement all the time. I would be careful with this one especially because you are using load bearing CMU walls, which will crack badly if you get some differential settlement or heaving. This will be a big visual to the owner that something is amiss in addition to slab issues.
Good Luck ! Simon
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
And it will have footings below the recommended frost depth, right?
Unless the soil is suspect or there will be a lot of vehicle traffic on the slab, why do anything? 8 feet of air will provide sufficient insulation to prevent frost heave. It is rare for frost to penetrate deep into soil unless there is vehicle traffic on it which is obvious on many northern roads.
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
Also, no expansive clay issues. An no, we will not set the dang thing on piers - way too expensive for this type of project.
I just get the feeling that a good layer of drainage gravel would do the trick, with minimal conditions where the slab is supporting anything...ie. free to heave a bit...but not too much.
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
BTW, these are called French Drains. French are always smart people.
Ciao.
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
Ohh....thats why they say I am half-witted <grin>
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
But with, say, 24" of granular fill under the slab, shouldn't that avoid most frost heave problems.
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
The whole issue seems like something a geotech should have input on, but I figure there must not be one for this project.
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
I would like to see what this one has to say
htt
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
RE: Unheated Building with Slab-on-Grade
I am starting a project in Coastal Maine (Hancock)in July. The soil is silt-clay-sand and is high (1/4 mi off coast, 72 ft elevation) with ledge rock all around. Ground water at 20".
We are doing a full 8' basement with walkout and 5-7 feet of backfill, full perimeter drains in & out to a daylight discharge on slope (covered with rock and hay to mitigate freezing), floating slab, 2 Piers for center columns (slab floats around lally columns. I've asked the contractor his opinion and from experience he stated that yes, slabs can lift, and that he can't guarantee anything. We decided adding 4-6" of stone under the slab will allow room for water to flow and/or provide some room to freeze. We'll also provide construction joints or score the slab into quarters.
Here's the beef. The residence will be weathertight by winter, but will NOT be insulated or heated. I'm told the soil generally stays @ 40 degrees F but have decided not to apply exterior insulation to the Foundation to allow the heat from ground to "warm" the unheated space thru the winter. Outside air temps can go below 0 but average 10-30 as lows.
Is this a cause for concern to heave the first winter? In subsequent winters, the house will be insulated, but still unoccupied. Perhaps a supplement of (2)100 watt bulbs will do the trick in the future, but what about the first winter?