×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Cubical Expansion Coefficient for Themal Expansion Calculations
4

Cubical Expansion Coefficient for Themal Expansion Calculations

Cubical Expansion Coefficient for Themal Expansion Calculations

(OP)
I am currently sizing a PSV which is situated on the discharge of a heat exchanger. The relieving fluid is cooling medium i.e. 75%potable water/25% MEG. Based on API standards, I have sized a rupture disc to prevent against tube rupture and process gas breakthrough. Therefore,the only credible scenario for sizing the PSV is the thermal expansion case. However, I am unsure of what value I should use for my cubical expansion coefficient for the 75%potable water/25% MEG cooling medium. The calculated gravity is ~5 oAPI and API521 suggests using a coefficient of 0.0004oF-1. However, if the cooling medium is 100% water, API suggests a cubical expansion coefficient of 0.0001oF-1. As this value is directly proportional to the required relief rate, it has a large effect on the outcome. This may mean a larger valve than required will be installed.

As the mixture 75%potable water/25% MEG, can I take a weighted mean for the cubical expansion coefficient i.e. say 0.000175oF-1? Does anyone know a standard which documents cubical expansion coefficients for MEG/water mixtures?

RE: Cubical Expansion Coefficient for Themal Expansion Calculations

thermal relief being what it is, how can you claim that it drastically affects the valve sizing? What areas are you comming up with?

RE: Cubical Expansion Coefficient for Themal Expansion Calculations

(OP)
I agree that the thermal relief rate will not drastically affect valve sizing.

However, the required relief rate is directly proportional to the cubical expansion coefficient.

Q = (B*H)/(500*G*C)   API 521

where Q= Thermal relief rate, B = cubical expansion coefficient, H= heat transfer rate, G= specific gravity of the fluid and C= specific heat of the fluid.

If I assume 100% water, API 521 states I should use a cubical expansion coefficient of 0.0001oF-1.The calculated gravity for the cooling medium is ~5 oAPI and API521 suggests using a coefficient of 0.0004oF-1. This will give me 4x the required relief rate which in turn gives me 4x the required area.

Taking B=0.0004oF-1, I have calculated an orifice size of 0.08sqin. The basis is conservative and acceptable. Assuming 100% water will probably only marginally reduce the size of the relief value due to the standard sizes provided by vendors.

However, I have another similar scenario. I am back-calculating to determine if a selection of PSVs have been sized correctly for the required relief rate. The same issue has arisen. The PSV has sufficient capacity based on 100% water (B=0.0001oF-1) but does not have sufficient capacity based on the 75%water 25%TEG mixture (B=0.0004oF-1). I have very limited information from the initial design calculations. If I can determine the actual expansion coefficient for the cooing medium it may prevent a PSV change out.

RE: Cubical Expansion Coefficient for Themal Expansion Calculations

2
BE1980:

If your tube rupture scenario is your worse case (capacitiy-wise), then you have protected the heat exchanger shell side.  Don't waste any more time trying to calculate the expansion coefficient and the amount or rate of shell-side liquid that could determine the theoretically correct orifice size for the thermal expansion case.  It isn't worth the effort.

The instantaneous rate of liquid expansion will be safely taken care of by a 1/2" or 3/4" thermal relief valve - and you don't require any calculations or documentation as per OSHA regulations.   I guarantee it; I've done this hundreds of times on safety relief valve projects here in the Texas Gulf Coast for well-known and world-recognized chemical processing plants.

 

Art Montemayor
Spring, TX

RE: Cubical Expansion Coefficient for Themal Expansion Calculations

i basically agree with Montemayor that this is an exercise that is typically not needed.

but to approximate the volumetric coefficient of thermal expansion, see the 5th edition of Perry's pg. 3-227, eqn. 3-3 which is:

beta = (rho1^2-rho2^2)/(2*(t2-t1)rho1*rho2)

if you have density information of the materials you are using over an expected temperature range (typically the case), you can approximate it with the above.  "rho" is my way of saying density ("rho^2" would be "density squared") and "t" is the corresponding temperature.

i don't think the 6th edition has this equation.

RE: Cubical Expansion Coefficient for Themal Expansion Calculations


To BenThayer.

I don't have access to Perry VII. Nevertheless, I've checked that formula in view of β = (1/V) (ΔV/ΔT).

If we carry on by replacing 1/ρ1=V1 and 1/ρ2=V2, and instead of 1/V we write 1/Vave, we get the above-quoted formula assuming 1/Vaveave=(ρ12)/2.

I think a more correct approach would be using

1/Vave=1/[(1/ρ1+1/ρ2)/2]

With a final simpler result:

β = (Δρ/ΔT)/ρave

BTW, I've checked both formulas for water over a span of 1oC and over a ΔT = 10oC, and found that both give equal results up to the third significant figure.

Would you care to check the formula I got ?




Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources